Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Rysith]

The reason is based on a single post because that post is the only post Magmadeath has made all game (except for the single-word post requesting an extension). There isn't anything else to go on.

And I'm objecting to him parroting Webadict's (and my) reasons, not voting for the same person as Webadict.

[webadict]

Hmm, interesting.  The overseer has posted.  The plan looks good, since I'm not a cybrid and the inspection will do nothing to me.

Anyway, unvote:
MagmaDeath does need replacing, but I'm not sure if he needs lynching.  Both webadict and Rysith have jumped straight on him, but Rysith's attack looks opportunistic and odd.  It's like he doesn't want to admit that he's pushing an easy lurker/ flaker lynch, and thus posted a small reason for it.  The reason is based on a single post, and since MagmaDeath obviously can't respond, Rysith must think that post is worth lynching over.

Also interesting to see you're voting someone for following webadict while following webadict.

How can you say he's parroting me when there... is nothing in my reasoning?

Unless you're reading things my mind! My God!

[Leafsnail]

The reason is based on a single post because that post is the only post Magmadeath has made all game (except for the single-word post requesting an extension). There isn't anything else to go on.

So WHY do you want him lynched?  Yes, there isn't anything else to go on, but surely that should make you less sure of his alignment.  The only reason you should lynch someone who needs a replacement is if they're previous incarnation made it abundantly clear that they were scum.

How can you say he's parroting me when there... is nothing in my reasoning?

Unless you're reading things my mind! My God!

No, more for just voting MagmaDeath after you did even though his evidence was a long way in the past.

[ToonyMan]

Unvote.

The CYBRID is Rysith and Dakarian/Webadict is the convert.

[ToonyMan]

also

Extension Extension  Extension Extension Extension Extension Extension Extension Extension Extension Extension Extension Extension Extension Extension Extension Extension Extension Extension Extension Extension Extension Extension Extension Extension Extension Extension Extension Extension Extension Extension Extension Extension Extension Extension Extension Extension

[Mr.Person]

@Mr.Person

The Overseer could be lying.  However, they ARE told whether the Enforcer exists. 

As for your answers, I find it interesting that you believe that since I dislike the way Rysith stopped scumhunting that you assume it to mean I feel that Vector should be attacked.  If I meant to have Vector questioned I'd do it myself, not browbeat folks into doing my work for them. 

The point is that Rysith went into a heavy attack against someone then suddenly stopped in mid stride with nothing to show that he was no longer suspicious.  That it was Vector is a non-issue: it could've been anyone else.  He started to scumhunt, then decided to just plain old stop hunting instead.

..and my suspicion has been proven.  Rysith believes that Vector could be the cybrid but doesn't want to hunt further.  Instead, he's after people who aren't on his side.  I highly suggests that he's NOT the cybrid but a rebel instead.

As to whether Vector IS the cybrid, I don't know.  I'll have to do a scan of her. 

For now, though, welcome back Mr.Person.  You can do more than throwing out comments and shit.  You could actually get to scumhunting. 

For example, can I interpret your post to suggest that you believe I'm the cybrid?  If not then what ARE you doing?  If so then where's your vote?

Even if you were a cybrid, you would be a horrible lynch. There's no point lynching anyone unless they can be the main cybrid.

I'm not even going to bother looking for converts before the main guy. As a prelim, I would say Archangel would be converted solely because I would convert Archangel if I was the cybrid.

I could argue my case, but I know I'm getting killed because I was gone. I dunno why I'm getting killed over MagmaDeath or Apostolic Nihilist, and I'm not going to ask. All I can do is prove I should stick around through actions.

I say we lynch Archangel.

So Webadict, why would we do that? I did just realize that perhaps Archangel is lying about being a guard, but it's possible to prove Archangel's a guard because guards roleblock. So Webadict, why do you want to lynch Archangel?

[ToonyMan]

Oh right. My mistake.

No, not Archangel. Unvote.

I meant MagmaDeath.

Whoopsies.

[Mr.Person]

Eh, not paying attention when I'm assumed to be a dead man. Same question but about MagmaDeath instead of Archangel.

[dakarian]

I don't see Rysith as the main Cybrid.  Web I've already read and I don't get a feel on him as one either yet (the reason I'm not attacking him). 

I have high suspicions about Leafsnail, but he's already being investigated.  Mr.Person has turned unreadable thanks to him being already ready to die. 

Actually, you know what?  unvote.

Vote Leafsnail.  Jumped hard and fast for that slip Web made but decided to jump on the easier target first even when he's suspicious of both. 

If we're going to lynch, we should try to lynch the main cybrid.  It'll give the Investigator less to do but it'll mean one less convert to worry about.

[webadict]

I don't see Rysith as the main Cybrid.  Web I've already read and I don't get a feel on him as one either yet (the reason I'm not attacking him). 

I have high suspicions about Leafsnail, but he's already being investigated.  Mr.Person has turned unreadable thanks to him being already ready to die. 

Actually, you know what?  unvote.

Vote Leafsnail.  Jumped hard and fast for that slip Web made but decided to jump on the easier target first even when he's suspicious of both. 

If we're going to lynch, we should try to lynch the main cybrid.  It'll give the Investigator less to do but it'll mean one less convert to worry about.

I've got an idea.

How about we we protect dakarian with Archangel, and I'll protect ToonyMan, since I'm a Doctor. I just feel like this would be a good idea, since it allows us to block dakarian, who may be a convert (Losing his converting powers), while it leaves ToonyMan still alive and able to use his inspect. Plus, I would like if he would use his power on me tomorrow, thereby gaining us a lot of confirmed peoples.

