Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[ToonyMan]

Yes it is.

[webadict]

And I can prove through rational reasoning why saying there's a cult would be worse off for me if I were cult.

Assuming I was in a Cult or the Cult Leader: by bringing the attention of a cult, I make any Cops with neutral readings bring about members of my cult. It also allows others to meta argue the difference between Days for behavior. If I had not done that, I could assume the disguise of a Mason Group and hide from suspicion as well as avoid the Mafia, which would also be my greatest concern.

Your other argument would be if I were another type of scum trying to cover myself. Possible, but then I still wouldn't be cult, and there aren't any non-cults that convert players, making me still fall under the category of town, since you gave information showing me as Town.

Indeed, I'd still look Town without mentioning it at all, since I could continue converting or being in the cult since you mentioned I was town.

Or does that make zero sense?

[Cheeetar]

I didn't ask for a replacement in this game? My bad. I do need one of those.

And your* only argument is the WIFOM. Not much of an argument if you ask me.

Fixed.

Your reasoning: Your second argument doesn't make much sense to me. It's confusing.

Jokerman: Who do you think is most likely to be scum/cult? Explain.

[Solifuge]

Cheeetar, lets not get petty with the spell-checking.

Your other argument would be if I were another type of scum trying to cover myself. Possible, but then I still wouldn't be cult, and there aren't any non-cults that convert players, making me still fall under the category of town, since you gave information showing me as Town.

It took me a moment, but I see what you're saying here. At first, I thought you were trying to use circular logic to confuse others; yes, if you were a non-cult scum player, you would be a type of scum that is not cult. But without a cult or an alignment-swap, that would preclude you, given the Anonymous Tip that suggested you were town as of Day 1. Therefor, you are either a Cultist trying to create a grand ol' WIFOM, or have an ability that suggests the presence of a Cult. I doubt you would do something this risky as a Cult Leader, but as a recently indoctrinated Cultist you might try to either protect the leader, or yourself depending on if the gambit came to light.

At any rate Web, you say you gained this anti-cult ability last night though. Was it gifted by someone with an alias, or merely something that you were informed of?

[Cheeetar]

Jokerman: Who do you think is most likely to be scum/cult? Explain.

[Jokerman-EXE]

I'm not entirely sure. I don't even know what Cult entails.

[Org]

Are we sure there is a cult?

[ToonyMan]

Are we sure there is a cult?

I haven't seen anything that points to it.  I only said, "You." because only somebody asking the question would know if such a thing existed.

[Org]

Are we sure there is a cult?

I haven't seen anything that points to it.  I only said, "You." because only somebody asking the question would know if such a thing existed.

What.

[ToonyMan]

You are a great help Org.

[Org]

I do not understand.

[ToonyMan]

Can you please explain what you don't understand?

[Org]

Are we sure there is a cult?

I haven't seen anything that points to it.  I only said, "You." because only somebody asking the question would know if such a thing existed.

[ToonyMan]

You.

Referring to Cheeetar.

[Org]

You.

Referring to Cheeetar.

Kay. Cool.
I was like, what.