dakarian is genuinely scumhunting in my opinion.
I've played a lot with Mr.Person on IRC and we've learned to be agressive and look at every single thing. There's a lot of things that give me town-tells from his part.
The way in wich he suspected me before seems truthful.
The fact that he was trying to get me nightkilled is very reasonable. I would do the same. I actually knew I had to use the kill on day 1 so I could be viewed as nothing more than a townie so as to stay alive because scum would try to kill a PR. Yes, I am selfish.
Josh gains town points for his play. He could've shutted up about it.
What if he's lying scum and he has a power that makes lynching him a bad idea for the town?
Dude... This seems one stupid question... There's no game where scum can get lynched without losing... Otherwise... how would town win?
Like a deadman bomb that kills two people who voted for him or something?
Then he wouldn't use it now. He would use it when he is near lylo so he can win the game early. There was NO suspicion on him. Also... 2 town players for one scum is a fair deal.
And if he's a role that we definately do NOT want to kill? Scum Beloved Princess perhaps?
What... the... fuck?
Same thing I said to meph... Also, why the paranoia? If someone admitted scum would you be suspicious that he is some kind of scum that benefits from getting lynched?
Unnecessary hostility duly noted.
so?
Welcome to what-if land, population: you.
lol
When you do make an accusation, it's riding on another person's argument. When Cheetar accused Panda you pushed Cheetar for more info then, when given, went for the vote. You had NO questions to Panda? If Cheetar didn't speak out would you had said anything? Are you trying to get others to do the work for you?
Cheetar accused pandar for writing in CAPS, lying about the Archerub role and lurking... the first one is joking around wich it may or may not be viewed as a scumtell. The other 2 are fake. What's wrong with saying that? I did it too. Why didn't you call ME on it?
Then once in a while, you jump with someone and tell everyone to not question their actions. When I did question you strike at me with it.
You're starting to have a lot of flaws in your playstyle. You're generalizing here. When I said that you should trust me on not revealing my role before others did people thought it was some sort of stupid scum strategy and Mr.Person (who knows me) suggested that you should trust me when I said I had a reason for I wouldn't do such a thing otherwise. He did it once. Not "once in a while".
Take a deep breath. Leave your emotional ties to the game behind.
Why don't we get Alex to hammer-kill Person when the day resets instead of wasting the days lynch? I'd much rather do that, so if he does flip town, we might have a chance to lynch scum today.
is that your whole contribution?
Sleep is a good idea, thanks you Alexhans. When Webadict shows up, we should all claim to him. What's the worst that can happen?
Isn't this a non-free pm game?
Alright, Mr. Person's arguments seem hollow to me, using verbosity to batter people into thinking he's actually saying something, Therefore I say daykill: Mr. Person. I also think Boksi should say something. He's said less than me! (Sorry about that by the way, but I usually only have internet access in the evening and night, so it's difficult for me to post more than once or twice a day)
He is actually saying something and you're not. I know that you may have troubles posting... blah, blah but it happens every game you play in.
So pandar... you want to daykill Mr.P and fos diakron and dakarian? cool... You say both sides of the discussion are scum, righT?
FoS:PandarAs for the lurkers, it's always dangerous to kill lurkers since you're shooting blind and could be wasting a shot. If they are active but not posting, it's best to pressure them with votes to force them into the air. If they ignore that, they may not even be in the game and, thus, should be replaced by the moderator. True lurking is, in the end, a null tell, NOT a scum tell (active lurking, where they post once in a while but give no content is different). We should be aiming our kills, lynch and daykill, on people who we truly believe are scum.
Lurkers suck. If we let town lurkers live they will be lynched later in the game to support a scum win. We better take lurkers first. They wont be nightkilled and they cant be read. I know it may be a null tell but I dont care for they LOSE games. They need to be taken out before its too late. I definetly welcome a replacement.
But for now, I'll unvote and vote chaoticjosh. It seems like a decent idea right now, or at least better than trying to lynch Alexhans. Besides, it's getting a clear majority already.
Right now, I'm the most suspicious of Mr. Person, due to his general behavior, but I'm not ruling out anybody but myself.
