Like, if you say someone's being racist against a religion, I would conclude that you're probably a bit on the dim side.
Well, you'd be wrong then, because when it is completely blatantly obvious what you are talking about, very specific, pedantic details don't matter very much, no?
I could not possibly disagree more fundamentally with that statement.
Everyone should say what they mean!
Do you actually understand the reason why using the correct words and grammar is important?
It's because you want to be able to be understood, not because your house will get infested with Victorian-era ghost-demons if you don't. If you're already completely, unambiguously understood, then what's the goddamn point of correcting every which detail of your text? That's why grammar Nazis are looked down upon -- they annoy people and spam threads to no actual gain whatsoever.
You have a good point about pedantry. However, I would take offense at being called a racist for criticizing a religion, or even a culture. Beliefs and traditions should be open to criticism. Race should not.
I have some political opinions which cause people to think I'm racist, and I'm not okay with that. But I understand why it happens. I have an ongoing goal to improve my arguments, and even refine my positions using feedback, until I don't appear racist.
Yeah, that's definitely a sad...
But my concerns about Islam (or Christianity) aren't part of that. If someone decides I'm racist based on my opinion of Islam, I'm probably just going to ignore them. It's unlikely to be a productive conversation, from that starting misconception.
(Unless, like, I was complaining about Syrian people and calling them all... terrorists or something? Then I'm a racist pedant, sure!)