Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[dakarian]

For the first batch of S ranks, the ones that start off S when we begin this thing, we won't use that big system since chances are, we already know who should be up there.

I can probably say that if I were to ask everyone who's been around here "who would be a S rank (if you can't name yourself)" I bet I'd get a decent list of all of them.

In fact, let me just start it off now. 

@Everyone

Who do you believe would be an S rank?

[Leafsnail]

As I said, you, Meph and Webadict would be the ones I'd put up there first.  Alexhans also fufills the "game whipping" requirement pretty well, although it seems that I almost never play in a game that also has him.  Ah well.

[Zai]

Alexhans also fufills the "game whipping" requirement pretty well, although it seems that I almost never play in a game that also has him.  Ah well.

Alexhans would not fulfill an "activity" requirement; he abandoned Paranormal 2 (3?) only to come back at the very end to win the game as scum.

[Leafsnail]

Hmm... that was way before my time .

Wait... there were THREE army vets?  What the heck... the town coulda almost won if it No Lynched every day.

[Zai]

Wait... there were THREE army vets?  What the heck... the town coulda almost won if it No Lynched every day.

...Yeah, I meant Paranormal 3.

But nobody had known that there were 3 of us Vets in that one except Meph. So NLing every day would seem anti-town.

[Leafsnail]

I know it's an old game, but... shouldn't Org have killed Chaoticjosh too?  Eh, never mind.

Anyway, I thought Para 3 was what got Bay 12 into its anti lurker mindset.

[CobaltKobold]

Dakarian: High rank should not require substitutions.
Why?
That means that high ranks require OTHERS to require replacing.

If everyone's super...nobody will be.

Actually, I don't think Meph would be an S rank player- but he would be an S rank moderator.

You might notice that now you're arguing that S-ranks are, basically, more skilled at playing(/acting) town.
Solid S Players:
Bookadict
Drakonian
ChAoTiCjIm
Cheap Drink
maybe S players:
alex-chan (...except for the flake of Para3, would be definite S-rank)
arRay
apostatic nihilist
CinnabarSkulker
Cobrarsenic
Solidly A players:
Mrs.Human
Taitheproficient
LoonyMan
Methilestesas

[Org]

I am an A playa

[Zai]

I am an A playa

Org, it's grammatically incorrect to (1) place 2 articles next to each other (2) capitalize an article in the middle of a sentence (and 3) misspell "player" in the same vein as "gangsta".

[Org]

I am an A playa

Org, it's grammatically incorrect to (1) place 2 articles next to each other (2) capitalize an article in the middle of a sentence (and 3) misspell "player" in the same vein as "gangsta".

Yo dawg I herd you liek gramma so I put gramma in yo gramma so you can feel gud when yo feel gud.

[Leafsnail]

Dakarian: High rank should not require substitutions.
Why?
That means that high ranks require OTHERS to require replacing.

If everyone's super...nobody will be.

Actually, I don't think Meph would be an S rank player- but he would be an S rank moderator.

You might notice that now you're arguing that S-ranks are, basically, more skilled at playing(/acting) town.
Solid S Players:
Bookadict
Drakonian
ChAoTiCjIm
Cheap Drink
maybe S players:
alex-chan (...except for the flake of Para3, would be definite S-rank)
arRay
apostatic nihilist
CinnabarSkulker
Cobrarsenic
Solidly A players:
Mrs.Human
Taitheproficient
LoonyMan
Methilestesas

Hehe... interesting list, I suppose.  Even if I'd prefer to forget about the Cobrarsenic role (if anyone is wondering, it was supposed to be a one shot combined unlynchable/ untouchable before I added in the daykill).

[Mephansteras]

Actually, I don't think Meph would be an S rank player- but he would be an S rank moderator.

I have to agree with that. I'm a reasonably active player, but I don't pretend to be so active as to keep a game going all on my own. Especially lately, with how work has picked up.

[Org]

Actually, I don't think Meph would be an S rank player- but he would be an S rank moderator.

I have to agree with that. I'm a reasonably active player, but I don't pretend to be so active as to keep a game going all on my own. Especially lately, with how work has picked up.

But Meph has awesome games.

[Zai]

It's okay, Org. I didn't expect you would get a joke of such a high caliber as that.

Dakarian: High rank should not require substitutions.
Why?
That means that high ranks require OTHERS to require replacing.

If everyone's super...nobody will be.

Agreed.

And +1 Orator for Incredibles reference.

[Leafsnail]

I got the joke, Zai .

Anyway, that list he made causes me to remember I still have a list of Bay 12 Mafia 2 roles on my desktop.  Meh.