This guy keeps freaking me out. He always goes with the herd.
That last sentence is FULL OF NOTHING. Saying he can suspect everyone and that he suspects the guy in the spotlight for his "general behaviour"... come on!
'Ey, I'm here. I'd rather not roleclaim though, since my power is only useful if it's unknown.
I really wonder what role this is... I can't find anything like it in the list of roles.
Oh, and if it makes anybody feel better, Alexhans has made himself less town due to the fact that he doesn't want to take sides in the me vs. Dakarian thing. "Oh, you're both town!" is as close to saying "I don't want to get involved!" as possible. (Even if it is true, which it might be)
Bullshit man... I'm frigging posting what I think about everything... I just didn't have enough time.
And if you think Dakarian is scum. You're very probably wrong.
I nominate day-kill on Mr.Person.
Ok... another one that just wants to kill off anyone... first me... now Mr.Person... Give a fucking reason, pretty please.
Btw, your statement about Archangel sounds odd. Arc is the one that wants to kill of lurkers
Arch IS a lurker.
Hehe. Nice writing, Leafsnail!
Everyone should now PM their role to Webadict. Then we can see what he figures out.
... so it IS free pm... this feels SO breakable...
Josh... do you really think Mr.Person's argumentation was disproportionate?
We are doing the SAME SHIT we always do in bay12... the thing that makes me leave once in a while and forget about this mafias... We always try to lynch ACTIVE people... Absurd! Lurkers get a free pass because they have no issues but whoever post some gets attacked and if he decides to defend his arguments he will be acted more and more until people think that "Oh! look, he keeps debating and trying to convince us... he must be scum".
Right now, though, I want to hear from Boksi and brothernature the most. Who do you think are scum? Who do you think is town at this point? What is your opinion of everything that happened the first time around for day 1?
THIS!!! And add RedWarrior0 and Archagel.
Actually Zai, everyone's vote is reset. Nobody besides me has a vote on anyone right now.
Do your thing Alexhans.
Vote Mr.Person.
why should I? You haven't even explained a thing.
And Mr.P is the second person you're trying to get quickly killed.
Actually Zai, everyone's vote is reset. Nobody besides me has a vote on anyone right now.
Do your thing Alexhans.
Vote Mr.Person.
Sorry ToonyMan, that's just not going to cut it. Nice bandwagoning, btw.
You've been in my sights the whole game. You're acting really odd.
Reaaaaally? That's it??? he is acting odd? You're bandwaggoning a lot without much explanations. Why shouldnt I kill you, instead?
Alex: You would be my second choices as scum but you seem honestly repentive of you hammer, but that could be a ruse. Mr. P seems to defend you and it has been brought to my notice that this is a scumtell.
WHAT is a scumtell? You don't know my allignment. You don't know his... He defended me. I'm defending him now. What do you make of it?
By the way... I'd rather have 20 agitated players than 10 mild players and 9 lurkers lynching the only agitated player and then sleeping their way to defeat.
Well, my reason for voting Alexhans was Mr. Person's defense of him. I found it very suspicious and he seems to be overreacting to a lot of things. Not frothing at the mouth, sure, but his overall writing style seems a little... agitated.
Excuse me? Let me see if I have this right... You think Mr.Person defends me so I must be scum? Then you go and vote him? And why did you forget to explain this earlier?
Now, I'd also like you to remember that I don't have as much experience as most of you do, so my inexperience means I don't always make good decisions or arguments.
go Ahead... play THE NEWBIE CARD!
...That's just going to make you suspect I'm scum trying a "i'm new halp plz" ploy, isn't it?
Yes. A proud newbie tries to overcome his newbness by always trying to convince people and learning from others.
Confirmed town:
webadict
Town reads:
chaoticjosh
Mr.Person
dakarian
Leaning town:
Mephansteras
Neutral:
Diakron
Zaithemaster
Most Scum is probably here:
ToonyMan
Archangel
Cheeetar
Pandarsenic
FireWarrior0
brothernature
Boksi
Author
Topic: Bay 12 Mafia - Game Over - The Computer's Revenge (Read 72784 times)