Huh, necroing a topic by 120+ days produces a warning message. Now I know. I feel it's justified though. The Skyrim thread is still Bethesda General, but there's so much to discuss about New Vegas specifically.
At least among my group of friends, the ethical dilemmas at least have lead to literally hours of impassioned debate. Only one of us supports the Legion, and only to be laughably evil. Otherwise it's pretty much NCR vs enlightened player-run dictatorship. (Though *all* of us sympathize with House, he isn't quite our first choice).
I'm the NCR loyalist, and I may as well make my case. Yes, the NCR has issues. The weight of its bureaucracy has led to corruption and inefficiency, which have led to unjust deaths. Of brave NCR soldiers as well as locals. The NCR is expansionist, even to its own detriment. This cannot be denied.
But this is because the New California Republic is dedicated to bringing civilization back to a broken land.
New Vegas is a powerful state, with precious natural resources in the form of the dam. But could it really stand on its own? If the Bear or the Bull withdrew, wouldn't the other be able to overwhelm the securitrons and destroy Mr House's utopia? Maybe, maybe not. There's not enough information to say.
But there's no need! New Vegas already operates practically as a NCR state. It sends energy to the west, and receives protection in return. While maintaining a powerful military force of its own which ensures it is respected at the bargaining table. This arrangement is stable, even if the securitron army is never expanded. The NCR could probably win, but doesn't want to face the cost and public outcry of overwhelming New Vegas with troops. New Vegas doesn't want to be weakened or crushed, particularly with a vicious horde to the east diametrically opposed to its every ideal.
So my hero decided to support the NCR. Though... the death of Mr House, was... One of those things that logically must happen, for the greater good, yet will haunt her every night forevermore. Because he was a good man, who also dreamed of building a shining new world out of ash. Not to mention a genius, possibly the only good person to prepare *before* the bombs dropped.
Evil people of the old world prepared, of course. The... Enclave. Perhaps my perspective is skewed, but I played in this order:
Fallout 2
Fallout 3
Fallout 1
Fallout: New Vegas
Fallout: Brotherhood of Steel
And I will never forget or forgive the Enclave's actions in FO2, or before the war. I have yet to confront their craven descendents in New Vegas. I will listen before passing judgement, but they must admit that evil was done.
I haven't even discussed the Brotherhood of Steel, which I consider my foremost loyalty. But I suspect this post is already large enough to start discussion. I especially want to hear from people who disagree with me, because the beauty of FO:NV is that there is no one good side.
(Just one stupidly evil side, why the hell did they make the Legion so evil, they could have been SO MUCH MORE INTERESTING)