Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[ToonyMan]

I am town in all my games too Dakarian.

[dakarian]

If I could be sure that BYOR has nothing but typical roles that work normally then I could label it similar to Paranormal.  BYOR, though, can be anywhere from purely normal, role heavy, or flat out quirky when you get into roles that mix with one another or where everything runs as a theme.  I took the Liberal route and deemed it Quirky, though I'll admit I probably should've gone more conservative and mark it Role Heavy.

I mean, Toon has a MUCH better chance of going crazy (i.e. slipping a miniDelphy AND a touch of Bastardry to boot). 

Note that ISE is also on the fence, since most of the roles are traditional, but the setup overall, has enough quirks to push it closer to the Quirky rating.

SMALL bit of analysis:

Perhaps focusing on types of games will help balance things out.  Role Heavy gets the most flex since that's always the staple for Bay 12.  Having 1 BYOR and 1 Bastard works well I think.  We should have more Traditional setups though.  As Such, my next game will be Near Mountainous (yes, that means put it on the que).  When I get the green light I'll put that ONE game up.  Next game to go up will be Boot Camp.  Last will be Sudden Death.

[Eduren]

I mean, Toon has a MUCH better chance of going crazy (i.e. slipping a miniDelphy AND a touch of Bastardry to boot). 

The way I understand it, bastardry has to do with the mod actually saying lies and half-truths. I promise none of that in TM6.

[ToonyMan]

Yeah, my mafia games don't have lying.  I think it kills the town anyway.

[Leafsnail]

Sane Cop - You're a sane cop, for real.  Can't have this type of mafia without a honest cop to stop scum like a vig.  You also have to end each sentence with "desu".

EVERYTHING IN THIS ROLE PM WAS A LIE

[ToonyMan]

Not for some people.

[dakarian]

Bastard Mod is technically anything that runs counter to what the players expect.

Bellsounder, for example, WAS a bastard mod.  I didn't lie and actually hid very little, but you don't tend to expect everyone to revive over and over, and you do NOT expect a person to be able to revive THEMSELVES.  You also don't expect the mafia to win by keeping everyone alive.


The cops in the last Toon mafia was bastardly, especially with the quasi-Delphy setup inside it.  I know I heavily enjoyed it btw.

[Neruz]

What are everyone's thoughts on me running MSPA Mafia 2, after first writing up some roles for the newly introduced characters. Everyone seemed to like the first one, and Multipick isn't going anywhere, probably because we're all tired of BYOR style games.

[Org]

I'll be up for it.

[Leafsnail]

What are everyone's thoughts on me running MSPA Mafia 2, after first writing up some roles for the newly introduced characters. Everyone seemed to like the first one, and Multipick isn't going anywhere, probably because we're all tired of BYOR style games.

Sounds good.  Needs some passed around items though, methinks.

[ToonyMan]

What are everyone's thoughts on me running MSPA Mafia 2, after first writing up some roles for the newly introduced characters. Everyone seemed to like the first one, and Multipick isn't going anywhere, probably because we're all tired of BYOR style games.

Sounds good.  Needs some passed around items though, methinks.

I'd be in it, the first one was enjoyable.

[Leafsnail]

Not for some people.

Eh, kinda suspected I was naive from the flavour text, to be honest.

[ToonyMan]

Not for some people.

Eh, kinda suspected I was naive from the flavour text, to be honest.

I gave everyone the same flavor text.

You just all interpret things different hehehe.

[Leafsnail]

So... anyone who got an innocent result got

Webadict is always the best choice to do first night.  Doesn't matter if everyone else does, just matters that you do.  You head to his sea restaurant and sneak around his bedroom.  Him sleeping snugly.  You can't see anything incriminating, so you're going to have to say that Webadict is town.

[ToonyMan]

For roles.