Ok, I've gone through and grabbed stuff from Boksi, RedWarrior0, and Brother nature.
Let's see what we have here:
brothernatureWhy don't we get Alex to hammer-kill Person when the day resets instead of wasting the days lynch? I'd much rather do that, so if he does flip town, we might have a chance to lynch scum today.
Analysis: Dakarian picked this up and started pushing for the Hammer of Mr.Person. After this post, well, nothing at all from brothernature as far as I saw. I really want brothernature to show up and play. I know 30-odd pages of stuff is a lot to ask a new player to go through, but at the very least he could look at the last couple of pages and give us
something to work off of. I'm not really willing to lynch him at this point, though, since there is little to go off of.
RedWarrior0Oh, shoot. My post count for the day got reset.
I wouldn't be surprised if a role named after me was another one based off lurking.
So I need another post.
Archangel, why are dakarian, meph, diakron, zai, cheeetar, and pandar "no comment"? What exactly do you want me to come out and do, other than post and vote my suspicions?
We've decided to hammer ArchAngel? Let's figure out who to lynch after him. Alex was refusing to DK Mr.Person at one point. Pandar and Toony are seeming to agree. Archangel is as good as dead at this point.
By the way, has cj posted much recently?
How many do you need voting him to use the hammer? Because a majority is 8 IIRC, and we have 6 on him.
Also, I assume your decision to wait for his claim means your decision on the hammer as well. What role(s) would you choose to not hammer?
Okay. I'll unvote.
Alex, why were you so sure that Mr.Person was town earlier? Scumbuddies with him, perhaps?
More later. I'm currently getting kicked off the computer.
----
The heck? Alex, I assume you're joking here, right?Yes. RedWarrior... and with you too? Did you forget about our quicktopic or something? I AM pretty sure Mr.Person is town.
Why are you unvoting Archangel? Why did you vote him in the first place? Why didn't you mention you had any suspicions about me being with Mr.Person before?
"More later"? I hope there's something else than this poor attempt to copycat others so you look like scumhunting.
---- Back to RedWarrior
Is this how Alexhans normally plays? Insistance that a person is town, based off meta-knowledge? An absolute Lynch all Lurkurs policy? Second, I doubt he would have hammered on the first Day 1 if the Cobrarsenic role ability was known. Better yet, he would have hammered a mafia guy.
So, to be sort of productive, I re-propose the hammering of Mr.Person.
@Diakron: As zai told me, web makes mistakes sometimes. And as you said, he isn't a god.
Analysis: Lots of bandwagoning and pushing to hammer Mr.Person without really giving many reasons of his own. Sounds to me like he might be scum trying to rush things along and get a townie killed.
BoksiHmmm. I don't really have any excuse for not posting except forgetfulness. I don't have that much experience in these things, so I haven't made many assumptions either. But for now, I'll unvote and vote chaoticjosh. It seems like a decent idea right now, or at least better than trying to lynch Alexhans. Besides, it's getting a clear majority already.
Right now, I'm the most suspicious of Mr. Person, due to his general behavior, but I'm not ruling out anybody but myself.
Well, my reason for voting Alexhans was Mr. Person's defense of him. I found it very suspicious and he seems to be overreacting to a lot of things. Not frothing at the mouth, sure, but his overall writing style seems a little... agitated.
Now, I'd also like you to remember that I don't have as much experience as most of you do, so my inexperience means I don't always make good decisions or arguments.
...That's just going to make you suspect I'm scum trying a "i'm new halp plz" ploy, isn't it?
Anyway, I seem to be overly fond of bandwagoning, so I'm voting Mr. Person now.
Hm. I guess I don't have this burning drive compelling me to read and write massive walls of text and analyze people based on their current behavior, future behavior and behavior in relation to current knowledge and other people's behavior. Instead I make hasty decisions based on hunches. Hee, I'm being a bad player. How amusing. Or not, if you take a freaking text game on the internet seriously enough to hold grudges, but I don't think you do. Do you?
Compare my behavior if you want. I was scum in Mind & Magic Mafia 2 and Ridiculous Mafia 2. I can't be bothered to do this analysis stuff.
But on to Meph's question. Why did I bandwagon Mr. Person? It's a question which I can't truly answer myself. I guess I didn't like his overzealousness. I mean, he seems like the most aggressive person in this game, well outpacing Alexhans. But maybe that's because I don't spend as much time poring over this thread like you guys?
Hm. I guess I don't have this burning drive compelling me to read and write massive walls of text and analyze people based on their current behavior, future behavior and behavior in relation to current knowledge and other people's behavior. Instead I make hasty decisions based on hunches. Hee, I'm being a bad player. How amusing. Or not, if you take a freaking text game on the internet seriously enough to hold grudges, but I don't think you do. Do you?
Compare my behavior if you want. I was scum in Mind & Magic Mafia 2 and Ridiculous Mafia 2. I can't be bothered to do this analysis stuff.
But on to Meph's question. Why did I bandwagon Mr. Person? It's a question which I can't truly answer myself. I guess I didn't like his overzealousness. I mean, he seems like the most aggressive person in this game, well outpacing Alexhans. But maybe that's because I don't spend as much time poring over this thread like you guys?
That's fine, just one small detail. Why, exactly, is aggressiveness scummy?
Well, aggression isn't exactly scummy... How do I put this? Well, I really can't point to anything concrete. There's something about his style, especially early on, that just rubs me the wrong way.
Well. I have to stabilize my sleep patterns and it's almost eleven, so...
Eh, I've been trying to think of something to say for a while now but I realized I don't have anything worthwhile to say. I'll be trying to follow these massive WOTs, and while it is doable with my degree of reading comprehension I really want to say that I don't find WOTs to be such a good thing. Especially when WOTs start quoting WOTs in their entireties.
Anyway, I might have more things to say more when something concrete has happened. As in actual events, like webadict getting hammered. I still suspect Person enough to maintain my vote on him, mostly because his flip will really influence my reasoning.
So, status quo for me.
FAKE-EDIT: OH GOD ZAI, PARAGRAPHS, PARAGRAPHS. I CAN BARELY READ THAT!
Analysis: Playing the new player card a lot and is both jumping on bandwagons and acting really cautious. Most of his arguments are based on 'feelings' and 'post style' rather then any concrete behavior. Could be new player anxiety, or he could be a new scum player who's not sure what to do. I'm still leaning scum.
So, I'm going to
unvote and vote
RedWarrior0, with an intention to vote
Boksi afterwards. Redwarrior0 seems a bit more scummy, since I know he's been in a few mafias at this point. I don't know Boksi's playstyle, so I'm less sure about him.
Brothernature I'll have to hold off on until we get more information. He's just given us too little to go off of for us to risk hammering him or lynching him today. As web pointed out, we're in a bad spot this game with the # of scum vs town, so we really can't afford to be careless with this.