Oh, NOW you show up. Took me requesting you to be lynched to get you to try.
1. The piece on Forsaken was less about defense and more about showing how shotty your offense is. Given that it was in place of an actual defense that doesn't look well for you. Forsaken didn't make sense? Funny, you agreed that what he did MADE sense earlier. It's not until you were primed up for the lynch that ALL OF A SUDDEN it NOW looks bad to you.
Guess you were too busy pushing that....joke..trap..nonargument on Jim.
My best argument is deflecting? That's just icing. You already spotted the rest of my argument.
"not doing your usual "So-and-so is scum, but so-and-so might also be scum you usually do." "
I avoid doing that as much as possible. I HATE doing that. I've called people out for doing that! That's scum team building and it burns you more times than it helps.
Even when there's 4 scum around, I focus on 1 or two at a time. You find scum individually, and once you actually FIND one, then you establish the links. Until you do, you push and push individuals till you read them. When you run out of targets you Scan, find others, then push and push until the scum show off.
I pushed AFD until he talked. I pushed Jim until he did.. finally. Now I push you and this time I struck pay dirt.
Btw, the whole role mess: Rolefish mixed with WIFOM. The first bit meanwhile:
Janus was an FBI Agent, correct? Who do you think he examined? Perhaps he did, and perhaps he didn't, but if he had, and I came up scum, wouldn't there be someone calling for my lynch?
Broken Crap Logic. Janus died after scanning. If he scanned you and found you scum, he wouldn't have a chance to speak up unless there's a medium and that assuming he would check you rather than others he suspected, and that's also meaning the medium has to out himself.
Now we get to the argument at hand.
First off: meh to your attempt at a Meta Defense. "no way! My scum game works differently." Your scum game is what you want it to be.
Lack of aggression in my hunts? Aggression how? Wanna give me a valid post here? Because I don't go easy on real hunts.
This marks that everything you've done to Jim was not hunting Jim. Oh? It was a trap for anyone that will vote with you? Let's see now.
AFD: He voted for Jim, and you did
attack him...with only two back to back posts. Although you claim later that AFD fell for your trap when, in fact, AFD had his own reasons which you attacked on. Furthermore, you've done nothing beyond that. Now AFD is back as 'town' even though there was almost nothing to prompt you believing him.
The other who voted for him. Me, who you've said a few times looks town to you..well.. until JUST now were I 'might be' scum, but not because of Jim.
And that is pretty much the sum of your attacks, except for that 'written from the Gibbet' scan.
So no, very little aggression. Perhaps you are right in that you don't go easy on real hunts. I can believe that. Of course, that means you never were really hunting since the game started.
Changing of Day 1 motivation? Do you even speak English? My motivation every Day is to catch scum, you slut! That's everyone's motivation, pretend or not. I don't pretend, because even if I'm scum, I look for ANY scum.
Poor logic in answering that one. The meaning is "changing your stated motivation for the purpose behind your Day 1 actions."
Here you were just making a joke, and demonstrating how you can turn every post into a negative statement.
Here you say that you WERE pressuring him.
Here it's a trap to catch other scum.
Lack of focus toward scum? Uh huh, and you would know whom specifically I'd need to be focusing on, now wouldn't you?
You focused on Jim but, depending on which was the truth, either you were just making a joke, hunting, only to just give up on him without a reason, or not focused on him at all.
You went after AFD but only for a little while and never went back to him (no, spending all your time on me isn't an excuse. You can attack one person and defend against another). You spend a ton of time on me and I was town to you.
So no, you weren't focused on who you think was scum.
And somehow you can berate me for using Day 1 info and use it yourself. You're a class act.
Misrepresentation. I'm berating you for wasting your Day 1, not because you are USING day 1. There were also berates for your actions Day 1 which attempted to make any use of Jim's Day 1 info impossible (since it was a Joke/trap after all)
Lack of reasons for claiming people town? I can claim whoever I WANT as town! I feel like they're town, so I'll call them town. If they're not, then oh well, I was wrong, but I will call them town when and how I want. There's no way you're NOT trying to be so incredibly unintelligent. Almost EVERYONE ELSE has done this and you will only call me out on this?
You yourself say that it's bad form to not suspect anyone. That was a lesson you drilled into the folks of BM3 HARD since they kept calling you town. Townies don't know who is town and who isn't and can't just assume people are one way or another. Just like how you need more than one scumtell to find scum, you need more than just 'a feeling' without a proper read to see someone as town. You've done little to push people enough to find a read at all. As such, you have nothing day-game wise to see them as town.
Of course, there are people who can easily say if someone is town since they know, right at Day 1, who is scum.
And, buddying with Jim? I didn't buddy with him. You just think everyone buddies with everyone. That's the worst argument ever.
Nah. Buddying does happen and regularly. So has the "Attack someone then suddenly pull off to attack their aggressor" ploy. Btw, a quick poke on Exkirby and a direct claim against you is NOT 'everyone'.
As for your new attack on forsaken:
Yes, THAT is a good theory. Now if you had brought it up, say, Day 1 when it was being argued, or along with that Widescan, I would believe that it was your scumhunting. Instead, you just proved that when you make a man that's afraid to die a goal they WILL reach it after a few desperate fumbles.
Of course, you only had time to quickly find something realistic for one person. You don't have anything on Leafsnail and are now looking all over the place for something, some THEORY that would say "See? I can be pro-town too! Look, SCUM SCUM!"
You never had any of that info before. You didn't see ANYONE as scum before. You don't really see them as scum now. You're just talking to get me off your back. You were fakehunting before. You wanted to frustrate to push the attacks away after, and now you just want to put some other bait in front of me..anything, doesn't matter what so long as it is not you.
Fearmongering to end it. My soul is prepared. How's yours?
Author
Topic: Paranormal Mafia - Round 12 - Game Over! (Read 58051 times)