Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[dakarian]

You bypassed the argument.  The issue is that you called me Insane when I found you Guilty and you are 'supposed' to be a miller.  Even IF you called me 'paranoid' once I had an Innocent on myself anyone would've went "well, perhaps he IS sane.  Better tell why he's getting Guilty on me so we can use him."

No matter how it's swung, your claim came far too late to cover you now.

[ToonyMan]

VOTE COUNT:

webadict - dakarian, Apostolic, JanusTwoFace [3]
Apostolic - Vector, Rysith [2]

Not Voting - NUKE9.13, eduren, Webadict [3]

~Day End Today In One Hour~

I'll give you some extra time encase people want extensions.

[JanusTwoface]

I have this sneaky suspicion that giving us an extension would not actually end up with more being done so... No time extension vote from me.

[ToonyMan]

webadict has been lynched!

webadict - Will Smith - M

The game is nearing its end.....

SEND IN NIGHT ACTIONS.  LOCK.

[ToonyMan]

It's the last day, woooo

[Vector]

Hey, folks.  Let's finish this.

I'll start with my cop inspection--I've got JanusTwoFace theoretically cleared as town.

[Rysith]

It's the last day, woooo

Hah, I was right, we are ending on the morning of d6!


Dakarian  | Leafsnail | Eduren  | Archangel | Vector
Web-G     | Web-I     | Janus-G | none      | Rysith-G
Dak-I     | Vect-I    | Vect-G  | none      | Dak-G
Rysith-I  | none      | ?-G     | none      | Web-I
Unknown   | none      | ?-G     | none      | Janus-G
Sane/Rand | Naive     | Para    | Sane      | Insane


With that, assuming that Dakarian is Sane (and town) and Vector is Insane (and town), we've got me and Janus cleared. Unfortunately, we've got AN, Nuke, and Eduren (minus one, assuming Dakarian investigated someone last night) unknown. Assuming that Dakarian didn't hit the final scum last night, that leaves one in two. We can't double lynch, but since we know that there is at most one scum I'd suggest having the two unconfirmed people claim to someone, and work things out from there. Possibly, have the two unconfirmed people claim to multiple people (I'd say three, at least), since with at most one scum three people claimed to would hit at least two townies. Yes, I'm paranoid, but this is mafia.

[dakarian]

just to quickly type:  I found AN as town.

[Apostolic Nihilist]

Thus it's either Nuke or Eduren, assuming all cops are town.
I have an ability that could help here; we can kill the both of them tonight.

[dakarian]

In fact, it's last day.. it IS time to MC.

As heard long ago, I'm a cop and it looks like I'm sane.

[Apostolic Nihilist]

Right, so I'm Billy Bob Thornton -- at night, I can kill someone who complimented me during the day.
Perhaps the ultimate anti-buddying measure, but markedly useless in my hands this game.
It should be as simple as getting them both to compliment me then lynching one of them; I'll take out the other tonight.

[Vector]

Thus it's either Nuke or Eduren, assuming all cops are town.
I have an ability that could help here; we can kill the both of them tonight.

Assuming all cops are town, it's NUKE.  So why don't we kill the dude?

[Eduren]

Ok so I got mafia result on myself. Confirms that I am either Paranoid or impossibly Insane.

[Rysith]

Assuming all cops are town, it's NUKE.  So why don't we kill the dude?

Because I don't think that that's a safe assumption to make.

I'm Bob Sagot, who I'm fairly sure is supposed to be Bob Saget. By acting happy and telling jokes, I can negate up to five votes on me (hence, the suspicion that the game would end d6: with d6, there would be 6 people alive, and I would be immune to lynches, which seems like the only source of kills.)

[JanusTwoface]

Summary
- We may not get a night phase.  ToonyMan just said last day...
- I'm Team Fortress 2 Spy, as I mentioned what feels like years ago.
- If the cops are all town, Nuke or AN is the last scum.
- AN seems more scummy (probably because he's actually posted in the last two weeks).
- If the scum is a cop, then Dakarian is it.  He's not Sane (Archangel was) and Random is somewhat odd to use (I wouldn't put it past ToonyMan though...).
- vote Apostolic Nihilist

There is also the Random Cop, which is almost never used, because it's a bastard role and the randomness of the results prevents any valuable information from being gathered, including ones' own sanity. Games rarely last long enough to determine that results are truly random.

