Nirur Torir's plan wins because he has a level in CaEI, plus it's almost identical to the other one that had two votes, except better.
The villagers spend 2 hours collecting stone. They collect 180 kg.
The villagers spend 2 hours collecting wood. They collect 180 kg. Someone lights a fire.
Nirur Torir crafts javelins for 16 hours. He uses up 16 kg of wood and makes 4 -Javelin-s, 6 =Javelin=s, and 6 +Javelin+s. He gains several levels of Spearmaker!
Luke makes 3 stone knives over three hours. He then hunts for 13 hours, finding 2 kg of clams. (1.95 kg, but whatever) He gains a level in Hunter.
Ein makes a stone knife. He spends an hour butchering the wolf corpse, getting a large wolf pelt, 30 kg of wolf meat (weird, I looked it up and wolves are 38.5 kg max. I thought they'd be 200 pounds), and some remains. At 8:00 AM, he starts cooking the meat in small steaks. He manages to cook 28 kg by 10:00 PM.
Matis trains with his javelin for two hours, getting 40 xp while he waits for ein to butcher the wolf. He cooks some of the wolf meat and leaves the rest for ein. He then trains for 13 more hours, getting 260 xp and two levels in Spear-User.
Grey looks for bamboo for 16 hours, gathering 16 kg of bamboo. He gets 16 gathering xp.
Alex grabs a +Javelin+ and hunts pigeon for 15 hours. His quality-3 javelin gives him a 30% bonus, which translates to 3 hours per pigeon. He catches 5 pigeons and gains a Hunting level. He then cooks the birds for an hour.
Nanoth gathers 32 wood.
Kadzar takes a stone knife and butchers Org. He manages to get 50 kg of human meat, an Org pelt, and remains. The Org pelt is 6 sq. ft. of Org hide. He spends 2 hours making two
Org hide vests for 3 sq. ft. He then laughs maniacally for 13 hours. His throat is very sore.
The villagers spend 1 hour working on the granary. They build 90 kg stone of it.
The villagers gather fruit for 4 hours. They find 54 kg of fruit.
The villagers gather roots for 7 hours. They find 63 kg of roots.
The islanders eat 3 kg of 1-day-old fruit, 2.5 kg of cooked pigeon, 30 kg of cooked wolf meat, and 7 kg of fruit. They'd rather not eat raw meat, but they will if it comes to it.
ATTENTION: You may not be able to prepare for battle if you are caught unawares. Be sure to equip yourself with something to this purpose!