Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Mephansteras]

The Glowing Tally Board
Apostolic Nihilist: Jim Groovester, Leafsnail, Mr.Person
ExKirby: Apostolic Nihilist, ExKirby, Frelock, Jim Groovester, Leafsnail, Neruz, Org, SHAD0Wdump
Beacon80: Frelock
Mr.Person: Neruz, SHAD0Wdump
Neruz: Mr.Person
SHAD0Wdump: Apostolic Nihilist


Day is extended to ~5pm Pacific Today to allow Beacon time to figure out where his votes will go.

[Beacon80]

I don't need it.  If I'm the last one voting, that simplifies things.  Voting for Neruz won't accomplish anything.  I'd like Mr. Person to have a shot at going in the ring.  My second vote is largely irrelevant, but I'll toss in my support for ExKirby being in the ring.

[Mephansteras]

The Glowing Tally Board
Apostolic Nihilist: Jim Groovester, Leafsnail, Mr.Person
ExKirby: Apostolic Nihilist, ExKirby, Frelock, Beacon80, Jim Groovester, Leafsnail, Neruz, Org, SHAD0Wdump
Beacon80: Frelock
Mr.Person: Beacon80, Neruz, SHAD0Wdump
Neruz: Mr.Person
SHAD0Wdump: Apostolic Nihilist


ExKirby and Org have only a single vote cast so far. Since we have a tie between Apostolic and Mr.Person, I'll leave the day open until 5 unless they decide to Abstain with their last votes.

[Jim Groovester]

Beacon80, I'm going to ask you a few questions before voting ends, just to see where you stand.

What's your opinion of Apostolic Nihilist? What do you think of my questions posed to him, and how he responded? What do you make of him asking ExKirby to claim his role? What other thoughts do you have?

What's your opinion of ExKirby? What do you make of his claim of Archmage? What do you make of his alignment?

What are your thoughts on Frelock? Leafsnail? SHADOWdump? Myself? Everybody else in this game?

I just want to get you talking, that's all, to see where you stand.

Alright, Leafsnail, you're lurking. You post far more frequently in every other mafia you're in, so I've gotta wonder, what's up? Trying to avoid scrutiny by only voting and assisting and making gameplay clarifications? That looks mighty suspect to me, since you're usually a lot more active and helpful than this.

[Leafsnail]

I'm sorry, I have been lurking slightly in this game.  Mainly because I feel that getting ExKirby into the ring is a must for today, and that Apost hasn't really done anything since I voted him to show he's not scum.  I will try to post more tomorrow.

[ExKirby]

I highly doubt that my vote is detrimental so No Secondvote.

[Jim Groovester]

Dude, there's a tie on Apostolic Nihilist and Mr. Person, and you're going to abstain with your second vote?

Do you not care who you fight? Do you not care whether they're scum or town? Honestly, this strikes me as something incredibly scummy to do.

[Apostolic Nihilist]

You seem awfully shaken Nihilist...

Well, rather than shaken, I was fatigued. The sort of, 'stayed up all night to finish homework, went to school, then decided to post in the mafia forum without resting'.
Most of my posts are surprisingly nonsensical.

But yeah, ExKirby: You can decide who fights you. Who do you think has been scummier? Who's been dropping more scumtells, etc? There's no reason to leave the result up to chance.
Unless you're scum, and the both of us are town.
The lives of Tower Mages lay within your hands; your decision is important.

[Mr.Person]

You guys are forgetting about Org's second vote, let's let him talk, too.

[Frelock]

Alright, if it's a choice between Mr. Person and Apostolic Nihilist, I'm going to Unvote Jetsquirrel (thanks for filling in, beacon) and vote Apostolic Nihilist.

I don't mind fighting ExKirby. I'll die, no doubt, since he's either Cabal or Archmage...

I always find myself suspicious of people who throw themselves into the ring, but more so of people who give up and "don't mind dieing."


And Apostolic, I'm near certain that the town nullified me.  The scum know I'm town, and thus tell the truth.  If I had wanted to assist, I would have tried to get everyone else to do the same, not insisted that we all do nothing.  Therefore, a townie must have been suspicious of me, and therefore nullified me.

[Beacon80]

Beacon80, I'm going to ask you a few questions before voting ends, just to see where you stand.

What's your opinion of Apostolic Nihilist? What do you think of my questions posed to him, and how he responded? What do you make of him asking ExKirby to claim his role? What other thoughts do you have?

I'm on the fence about Apostolic Nihilist.  He could be a well-meaning tower mage siding with Mr. Person based on his more valid arguments.  His request for ExKirby to claim his role certainly makes sense if he believed that contestants were immune to night activities (for lack of a better term).  All in all, my opinions of him and Mr. Person are largely tied together (i.e. if one of them flips scum, I think the other is likely scum, too, or tower, if the other is tower), but I'm more suspicious of Mr. Person than Apol.

What's your opinion of ExKirby? What do you make of his claim of Archmage? What do you make of his alignment?

Too early to tell on him.  His clear-cut victory certainly suggests he might be an Archmage, but it does nothing to prove his alignment, one way or the other.

What are your thoughts on Frelock? Leafsnail? SHADOWdump? Myself? Everybody else in this game?

Nothing has really jumped out at me on my first read through.  The battle between Neruz and Person was a fair bit distracting.  I'll try to give the first day a more thorough analysis when I have more time.

[Mephansteras]

His request for ExKirby to claim his role certainly makes sense if he believed that contestants were immune to night activities (for lack of a better term).

The better term is: Side-action.

[Jim Groovester]

It figures that Org would come online, sign up for a mafia, and then not post in the ones he's playing in.

[Apostolic Nihilist]

All in all, my opinions of him and Mr. Person are largely tied together (i.e. if one of them flips scum, I think the other is likely scum, too, or tower, if the other is tower), but I'm more suspicious of Mr. Person than Apol.

This is bad. Really, really bad.
When I flip tower, don't suspect Mr.Person less. I agree with his arguments and the way he's applying them.
As far as town/scum-wise, it doesn't tell me a lot. He's using a decent strategy which I agree with, but that doesn't make him more town.

I'm actually interested to know what he thinks of my alleged 'defense' of him. His most recent post was particularly cryptic.

[Beacon80]

I should clarify that a bit.  Apostolic or Person flipping tower doesn't mean nearly as much to me as if one of them flips cabal.  My doubts might lessen a little, but not much.