Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[webadict]

So, you think ToonyMan is the Exterminator?

Isn't that the flavour for a doppkill?  I seem to remember Op killing in the same way as a vig.

I thought criptfeind killed NUKE and vice versa.

[webadict]

Got it:
criptfeind was attacked by both NUKE9.13 and an Exterminator.
Jim Groovester was attacked by a Vigilante.
Mr.Person was attacked by an Operative.

Makes sense, eh? That means the Exterminator is down a shield as well.

[Solifuge]

Ehem.
^{unvote Mr.Person}

I will not excuse that as anything but a lack of paying attention. Tried to pull all the visible and implied details into my cranium, and Critical-Failed my Spot check. Wisdom was totally my dump stat, guys.


At work. I'll get caught up, and review my observations, given the knowledge that Mr.Person was Town.

[Mephansteras]

The Whiteboard
Jokerman-EXE : JanusTwoFace, Pandarsenic
Leafsnail : ToonyMan
Pandarsenic : Jokerman-EXE
ToonyMan : Leafsnail, Toaster
webadict : Org


Day ends ~5pm Pacific Wednesday

[ToonyMan]

I voted Leafsnail for a list of suspicions, I am not being passive.

I'm trying to piece together what happened last night.

Man, can noone else see the scumminess?  ARGH

TOONYMAN IS SCUM

I must be tone-deaf because I don't see anything.  Can you please explain like I said earlier.

I voted Leafsnail for a list of suspicions, I am not being passive.

I'm trying to piece together what happened last night.

Until you come up with real reasons, yes you are.

You need a real reason to attack someone as well, bullshit doesn't pierce bodies.  Bullets do.

I would tell Webadict that the odds of me being Exterminator again would be rarely, but that's a fallacious statement.

[JanusTwoface]

Criptfeind and NUKE killed each other.
Jim was killed by a vig.
Mr.Person was killed by something, it just says he disappeared.

Now Leafsnail, can you give a better explanation than a "look it up yourself haha"?

And Jokerman, you're being my #2 scum right now.

Criptfeind and NUKE9.13 didn't kill each other.  NUKE9.13 protected Criptfeind and set off his War Vet'ness.  A Plasma Bomb killed Criptfeind.  Mr.Person's missing body is the flavor for a dopp kill usually.  They take the bodies to eat them.

... long analysis post ...

So, I say Mr.Person, with a side of Ethereal.Frog.

So... long analysis post and your final result is that one of the three people we *know* to be human is scum?  Good job.

It's possible that you did miss it, but it's sloppy considering how much effort it looks like you put into the rest of the post.

Got it:
criptfeind was attacked by both NUKE9.13 and an Exterminator.
Jim Groovester was attacked by a Vigilante.
Mr.Person was attacked by an Operative.

Makes sense, eh? That means the Exterminator is down a shield as well.

It's possible, but I still don't think that an Operative killed Mr.Person.  Why would they have taken the body?  That could easily have been the dopp kill.  I'm starting to feel like a broken record, but if NUKE9.13 tried to *protect* Criptfeind to look town than it would still have triggered the War Vet (which looks like what happened because of the bullet wound).

unvote.  Need to clear my head a bit, I'll give the thread another good read tonight I hope.

[Solifuge]

Janus, it was nothing but sloppy. I bounce between reasonably analytical to seeming moron, due to rampant absent-mindedness. I'm sure you've noticed this before.

In retrospect, I can see that I was trying to prove to myself a preconcieved notion held over from D1, that Mr.Person was scummy. I went into my analysis of the prior day with that conviction, and it colored my investigation. When I got to the end of it, I was trying to pick out who I most suspected from among those people, and it was Mr.Person.

To be frank, it was pretty damned retarded. I sometimes find myself hillarious.

[ToonyMan]

Ah, Refuge in Audacity.  Sweet sweet audacity.

[Toaster]

You need a real reason to attack someone as well, bullshit doesn't pierce bodies.  Bullets do.

Oh really?

Leafsnail, who do you think is scum?

I voted Leafsnail for a list of suspicions, I am not being passive.

I'm trying to piece together what happened last night.

Criptfeind and NUKE killed each other.
Jim was killed by a vig.
Mr.Person was killed by something, it just says he disappeared.

Now Leafsnail, can you give a better explanation than a "look it up yourself haha"?

And Jokerman, you're being my #2 scum right now.

Who's doing the bullshitting again?  All you're doing is making me more sure.

[Solifuge]

Stupidity =! Audacity. :/

In fact, I am quite aware that choosing such a tactic would get you killed, as personal experience has told me. Either way, should this turn into a fatal slip, I'll try to make the best of it I can.

Anywho, contribution time:
Nuke = Killed by Criptfeind, War Vet.
Criptfeind = "Was obviously protecting himself from Nuke," Killed by Exterminator (or Plasma Bombed).
Jim Groovester = Killed actively by Vigilanti.
Mr. Person = Killed actively by Doppleganger (or Abducted).

Given that a Plasma Bomb takes precedence over other kill flavors, and that all night kills are simultaneous (thus everyone involved would have been Bombed, and not separately shot), I'm inclined to believe that the Exterminator/Operativen did a regular kill. The "grenade with silver shards" flavor may have been to differentiate the kill from standard Exterminator, hence Operative. That implies that the Exterminator used a different power last night, and may still have a Plasma Bomb.

[ToonyMan]

Quoting people and telling them that "this is scummy" is bullshit.  You can learn how to do that from Leafsnail.

[Leafsnail]

Quoting people and telling them that "this is scummy" is bullshit.  You can learn how to do that from Leafsnail.

Hey, ToonyMan, why are you voting me again?

Again, look at ToonyMan's normal behaviour.  Then look at this game.

The man's scum, people.

[ToonyMan]

I hadn't heard from you in awhile and I wanted suspicions.  I thought I answered this before.  It also has evolved into the fact you OMGUS'ed me and now are being stupid scum with false logic.

You did the exact same "look he is scum" for the third time now as well.

[Jokerman-EXE]

@Leafy: Do you have any concrete proof? Because honestly, he seems the same to me. Maybe I haven't played enough games with him, but I don't see any difference yet.

@Soli: I'm not quite sure I follow you on your analysis of the night actions. Admittedly, I don't really understand the whole Alien element of the game. Can you explain harder, or should I just read it slower?

@Toony: I'm still waiting on your reasoning for why I look like scum to you.

[ToonyMan]

Too much intuition and you were buddying Org.