Let me try to make my logic a bit clearer.
Vector is alive
With you on that one.
With all the attention he has been getting, and his "Scumhunting", he should have been targeted.
Not so much.
Take a look at Webadict in BM1. We never targeted him. We didn't do anything with him, even when he tried to eat me alive D2. Why? We thought he'd be the prime target for doctor protection, so we always went after the lower-level people. Your logic is too black and white for this sort of game.
There could still be a doctor who "Got lucky" on the first day, then "Got lucky" again yesterday but I find that rather unlikely.
Becauuuuuuuuuse....
The simple fact that you are alive really makes you likely to be scum. You either are extremely lucky about the theoretical doctor, or you are scum. Apostolic Nililist is probably not Scum, all we really have against him is the fact that he was lurking.
ALL YOU HAVE AGAINST ME IS THAT I'M NOT DEAD. BREATHING IS NOT IN FACT A SCUMTELL, DUMBASS.
The simple fact that you are alive really makes you likely to be scum. You either are extremely lucky about the theoretical doctor, or you are scum. Apostolic Nililist is probably not Scum, all we really have against him is the fact that he was lurking.
Right, so I figure I'll try analyzing everyone since I just realized I haven't been contributing much in this mafia. I've organized them into priorities, roughly.
Vector - He's helpful and furthermore acting extremely pro-town. This is hardly good, as most people have stopped suspecting him. If he's scum, we're in a bad situation. A really bad situation, in fact. I'm not picking up any scumtells, but we need to watch him. If he isn't dead in a few days, we need to start suspecting him a lot more. He should be one of the scum's first targets.
Laetificus - He's somewhat helpful, but he's not pressing people much. His latest jab at tehstefan was his only such in the game. At the very least, he's not active lurking and most of his posts have content.
CobaltKobold - There is little to say -- he's active and pressing people. He probably has the most posts in this thread, actually, and since he's a new player I sort of doubt he's scum. Most scum would be hesitant to put themselves in the spotlight by making so many posts as they figure the more posts they make, the more people can analyze.
RedWarrior0 - Mostly silent. He seems like he's trying to slide under the radar, but it could just be his lack of posts. At the very least, the posts he makes do contain content, most of the time.
SirBayer - Bragging about how dangerous he'd be as scum?... er, anyways. He seems to not like asking questions and is indeed trying to stop or at least avoid them. He's acting suspicious. It's similar to how I acted when I was extremely new and town, so it could just be that. Either way, he's not helping town much as it stands.
tehstefan - He's out of town, so it's a bit difficult to question him. He's posting a decent amount, but he's levying no hefty suspicions. Altogether he seems to be a bit wishy-washy, but he seems to be improved from Beginner's Mafia 3, which is more than I can say about myself.
Org - Org is Org. Lurk. Lurk. Maybe an active lurk here and there. This means he's a great scum, but it also means he's really not dangerous at all. As long as we aren't stuck with him at Lylo, we can deal with him. At the very least though, we should try and stir him up, which is what I was trying to do earlier. He's also an expert at evading questions it would seem.
Org, tell me: Does SirBayer strike you as particularly scummy? He doesn't seem to care much for questions, which is mostly what this game is based around at this stage. He's trying to reassure us that he's town by reassuring himself that he's answering 'completely honestly'.
He was also grasping at straws to implicate me earlier, though I'm not sure why -- faulty reasoning is often present in scum's accusations.
His analyses seems quite accurate for me.
I am not retracting my vote.
Interesting. Let's think about this a minute.
Your counterpart goes lurkylurkylurky and occasionally posts stuff. Okay. Now, what do you do? You show up. You rip posts from Apostolic Nihilist, and that's it... even though most people think he's scum. No one else's judgment, really. No further analyses. Just "Hm, I guess I'll follow Apostolic Nihilist! He looks like a
smart guy."
"As such, I'll try to convince the town to lynch Vector at mylo. Because I, too, want to be a
smart guy."
Let's look at this.
OMGUS
Buddying/"emotional coordination"
Attacking players with no/little evidence
Lurking (Laetificus)
Pushing lynches at mylo
Using evidence incompletely to engender bias (Apost attacks SirBayer heavily; says he's scum. Etc. Didn't like that bit, did you? Afraid of losing your scumbuddy?)
Lack of scumhunting (Laetificus)
Spreading WIFOM everywhere
It's a scumtell bargain sale!
Wake up and smell the cypress. You die tomorrow.
To everyone else, I ask that you consider what I've said. I don't really feel that I can say any more, though if I can answer any questions or clarify any points of my argument, please let me know.
For now, however,
unvote.
NoLynch.
Early day end.
Author
Topic: Beginner's Mafia 4: End - Winter Wonderland (Read 52940 times)