Lonewolf: It depends on which of his accusations you mean. Am I new? Yes, I am. I played like crap day one, and I intend to make up for it now. I was (clearly) wrong on my suspicions of him. It appears he's always that defensive. Am I scum, what you probably meant? No, I am not. Day one I didn't have any leads, so I tried to ask probing questions to get some. All I got was a bust.
Was that what you were looking for?
Janus:
I'm dragging ToonyMan into your question, if you don't mind.
Initially I liked Leaf for town. Toony had posts that seemed empty, and Joker had been focusing on Pandar.
During the argument, Toony's arguments became wordier, but not really any better. Solifuge calls him on this, and he quiets back down. Past that he didn't say much at all, but this is where Jokerman takes over. He jumps in on the offensive as Toony is quieting down. Joker does better, and pokes some holes in his arguments. Leaf's defense is decent, but Jokerman appears to have a small leg up on this one.
Joker claims to have originally suspected Toony, but had no problem moving in on his attacker. This smells like it could be a chainsaw defense. Final thoughts? I still feel heavily that Toony is scum, and intend to leave my vote on him. If he dies and flips scum, I'll be reading hard on Jokerman. If he flips town, though, I'll be reexamining Leafsnail.
I'd like to know this:
Jokerman and Leafsnail: If ToonyMan was lynched and flipped scum, would you two be more, less, or equally suspicious of the other?