Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Rashilul]

You going to have to replace me...

[ToonyMan]

You going to have to replace me...

As in replaced?  Like.  Replaced replaced?

[Pandarsenic]

Toony said no traditional killing roles, so a mafia member who inspects and then has his results publicly announced would be another way of achieving the same effect.

As for scum... I dunno.  Some people haven't even said anything yet.  Any of my suspicions would just be an OMGUS or overreaction at this point.

Unvote. That's awfully specific, Leafsnail....

[webadict]

I can replace!

[dakarian]

Toony said no traditional killing roles, so a mafia member who inspects and then has his results publicly announced would be another way of achieving the same effect.

As for scum... I dunno.  Some people haven't even said anything yet.  Any of my suspicions would just be an OMGUS or overreaction at this point.

Unvote. That's awfully specific, Leafsnail....

3rd vote.  FOS Pandarsenic

Mind if I ask why that's specific enough for being the 3rd vote, Pandar?

[Pandarsenic]

As I said, he's being very specific. I suppose I'll unvote, actually, because as you've pointed out, that doesn't really feel worthy of vote. An FoS at most, perhaps, depending on if he's right, but nothing much more than that.

It's really a logical conclusion to reach considering how specific Toony was about confirmation in this, so I suppose you're right that it isn't voteworthy.

[ToonyMan]

I can replace!

Alright.  Let me send you his stuff.

dakarian, that doesn't count as a karma loss for Rashilul, does it?  Look at this...
http://www.bay12games.com/forum/index.php?topic=43236.msg833566#msg833566

[dakarian]

Hosts have the power to forgive karma losses.  Even if he would've gained -5, if you felt there was a real reason for it then you can forgive him.

It'll mean he won't get the +1 for finishing, but he won't lose anything either..

[ToonyMan]

Make it 0 karma then.

[dakarian]

Well, furthermore, if you hadn't prodded him and he jumped and said that first then there's NO karma loss anyway.  A request to replace before any prodding results in no karma loss anyway.

So if you had to prod, it's your choice between -1 karma or 0 karma.  If you didn't get to prodding him, then he should lose nothing for it anyway.

In any case, 0 karma it'll be. 

[webadict]

Somebody sum this up for me.

[Apostolic Nihilist]

Hello everyone.  Leafsnail! What do you think the mafia might get to compensate for not having a NK?

Someone who has to end every sentence with desu?

No, not really.  Thanks for not making me, Toony .  On a more serious note, perhaps a conversion?  Or extra PRS?

Apostilic Nihilist, what's up with the lack of avatar and posting?

Well, I had a close encounter with major computer failure earlier today.
Quite unfortunate really; my main hard drive failed and my backup didn't want to work.
Solved the problem with a 6 hour long CHKDSK session though.
Lack of avatar due to all potential choices being hopelessly campy.

Web:
RVS abound. Dakarian calls Rashilul on WIFOM. Pandarsenic finds Leafnsail's specificity striking and votes, when pushed he removes his vote.

I don't see anything major enough to vote for, so RVS engage.
Twiggie:
How do you suppose a thirteenth player will add to this probable cacophony?

[Pandarsenic]

AN, it's hardly "when pushed." I responded to a valid point. I do of course accept requests to stop responding to valid arguments.

[webadict]

Hello everyone.  Leafsnail! What do you think the mafia might get to compensate for not having a NK?

Someone who has to end every sentence with desu?

No, not really.  Thanks for not making me, Toony .  On a more serious note, perhaps a conversion?  Or extra PRS?

Apostilic Nihilist, what's up with the lack of avatar and posting?

Well, I had a close encounter with major computer failure earlier today.
Quite unfortunate really; my main hard drive failed and my backup didn't want to work.
Solved the problem with a 6 hour long CHKDSK session though.
Lack of avatar due to all potential choices being hopelessly campy.

Web:
RVS abound. Dakarian calls Rashilul on WIFOM. Pandarsenic finds Leafnsail's specificity striking and votes, when pushed he removes his vote.

I don't see anything major enough to vote for, so RVS engage.
Twiggie:
How do you suppose a thirteenth player will add to this probable cacophony?

... Wouldn't the added person be town for sure? Since there was three scum to begin with and the number of scum isn't going to change, he is, therefore, a confirmed townie.

I just killed a player that was just added. If he doesn't die, he is an SK or some other third party.

Now, my next question to you, Apostolic, is why didn't you catch this right away, or did you avoid the fact that calling him confirmed would end with him being modkilled? Because that's a dumb fact to avoid, because it's so obvious it should've been noticeable to everyone, so you all need to step it up.

Geez...

[JanusTwoface]

... Wouldn't the added person be town for sure? Since there was three scum to begin with and the number of scum isn't going to change, he is, therefore, a confirmed townie.

Basically, read this: Unexpected Hanging Paradox

So, I think that Toony choose randomly.  There's really no more or less chance of Twiggie being scum than anyone else in my opinion.  In fact, I think that it's vaguely suspicious of you, webadict, for pointing it out.  Scum players often go for *easy* lynches, I think this definitively falls into that category.

For now, vote webadict.