I've been having some fun with this game, I broke down and bought it for full price, I missed the 60% off sale by like a day...
It's an awesome game, I have to say. Terrible tutorials, laughable help files, incredibly outdated wiki, a weird mix of great and terrible UI, but I'm a DF player damn it, no fancy graphical game is going to get the better of me!
But yeah, it's a lot of fun. I'm on my third game now, after the first two went rather poorly.
Game 1: What am I, a wimp? I don't need no stinkin' tutorial. Oh, and I read the AI isn't that great, so I'll start on hard mode, cuz I'm a pro at everything! (Builds a crappy spaceport and like 1 research lab, and a couple ships) Ok, my advisors think we should stop paying these pirates, sounds good to me! Hey wait, all my stuff is asplode...
(Do some internet reading, try the laughably useless tutorials)
Game 2: Ok, let's go with normal difficulty. (Does stuff, gets a decently sized empire) Ok, now to crush some of these puny weaklings around me. HAHAHAH!!! (Takes over some weaker races) Hmm, those new refugee guys are really doing well.. oh well, they're on the other side of the galaxy, I'll deal with them later. (Continues a fruitless war against a neighbor) Wow, the AI sure is bad at running wars for me... I guess I'll handle that in the future... (Story stuff happens) Hmm, well I have an alliance with most of the other races and those ancient robot guys, it should be fine, besides this is a story encounter, I'm sure it'll be easy to win. (More stuff happens) Well... those guys seem to be kicking everyone's ass... oh well, I'm sure some scripted event will happen and turn it around. (More stuff) Well! I'm sure dead!
Game 3: Well, screw that story mode noise, I want to just play in the galaxy! And the AI did such an atrocious job, I'll just handle everything my damn self. (Does the things) Hahahah, stupid dinosaurs, your puny colonies will be mine (Blows up the stuff) Hey, what the hell, why are all my colonies rebelling. Oh... I have dinosaurs in my empire too... oh right, that independent world, apparently I colonized a few more worlds with them... now they're all mad because I'm attacking the empire of their race. (Continues with the war, planets continue revolting and re-joining the dino empire) Damn it! (Pirates take advantage of all ships in the warfront, build bases all up in my territory) No! More raids?!? Why is my money so red, anyway?!? ARGHGHGHGH!!!! Fine, no more war, as long as you dinosaurs will be my subjugated slaves. (Ends the dinosaur war, having ended up with 1 of the 3 planets originally conquered)
So that's where I am now, trying to build the infrastructure I should have had in place before I started this war. Also, my stuff periodically just blows up because a nearby empire is really mad at me and apparently has really good intelligence agents. I also now realize the error of my ways when I just went to the expansion planner screen and just colonized every available world. As a result, my empire has a few distant outliers and it takes forever to build a defensive base. My awesome warships turned out to be a little light in the fuel tank department, so now they need to be retrofit...
I'm really liking this game. The usual 4X strategy of wild expansion is punished just like in real life, with logistical problems, rather than artificial silly penalties. The fact that my fleets are way more powerful than an enemies does me no good if I can't keep those fleets well supplied. My explosive expansion looked like it was working really well, until it became obvious that I had stretched myself too thin.
I do wish someone could do a mod to make the UI better. I know there are mods to make it better looking, but I need more functionality. It annoys me to no end that there is no way (that I could find) to quickly check if each colony has a defensive base, I had to actually zoom into each planet and click to see if there's a base. Really?!? They couldn't put a tab under the colony view for space structures?!? I can't be the only person who's run into this.
The galaxy map in general could afford to show a bit more in terms of what's going on in each system as well. At least whether or not there are independent colonies there! That's important and useful info that would be good to have at a glance.
The fact that fleet stances don't work at all against pirates is also really annoying. I know it's because technically you're not at war, but that's a stupid cop out. Yes, fine, that's the technical reason, but obviously if a player tells a fleet to defend a certain region, he means against enemy empires and pirates that he's not in a protection agreement with. If a player commands a fleet to attack bases in a certain region of space, it's a safe bet he wants to kill the pirate bases there too. It's a shame they left this feature half finished (And from what I've read, even in the circumstances where it works it does not work well). If automation is a big selling point of your game, it's a good idea to make sure it actually works...
So, like many games, I really like it, and I'm really disappointed in the devs in some respects. It's just weird they went to the effort to make such a great game, but left so many things in a state of half-assedness. The fact that they advertised that universe would be discounted for people who owned previous titles, then retroactively made that advertised offer a limited time one, really rubs me the wrong way, although I personally wasn't affected, it's just plain bad ethics. In fact, it might qualify as downright fraudulent... So I will be quite unlikely to buy another matrix published game, at least, it would have to be really good, because on top of shady marketing practice, you know it'll be wildly overpriced.
So my review? Great game under the hood, quite bad UI, not much in terms of resources to help learn the game. If you're not willing to put in a bit of a frustrating slog to learn the game, don't bother with this. If you don't mind deplorably awful UIs and shady ass marketing, I'd recommend it.