Eh, not paying attention when I'm assumed to be a dead man. Same question but about MagmaDeath instead of Archangel.

Why would you want him here? He hasn't done anything. Leaving lurkers alive only leads to more lurking.

[dakarian]

That'll work fine with me.

As for Magma...we could decide to use the night kill on Magma instead of Mr.Person.  I'd like the lynch be on someone we can read as scummy, rather than a lurker remover.  Besides, to be utterly practical: if the cybrid is an inactive player, they won't convert anyone so leaving them for the nightkill won't result in one last convert attempt.

[Leafsnail]

I don't see Rysith as the main Cybrid.  Web I've already read and I don't get a feel on him as one either yet (the reason I'm not attacking him). 

I have high suspicions about Leafsnail, but he's already being investigated.  Mr.Person has turned unreadable thanks to him being already ready to die. 

Actually, you know what?  unvote.

Vote Leafsnail.  Jumped hard and fast for that slip Web made but decided to jump on the easier target first even when he's suspicious of both. 

If we're going to lynch, we should try to lynch the main cybrid.  It'll give the Investigator less to do but it'll mean one less convert to worry about.

Ok, dakarian.  This post makes no sense AT ALL.

We're trying to lynch the main cybrid, even though, if I am the main cybrid, I am going to be discovered TONIGHT.  And we give the investigator "less to do"... riiight.  Now, if you are certain that I am the main cybrid (so certain that you're prepared to fuck up the confirmed townie's plan) then why are you so hesitant to vote me?  Surely the "You know what?" bit should've been unnecessary if ou had such a strong suspicion.  I mean... why not just say "I think Leafsnail is scum, lynch him!"?

And your non role related reason is equally crap.

Jumped hard and fast for that slip Web made but decided to jump on the easier target first even when he's suspicious of both. 

Uhuh.  So, if I see a slightly scummy move and a very scummy move I should jump on the person making the slightly scummy move first if they're more experienced?

[GlyphGryph]

Vote Count:
Leafsnail[2] <-Dakarian, Vector
Rysith[1] <- ToonyMan
MagmaDeath[2] <- Webadict, Rysith
Webadict[1] <- Mr.Person

Not Voting:
Archangel, Leafsnail, Apostolic (LOOKING FOR REPLACEMENT),MagmaDeath (LOOKING FOR REPLACEMENT)

1 extension heard from ToonyMan, day extended until 3pm friday.

[Rysith]

How about we we protect dakarian with Archangel, and I'll protect ToonyMan, since I'm a Doctor. I just feel like this would be a good idea, since it allows us to block dakarian, who may be a convert (Losing his converting powers), while it leaves ToonyMan still alive and able to use his inspect.

While that would work in theory, can't Archangel only change his protect once a day, and didn't he already change to Toonyman?

Now, if you are certain that I am the main cybrid (so certain that you're prepared to fuck up the confirmed townie's plan) then why are you so hesitant to vote me?

Active Rebel Roles (Has quickchat, though only organizer starts in it):
Snowman - Has access to the overseers announcement system.

Leafsnail, why are you overlooking some important features of the game that mean that the Overseer isn't a confirmed townie? Why are you hiding behind it as a shield? I'd much rather than we independently decided that the Overseer's plan was sound than attack people for questioning him.

And Magmadeath has been active (today, even), but has chosen not to post in this thread. That's actively lurking, not just being not here, and lurking + buddying + bandwagoning is exactly the kind of thing that you do call people out for, and do vote them for.

[dakarian]

Ok, dakarian.  This post makes no sense AT ALL.

We're trying to lynch the main cybrid, even though, if I am the main cybrid, I am going to be discovered TONIGHT.  And we give the investigator "less to do"... riiight. 

read as "if I am the main cybrid, I'll be found out after being able to make my second conversion before being found out AND it'll give me a chance to convert the Investigator before they tell what happened."

The point to lynching you rather than just investigating you is to stop you from converting another person.  It beats having Magmadeath policy lynched.

Now, if you are certain that I am the main cybrid (so certain that you're prepared to fuck up the confirmed townie's plan) then why are you so hesitant to vote me?  Surely the "You know what?" bit should've been unnecessary if ou had such a strong suspicion.  I mean... why not just say "I think Leafsnail is scum, lynch him!"?

first mention about you is a vote.  That's hesitant?  News to me.  "You know what" refers to not being content with just investigating you when we have a perfectly good day to scumhunt and lynch instead.  In the end, it's bad to just rely on the power roles and throwing away the day game.

And your non role related reason is equally crap.

Jumped hard and fast for that slip Web made but decided to jump on the easier target first even when he's suspicious of both. 

Uhuh.  So, if I see a slightly scummy move and a very scummy move I should jump on the person making the slightly scummy move first if they're more experienced?

Well, if you see an easy lynch and a hard lynch, it makes sense to go for the easy lynch.  You don't seem very willing to go after me or Webadict.  That's how it seemed.

But meh.  I needed a read on you before I let you be settled with an investigation.  I want the lynch to be for the best target after all.  Between your response and what Rysith just pointed out we may have the best option.

@Rysith

Wait, Magma HAS been around?

Ug, unvote

Vote Magmadeath

Ok, that IS active lurking.  That ruins the "absent player won't do their night action" option and is scummy to boot.  Besides, I've gone through my first reads and I'm content here for now.