Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Org]

What makes you think that? Just because he's laughing at you?

There are several possibilities I can think of. Night Action. Vote from previous day. Votes you placed on the previous day.

Cant be me.

[Bandages]

So I'll ask you two more questions. The first is this: How many games of mafia have you played? This is not a perfect measure of your experience since it really depends on the person on how fast they pick up how to play mafia, but it should give me a good idea.

I think 3 beginners games. Two were I was lynched first night, one where I was lynched second day I think? I'm in one other game by redwarrior which has... just stopped updating after night one... I'm still not familiar with a lot of the logical arguments that are common in mafia, but I am trying my damn hardest to learn.

The second is this: What made you decide to throw away your caution and vote me? You've been stressing your role as a reason for your reluctance to vote, so why did you decide I was worth it?

It feels to me like you are using some pretty iffy reasoning, and are very set in causing me to fuck up at some point so that everyone will think I'm scum. Anyone who is that set on getting the first person they're suspicious of lynched, enough that they wouldn't even bother questioning anyone else, comes off as pretty scummy. I'm not ready to reveal my role yet, but if you're town and you prove it, my vote won't condemn you. I'm just highly suspicious of your actions.

I'll likewise answer any of your questions, if you point out which ones you want answered. I don't really want to do quote for quote sparring. While fun, there are better ways to go about scum hunting.

Fair enough. It's hard enough organizing the quotes in my posts, especially when I only have like 10 minutes between orientation courses.

As for questions:
Who are your other suspicions and why?
What do you think of Org's general silliness? It's vaguely reminscent of Toony's in a way.

[Jim Groovester]

So I'll ask you two more questions. The first is this: How many games of mafia have you played? This is not a perfect measure of your experience since it really depends on the person on how fast they pick up how to play mafia, but it should give me a good idea.

I think 3 beginners games. Two were I was lynched first night, one where I was lynched second day I think? I'm in one other game by redwarrior which has... just stopped updating after night one... I'm still not familiar with a lot of the logical arguments that are common in mafia, but I am trying my damn hardest to learn.

Hmm. That's not a lot of experience. I'll unvote you for now; I think you're just new, and not scum.

As for questions:
Who are your other suspicions and why?
What do you think of Org's general silliness? It's vaguely reminscent of Toony's in a way.

I've said repeatedly I suspect Toaster because of a hunch based on very little evidence. Anybody else I haven't been able to get a good read on, because they haven't posted all that much.

About Org: This is pretty standard for Org. Frustratingly reticent. Consistently unhelpful. It'd be nice if he tried to scum hunt once in a while, or gave his suspicions without prompting. Are you reading this, Org? HINT MOTHERFUCKING HINT

Pandarsenic: Are you going to do anything in this game besides complain about how your role is secret?

Jokerman-EXE: I don't recall you saying anything in a while. What are your suspicions at the moment?

[Jokerman-EXE]

Jokerman-EXE: I don't recall you saying anything in a while. What are your suspicions at the moment?

Been watching you and Bandages go at it. At first it seemed like Bandages was being pretty damn scummy, but as it went along I sort of see him more as a newbie and less as obvscum.

This new thing with Bayer/Org bears watching, but other than that I don't have any major suspicions.

Mr.Person, I might have missed it but who do you think is scummier out of Jim/Bandages?

[Mr.Person]

Jim. I haven't noticed anything Bandages has done as being scummy.

[webadict]

Vote Count
------------------------
ToonyMan -
Toaster -
Lonewolf I -
Mr.Person -
Jim Groovester - Bandages,
Org -
Jokerman-EXE -
abculatter_2 - SirBayer,
SirBayer -
Bandages - Pandarsenic,
Pandarsenic -

Not voting - Lonewolf I, Toaster, Mr.Person, Org, Jokerman-EXE, abculatter_2, Jim Groovester,

Day ends on Wednesday 9 PM Central.

[Org]

Sir Bayer seems glad that innocents lost a vote.
HINT SMOTHER FUDGING HINT

[Jim Groovester]

So just because he's laughing at your situation you think he's scummy?

[Org]

Yeah kinda.

[Toaster]

Org:  Why are you not attacking Bayer if you think he is scum?  You didn't even vote him without a comment, like you usually do.

Person:

Which do you think is more likely? According to yourself, they can't both be scum.

At this point he had already voted Bandages and said:

Bandages, you're my top pick for scum

Why are you asking what is obvious?

You then go on to defend Bandages in both your posts today, while attacking gently tapping Jim. 

Further, I missed your subtle rolefishing D1:

It's still best if we just go along like a normal game, but if anybody has a role that needs to be claimed, do so now.

Your actions condemn you, Mr.Person.

[Mr.Person]

So you're saying I'm scum because I wanted clarification, I don't think Bandages is scum, and I gently reminded everyone that it's ok to claim alone before MC?

[Toaster]

No, I think you are because you're being very passive, defending someone who can defend himself, rolefishing, and also not really attacking anyone.  Do you think Jim is scum?  If so, why aren't you voting him?  If you don't think so, why aren't you finding someone who is?

[Org]

My vote means nothing really, other than the implication that I am voting him.

[Jim Groovester]

Those red letters still carry weight even without the force of a vote behind them.

SirBayer: While I'd love to wait for abculatter_2 to show up so that you can speak again, what are some other thoughts you have about the game so far?

[Org]

Bayer.