Bay 12 Games Forum

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

Author Topic: Dwarfy descriptions  (Read 412 times)

Bunny

  • Bay Watcher
    • View Profile
Dwarfy descriptions
« on: August 11, 2009, 12:15:58 pm »

Moved here from the list of remaining items thread under suggestion from the other guys.

The current descriptions are awesome, but a little over-detailed.  A suggestion going around was that a description only offer unusual features, or the main features, sort of like a caricature.  Ie, if most of the dwarves in a fortress have long noses, there is little need to mention this for every one.

There was concern though about not really knowing what a dwarf looks like if all you read is "has short, downturned nose, blue eyes, is fat".  I figured maybe this could be looked into for a future release as follows:

I think it would be good to develop the descriptions so that they only focus on things that deviate significantly from the norm... but I don't think hair/skin should be worked that way.  If most dwarves in a fortress are broad of body with brown hair and green eyes I would still want to know this to get an accurate picture.  And I can see the potential frustration of never finding out that the average dwarf in your fortress has an extremely long nose.  Maybe there could be some sort of page giving an overall fortress description to give us the averages.

The Caves of Iron was founded in the year 10 by the dwarf Urist CleavedMoon.  The fortress extends across 12 levels and consists of 20 burrows.  The walls of this fortress are mainly microcline and some are engraved.  The fortress army consists of 37 dwarves in 8 squads.  The Champion of this fortress is Big McLargeHuge, who killed 8 goblins during a siege in the year 87.  The main export is olivine crowns.  The main import is Dwarven Rum.  The dwarves of this fortress are uncommonly rugged and stocky in build.  They are taller than normal and tend to be very lean.  Their skin is usually olive and their hair is on average copper.  They tend to have long, upturned noses.  They prefer to keep their beards neatly combed, their sideburns shaven and their moustaches in double braids.

I would then know that Urist McSparsebeard who is described as short, fat, uncommonly frail and with large ears, a braided beard and purple eyes is actually shorter, fatter and frailer than the rest of the fortress and, in addition to his large ears and purple eyes, likely has olive skin and a long nose.

It would also add a nice touch when picturing my fortress - a mass of stocky, tall olive-skinned dwarves with long noses... and the few notable dwarves whose descriptions I've paid attention to standing out from the crowd by virtue of their unique features.
Logged
Ph’nglui mglw’nafh Cthulhu R’lyeh wgah-nagl ftaghn

Granite26

  • Bay Watcher
    • View Profile
Re: Dwarfy descriptions
« Reply #1 on: August 11, 2009, 12:22:19 pm »

what to show and what not should be easy...

Hair/Eye color is a discrete variable.  Should always be shown.

Weight, Build, Nose shape is (conceptually) a continuous variable.  Should only be shown when abnormal.



I don't know that I like normal-by-civ.... well, I do, but not used as a way to cull data from individual descriptions.