Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Vector]

...

Oh.  The thing is, it says that if they aren't protected against kills, then I protect them.  It doesn't say anything about their being killed or not, which I think initiated the confusion.

Waiiiiit... no, this isn't like the anti-doctor you're talking about.

It says that if the target it un-protected, then it becomes entirely protected from kills
If it's protected, then it dies

And then, when I asked Dakarian about CPR-doc stacking, he didn't inform me that I wasn't actually one (I suppose he didn't see why I'd be confused).


I'm starting to wonder if the goal is to have everyone action but no one die.  We have an interesting medley of protective and killing roles.

[Leafsnail]

Oh, right.  Then the difference between Anti-Doctor in this case and CPR Doctor would be that a CPR doctor kills someone who is neither protected nor killed.

[Mr.Person]

I'm starting to wonder if the goal is to have everyone action but no one die.  We have an interesting medley of protective and killing roles.

Unvote

I think that would be our best bet. I'll have to check it out later for a detailed plan, but I want to do this.

[Leafsnail]

Well... our roles are

1. Pandarsenic - Redirector
2. Zai - day poisoner whose kills go through at night
3. inteuniso - Doctor (Roleflipped)
4. Vector - Anti-Doctor
5. Leafsnail - Body Guard
6. Webadict - Copycat (roleflipped)
7. ExKirby - double-killer
8. RedWarrior0 - Dayvig SuperSaint (roleflipped)
9. Mr.Person - CPR doctor

The main problem I see is that Zai is a poisoner, and poison cannot be blocked.

[Vector]

In that case, we make a plan and then hammer the hell out of Zai.

[webadict]

I think the bigger problem is that there's a Dayvig Supersaint.

Therefore, that's impossible.

[Vector]

Therefore we make a plan and hammer the hell out of both Zai and RedWarrior0, with the idea of everyone nones tonight.

[dakarian]

Current Vote Count:
webadict[1]: Pandarsenic,
ExKirby[1]:  Leafsnail
No Lynch[1]: Webadict

Not Voting: Mr.Person, Zai, inteuniso, Vector, ExKirby, RedWarrior0

Deadline: Friday, 9pm EST

or

9 alive 5 to lynch

[Pandarsenic]

Guys, I was thinking about this and it CANNOT be that simple. Dak said we still need our daygame, which means we have scum among us and we have to figure out how to deal with them while avoiding them reviving or whatever.

[Vector]

Guys, I was thinking about this and it CANNOT be that simple. Dak said we still need our daygame, which means we have scum among us and we have to figure out how to deal with them while avoiding them reviving or whatever.

Yeah, but Dak also likes pattern-puzzles.  This is a pattern-puzzle, and they've found themselves in trouble by virtue of having the "wrong roles."  Now that we know all the roles definitively (except perhaps Zai's), we know who we have to speedy quick-hammer in the morning.

Why do we need the day-game?  Because we need to find out which roles are which.  We must lynch so that we can trust each other, and we must lynch those who would provide random information.

Please note that RedWarrior0 is lurking even more than he usually does, and that Zai is not only 1. less silly than usual (I hear it is a serious scumtell with him) and 2. did not tell us who he poisoned, ever, or even discuss our plans.

They are both scum, and we need to figure out what to do with them.

[webadict]

Vector, shut up.

Whoever is giving out ideas is basically stealing them from me. Which means they're trying to ring bells. I'm going to see what happens when nothing happens. No actions. Nothing.

[Vector]

Vector, shut up.

Whoever is giving out ideas is basically stealing them from me. Which means they're trying to ring bells. I'm going to see what happens when nothing happens. No actions. Nothing.

We have a day poisoner and a high probability of defection.  That is all I will say before shutting my trap.

Additionally, I formally agree to your plan.

Unvote.

No lynch.

[Mr.Person]

Guys, I was thinking about this and it CANNOT be that simple. Dak said we still need our daygame, which means we have scum among us and we have to figure out how to deal with them while avoiding them reviving or whatever.

Yeah, but Dak also likes pattern-puzzles.  This is a pattern-puzzle, and they've found themselves in trouble by virtue of having the "wrong roles."  Now that we know all the roles definitively (except perhaps Zai's), we know who we have to speedy quick-hammer in the morning.

Why do we need the day-game?  Because we need to find out which roles are which.  We must lynch so that we can trust each other, and we must lynch those who would provide random information.

Please note that RedWarrior0 is lurking even more than he usually does, and that Zai is not only 1. less silly than usual (I hear it is a serious scumtell with him) and 2. did not tell us who he poisoned, ever, or even discuss our plans.

They are both scum, and we need to figure out what to do with them.

I'm curious as to why you see no problem with Leafsnail being the only role that can't kill, directly or indirectly.

[Vector]

Leafsnail's role fits with the doctor/CPR doctors/anti-doctor running around.

Here's the quote from Xylbot:

Bodyguard (town; common; 4+ players): You can guard another player. If that player would be killed, you and the attacker will kill each other instead. Actions: guard

Assuming that's what Leafsnail's role does, he has an indirect killing role, which makes perfect sense given the context of the game.

[Zai]

I would tell you who I killed if I had actually killed anybody. I have yet to use my role.

Feel free to lynch me if that fits into some sort of plan.