Ok, since we're at a quandary and since I don't want to choose we're gonna let chance choose for us. I'm using Random.org's coin flipping program. Heads, we do it, tails, we use the mouse. We got heads.
After a moment of thought you decide not to use Reginald and place him several feet away in what you hope will be relative safety. You insert a coin into the game and brace yourself on the cabinet, laying your finger on the start button. After a few deep breaths and an instant's hesitaion you press the button. At first the game seems to boot up as usual, but almost the instant the strobing, pulsing colours begin to appear things go very differently then before. The machine, the room around you and indeed the entire world grow hazy and fragment, disintegrating into static before vanishing entirely. Behind this veil of static lies a starfield and a vast nebula, an endless expanse of glowing ether punctuated with throbing, luminous eyes. You hang, suspended, above a planet you do not recognize in an alien sky. As you stare at the unknown stars you feel as though something is probing your mind, leaving behind bits and pieces of information you don't quite understand. Strangely though, you are at ease with it all and do not fight the unknown, invasive force. You close your eyes.
When you open them again you are standing back in the arcade. As you step away from the machine you notice an extra shadow on the floor next to yours. You turn and come face to gun barrel with the jumpsuited woman from before. She's smiling.
"Die, Chronophage"