Mod: I'd really like to see Nuke either replaced or mod-killed.  I'd prefer mod-killed, because we won't have a chance to read the replacement, but I understand if that kind of breaks the game.  Also, major bad mojo (read: karma) for whoever keeps track of these things... (dakarian methinks)

Spoiler: Cop logic (click to show/hide)

Updated with new claims:
Dakarian  | Leafsnail | Eduren   | Archangel | Vector
Web-G     | Web-I     | Janus-G  | none      | Rysith-G
Dak-I     | Vect-I    | Vect-G   | none      | Dak-G
Rysith-I  | none      | ?-G      | none      | Web-I
AN-I      | none      | Eduren-G | none      | Janus-G


Things we know for sure:
- Leafsnail was Naive.
- Archangel was Sane.
- There is one scum left.
- These players are still alive: Vector, Rysith, NUKE9.13, JanusTwoFace, eduren, Apostolic Nihilist, dakarian
- We only have one chance left to lynch.

Things we can assume:
- Because Vector got an innocent result on Webadict and a guilty result on me (Rysith and Dakarian, if town, can use the same logic), he is either Insane or Random.
- Because Dakarian got guilty on Webadict, he's not naive or insane.  Because he got innocent, he's not paranoid.  So he's either Sane or Random.
- Eduren got guilty every time.  He's probably Paranoid.

From this, I'm going to say that it feels like we have one cop of each role (Sane, Insane, Paranoid, Naive, and Random).  That doesn't necessarily mean that they are all town though.

Cops (in order of certainty):
Leafsnail - Naive*
Archangel - Sane*
Eduren - Paranoid
Dakarian - Random (because Archangel was Sane)
Vector - Insane (because Dakarian was Random)

Spoiler: Scum logic (click to show/hide)

Assuming that none of the cops are scum, that would mean that either NUKE9.13 or Apostolic Nihilist is our last scum.

I'm actually at the point of asking for either a request or mod-kill for NUKE9.13 (and negative karma, if people keep track of that) because he hasn't posted in a very long time.  If a mod-kill, that would help narrow things down at least.

On the other hand, there's actually a decent case against Apostolic Nihilist...

- webadict named me, Nuke, and AN as scum before dying (he's the type that would put an actual scum in the list)

Thus it's either Nuke or Eduren, assuming all cops are town.
I have an ability that could help here; we can kill the both of them tonight.

- Eduren is one of the cops.  Scum have a tendency to not always think all the way through their scum claims, because they actually know who the scum are, thus they would make mistakes like this.  Could be an honest mistake, but it feels scummy to me.

Right, so I'm Billy Bob Thornton -- at night, I can kill someone who complimented me during the day.
Perhaps the ultimate anti-buddying measure, but markedly useless in my hands this game.
It should be as simple as getting them both to compliment me then lynching one of them; I'll take out the other tonight.

- This sounds like a perfect scum ability.  Just get someone to insult them and then you have a night kill.  Especially when you don't normally get one.

....

Apost, I'm almost 100% certain you're scum.  Why is that?  Well, it's because you're displaying your bonafide scumtell.

When you're scum and being accused, you chop your posts up like this.  When you're town and being accused, you write in nice paragraphs.

Sorry, but I don't buy it.

- Vector thought that he was scum based on posting style.  AN tried to back off once caught, but things like this are a decent way of identifying scum in forum games where you cannot read expressions.

(AN, if you are scum, this is something to really keep in mind in the future... )

So in this setup presumably we have several cops, all with questionable sanities, along with an assortment of other town roles.

I'm willing to trust Dakarian/Vector here; webadict seems guilty.

- Joining a bandwagon against a scum buddy that you were pretty sure was going to die?  You were the third vote, no-one else even had any votes on them at that point.

Anyways, I think I've managed to convince myself that (assuming cops are town) AN is the last scum.