Alright then. Glad to see Web's on top of things as usual. Considering the fact that he's a confirmed townie who claims he has proof of a scum (I'm guessing the Arg role got really lucky this round and tracked meph or something), I'm willing to vote with him. Vote Meph.
Now on to the others.
Archangel-
I'm somewhat intrigued by his eventual voting of himself. Yes, I'm sure everyone was frustrated at that point and wanted the day to end, but isn't that something of an extreme way of going about it? You also didn't vote any more after that. Why? There were plenty of accusations flying about, and plenty of reason to vote for someone. Did you just let go of this game and forget about it?
Chaoticjosh-
Looking at the handy voting record our scum provided, he's been bouncing around a lot. First he's against Mr.Person. Then he's against the lurker, Redwarrior, then he's going for Toony, then he back against Alex, then Redwarrior again, and finally ends on panda. Now, this wouldn't be suspicious normally; it was a long day and people were bound to change directions, even a 180 change like toony-alex. However, the thing that really gets me is that each of those votes was onto an already-developed bandwagon. Alright, I exaggerate here. I know for a fact that Toony, Alex, Redwarrior (the second time) and Mr.Person(though technically he was the first to vote for Mr.Person, it was clear that everyone wanted him dead as soon as the restart took place) were bandwagons. The others I can't seem to find off-hand, so I'll give him the benefit of the doubt. Still this strikes me as both odd and scummy.
Of course, let's not forget Josh's shining moment: the moment where he gave us a confirmed townie. It was his plan; he came forward about his role and what it did, and suggested the only way it could have worked. There was no way brothernature could have seen that. However I saw it as soon as web died, as Leaf gave me BN's known role too. And everyone else would have seen it when BN finally revealed his known role (if ever). They would have seen that it was the perfect opportunity to get a confirmed townie, and that Josh was smart enough to realize it. They would have lynched him for not revealing his role and giving them a confirmed townie. So he willingly brought about webadicts return. As soon as I read that, I classified it as a null-tell: he'd do it as scum, he'd do it as town. However, I think that that action has, subconsciously or consciously, made people very willing to believe he's town. Note how on all the scum lists around that time he appears in the "most probably town" category. Now understand here, I'm not saying that this makes Josh scummy. I'm saying it's a null-tell and we need to entertain the notion that he is scum, however unlikely that may seem to us.
Dakarian-
I've got nothing. Perhaps I just like his posting style too much, but I can't see why he's suspicious. Perhaps he's just flown under my radar but for the time being, he's neutral on my list.
Alexhans-
Though you're going to yell at me for it, you require a post all your own, and I don't have the literal hour it would take me to do it. I'll get back to you. However, a quick question: was my post nice and tidy?
Author
Topic: Bay 12 Mafia - Game Over - The Computer's Revenge (Read 72948 times)