Argh, you people post a lot. I go to bed, and then when I come back, there are five more pages of discussion to go through.
To start, I guess I'll comment on the top four scum candidates the town has so far.
Re: forasken1111: I'm not entirely surprised that his behavior was planned. I was thinking about jokingly asking him about the possibility of it, but decided against it for reasons I can't entirely remember. I guess I thought it would be a useless inquiry.
I thought he was an unhelpful townie before, but now that I know his actions were planned, it places a layer of suspcion over everything he's done. While I agree with his reasoning that scum wouldn't have drawn so much attention to themselves, I'm still left slightly uncomfortable by his actions.
For the most part, however, I think he's town.
Re: NUKE9.13: Nuke is really trying hard to justify his actions. I just don't like it when people throw down walls of text scrutinizing insignificant details for scumminess, because, well, I don't like reading through all of them. He still wants forsaken1111 dead, and he's pulling out everything he's got. He's analyzing timestamps, for crying out loud. And while some of you have said he's doing helpful scumhunting, he's still only scumhunting in one direction.
I've read all of his walls of text, and haven't really been convinced by anything he's said so far, so my vote will remain on him.
Re: Humaan: Everything he's posted so far has been laced with suspicion, as others, particularly Leafsnail, have pointed out. His last post, which was five pages ago, is full of errors. His insistence that we should lynch to thwart just the Watcher is suspicious.
I agree with Leafsnail's conclusions about him, but he needs to post more so that we can make a better judgment about him.
Re: muchenik: Is he just bad at the game or is he scum? I can't decide.
I agree we're getting tunnelvision focusing on these four candidates for scumminess. So, it's time to bring all our fine friends back into the discussion. If this seems hypocritical of me since I haven't posted that much, I understand where you're coming from, but my infrequent posts aren't from a lack of desire, it's from a lack of internet access. So I do what I can in the time I have.
Frelock, Kashyyk, eduren, RedWarrior0, Diakron, JanusTwoFace: Comment!