Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Nolor]

Nolor, I see two problems with that.  One, we can't be sure Char even did send in an action- he was that inactive.  Two, it could have been Jokerman he investigated- even though he died in the night, he would have been a valid target.  Web may have had no information at all.

I didn't even consider the possibility that Jokerman was investigated. Actually, that makes more sense now, looking back. Web would know to confirm someone if he had investigated them. It's too bad; I thought we had finally found something concrete.

Even tossing aside the investigative results, though, we should still put some faith in web's judgment. I'm willing to bet that either Blarg or Siquo is scum.

Cript's claim of doctor is pretty interesting, and rather gratuitous for scum to make at the time. Usually though, each side is limited to one power role in Beginner's Mafia (at least if I remember the rules correctly).
Org, can each side have multiple power roles? Also, votecount please.

Blargityblarg, what do you think of Cript's accusations and his claim?
(I thought I voted him this morning, but apparently I forgot)

[Org]

Votecount
--------------------
Criptfeind-Blarg, Toaster
Blarg-Nolor, Criptfeind

[Siquo]

Org, when does the day end?

Nolor answered ok, as did Toaster. Now... I'm still undecided. Both Cript and Toaster are making a good case.

For now, I'm going to go with Cript, for the reasons stated earlier. Cript, you're now doing a double OMGUS, implying both people who vote for you are scum. I'd love to believe that you had more valid reasons than just "them voting for you".
You name Toaster as Blarg's partner, why? You specified no reason, therefore I can only assume OMGUS.

[webadict]

Org, can each side have multiple power roles? Also, votecount please.

Each side has two possible power roles: Town has Cop and Doctor, Scum has Godfather and Roleblocker. There can only be one of each in any game.

[Org]

Org, can each side have multiple power roles? Also, votecount please.

Each side has two possible power roles: Town has Cop and Doctor, Scum has Godfather and Roleblocker. There can only be one of each in any game.

Go away. You are doing it wrong.
You can Town IC since LEAFYBOY HAS LEFT.

[Leafsnail]

I don't know if I even agreed to be in the restart :/.

In any case, feel free to replace.

[Org]

Oh.

:/

Sorry

[Org]

Org, when does the day end?

Nolor answered ok, as did Toaster. Now... I'm still undecided. Both Cript and Toaster are making a good case.

For now, I'm going to go with Cript, for the reasons stated earlier. Cript, you're now doing a double OMGUS, implying both people who vote for you are scum. I'd love to believe that you had more valid reasons than just "them voting for you".
You name Toaster as Blarg's partner, why? You specified no reason, therefore I can only assume OMGUS.

DAY ENDS THURSDAY AT 9:30 PM UNLESS EXTENDED.

[Criptfeind]

You name Toaster as Blarg's partner, why? You specified no reason, therefore I can only assume OMGUS.

Because honestly looking though the game he came runner up, but just barely above the rest, I don't know that he is scum but it seems most likely.

[webadict]

I can't IC. I just answered a question that had a clear answer.

[Toaster]

Cript, I find your claim weak.  It relies on scum picking you out of the remaining townies to block.  Why you?  You were the least active of all D2, except maybe Knight.

You name Toaster as Blarg's partner, why? You specified no reason, therefore I can only assume OMGUS.

Because honestly looking though the game he came runner up, but just barely above the rest, I don't know that he is scum but it seems most likely.

That's a non answer.  If you have questions for me, ask.


However...

Let's not forget something very important- we're at lylo (Lynch or Lose.)  If we lynch town today, scum wins.  Here's my view- with two scum, they are likely voting for the same person, unless two of the town are voting for the third.  It'd be silly to bus a partner at this point.  I started this day thinking cript/Siquo, but the voting pattern today doesn't hold that up.  Honestly, I haven't suspected Nolor at all, really.  Now I am not sure what to think.  Hence, I will unvote.

Blarg, Siquo:  Please clearly detail your suspicions of criptfeind.  He's right on one thing- you didn't really ask him anything.

Cript:  Do you think newbie docs act scummy?  Also, see first part of post.

Blarg:  You FoS Siquo and hit him with a question, but he never responds, and you don't push him on it at all.  Why?  (Question below:)

Also, Siquo, why are you asking Diablous' replacement why Diablous didn't vote yesterday? He won't know.

Nolor:  If Web hadn't suspected Blarg/Siquo, would your vote change?  Do you agree with my assessment of scum vote pair?

Siquo:  You missed the last part of my question from my last question block.  Did Blarg's answer satisfy your question?  Are you two just prodding each other with no regard for the actual answer?

[Blargityblarg]

Toaster: Your link to my 'answer' post details most of my suspicions. I didn't ask him anything, but I accused him. I'd have grilled him some more if I didn't get distracted by Web/Char.

What does FoS mean? Sorry for my jargon illiteracy. I didn't press him on it because I got a reasonable answer from him that corresponded well with Leafsnail's explanation.

1: He attacked web really hard for no reason.
2: He lurked day one but than popped up on day two
3: Web died after beating him down.

1) I attacked Char after web replaced him, for suspiciously huge lurking, unaware that scum usuall don't get replaced for lurking. Web's answer did not make any sense to me, so I switched targets to Web himself.

2) I've already explained this once today; To reiterate: My change of tactics is more me getting into the swing of the game- I decided that to learn to play this game, I had to actually play it, so I did.

3) I can hardly defend the actions of the scum, but I'd like to disagree on the 'beating me down' point. I didn't respond to his final post, but only because I didn't get on between then and when Night began. I was ready to continue arguing.

[Siquo]

I just asked Cript a question. The answer is unsatisfactory.

Blargs answer was, kind of, and I presumed the question you quoted was rhetorical; he was right, there.
Blargs answer is here, by the way, not the one you posted. Toaster, you're now either making shit up, or not reading the thread at all.

Hell, I'm not sure of my vote either, but we've got to do something.

Request Extension, because it's lylo and I'm still unsure. And a nolynch is a lose as well...

[Blargityblarg]

I'll throw my vote in for an extension as well.

[Blargityblarg]

Also, Siquo, your link doesn't seem right; that's part of my argument with Web, and is all response to him. Toaster posted the right one.