Looser in thought? No, I'm just specifically trying to avoid too much WIFOM and using Occam's razor on the situation. The idea of you killing Panda makes some sense. Is it a great scum-tell or anything, no. But it is a plausible reason for you to have killed him, more then anyone else.
Besides, that isn't why I'm voting for you. I'm voting for you because if Org is town and you're scum the town has pretty much lost. If you're town and Org is scum, the town still has a decent shot at winning. That's not based on WIFOM or voting patterns or anything except hard math. You get three votes tomorrow. That's as much as every other player combined at that point. More, if both you and Org are still alive tomorrow. In that situation you pretty much control the entire vote. Which is fine if you're town, but horrible if you're scum since you've pretty much won at that point.
Is it like josh's power last game, yes. However, I died in that game before it got to that point, so I didn't have to worry about it as much. This game I do. That game also had a very different set of powers involved, and that changed things quite a bit.
The fact that Josh's role was a town role last game means nothing. Web can and will shake things up all he likes, and as long as the resulting set-up is reasonably balanced he'll use it.
--
Really, there is no situation where I'll be content with both you and Org surviving today. If everyone is convinced Org is scum and wants to lynch him, and we have a reliable replacement for Leafsnail, I might accept that. We'd at least have a chance to lynch you tomorrow if people decide you're scum. Otherwise, it's just too risky to leave you alive, since your three votes against only two active townies would mean you win.
I know I'm voting on role, but I'm not voting on role because I think the role is scummy, I'm voting on it because of the consequences of it being scum. You have, by far, the most powerful role for Scum right now. So powerful that it's game ending at this point. Considering that the other two scum roles (Vote stealer and twin voter) weren't all that powerful, I wouldn't be surprised if Web gave the Fibonacci voter to scum. Especially since things would have to have gone oddly for the game to go past 4 days, so it's not really much more powerful then Josh's triple-voter role.
Janus, Frelock, Leaf (if you're here), what are your thoughts?
Author
Topic: Vote Mafia, Round 2! (Game Over!) (Read 32934 times)