Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Xegeth]

I wasn't saying that they should betray their own team, just that they could help us against the exterminator. I can see how letting it live would help them though.

[Kashyyk]

I wil notl vote Mr Person yet, because I want to raise a point. Both chaticjosh and Cheeetar said they were Watchers, and Cheeetar is now proved human, which must mean Chaoticjosh is a Dopp. Unless I have missed something...

[JoshuaFH]

It's been changed Kashyyk, so now one side can have more than one of a role. So Cheeetar and I were both Watchers, through sheer coincidence.

[Kashyyk]

Ah, that would explain it.

vote Mr Person

[ToonyMan]

I'll be following what NUKE's been saying for all its worth.

Vote Mr.Person.

[JanusTwoface]

There's so much less to analyze...   vote Mr.Person

[Kashyyk]

Yeh, it's starting to feel like the ghost again.

Also, Janus how do you pronounce a 'Germanic J' I've been wondering...

[JanusTwoface]

It's a Y.  Pronounced closer to Yanoos than Janus.  Based off of the pronunciations I've heard of the Roman two-headed god.

And we do still have two things left to do:
- Find the Alien Scientist (if that's what vanishing means)
- Find the Exterminator (if that's what burns mean)

Because by having both, we might still be able to pull of losing.  Theoretically.  (Although I would be rather impressed with us if we identify all of the Mafia on day 1 and still lose )

[Kashyyk]

Are you sure 'Impressed' is the right word? 

Also, thanks for the Germanic J thing.

[JanusTwoface]

Impressed with the quantity of fail, yes. 

Any ideas on either alien?

[Kashyyk]

Not as of yet no. Although I will keep scum hunting.

[Rysith]

Also Cheeetar obviously suffered death by exterminator (or some other alien).
The dopps were obviously hindered in their murders somehow. My guess: They went for webadict, who, naturally, was not there.
Anyway, unless somebody found the exterminator or the scientist and thinks they should tell everyone before they die, speak up.
Otherwise, let's lynch Mr.Person for being a dopp.

Why wouldn't the dopps have gone for chaoticjosh? Sure, he's likely to have been protected, but it seems like a more likely target than webadict.

Anyway, vote Mr.Person, but pose the following scenario:

chaoticjosh, pandarsenic, and Frelock are dopplegangers. Pandarsenic agrees to get lynched d1 to allow chaoticjosh to advance his watcher claim. Pandarsenic then posts his "bah" post claiming to out the rest of them. Sure it's risky, but it gets them a "confirmed" townie in either Frelock or chaoticjosh, and keeps their last member hidden as an emergency backup.

That doesn't change my vote for Mr.Person, though, since either he'll flip dopp (good!) or he'll flip town and expose something like the above scenario (worse, but still ok).

Mr.Person, if you are town, I'd urge you to come out and lay out what you know, and what (if anything) you found out last night.

And the game circumstances are going to make it hard to scumhunt, since the "right" answer is to go along with the person from chaoticjosh/pandarsenic's list.

[forsaken1111]

I can say that nobody visited Chaoticjosh's house last night. I was scoping it out hoping to get a story out of all this. It's a reporter's job, after all. Long boring night, and I didn't see anyone come or go.

[Kashyyk]

although it would mean that Chaticjosh would HAVE to be a Watcher, as Cheeetar confirmed his results.

Anyway, does anyone have any idea why the exterminator went after Cheeetar? I would have gone after Chaticjosh personally.

[forsaken1111]

I would have gone after Chaticjosh personally.

Indeed, I expected him to go after chaoticjosh as well which is why I was watching the house.