I heard about this back when it happened in late April on the forums. The guy just posted a rant out of nowhere, everyone else was kind of like "uh what?" and then Andrew was like "uh what?" Basically he was unimpressed with the process (and was possibly posting his stuff elsewhere) and lashed out pretty hard when people told him not to, condemning everything related to the process as well. Judging by his MySpace post there, he expected Andrew to walk him step-by-step through every storyboard panel with a good gist of the kind of thing he wanted, and when he didn't get that, he got really really mad. From the looks of it every artist music and art-wise in the project got a very, very general idea of what Andrew wanted for the comic, but Bolin got furious that he wasn't getting a more hands-on step-by-step approach. I don't really see the problem myself, since I compose music like a lot of the Homestuck stuff myself and being told "about this long, kinda like this" isn't a big deal for me at all. I do understand him getting frustrated at the implied non-disclosure thing but he really didn't pick a very good way to deal with his issues.
But yeah, sad to see all his stuff gone despite good reason for it. At least we still have Bowman and Radiation.
Also Armok, stop trying to justify things in a way that benefits you all the time. The guy's stuff getting taken down from Homestuck doesn't make it free. Bolin's already been shown to be overprotective about it anyhow.
I can see where he is coming from, even if I have to support AH at the end after thinking about it.
I'd imagine AH was more than happy to give his artists the artistic liscence that most people desire. Perhaps the problem came from not enough feedback to the musician. When you spend hours of your time on a song, asking for feedback and getting in return, yeah its good keep up the work, is almost disappointing. The point of asking feedback is to make sure the parts of the song that you've made are acceptable, and what should be changed, and what should be added. It really requires a lot of in depth time from the person giving the feedback. However in the end the way AH seems to do it really would be preferable to me at least, rather than working on things for a few hours and checking to be sure it's what he he is looking for.
Also, the fact that AH is willing to do a storyboard design to fit the music instead of the other way around is simply amazingly effective to me. It really limits the need for feedback required.
My unaffiliated guess would simply be that the musician kept asking for AH's feedback and wasn't happy with what he got in return. Making music is extremely time consuming on a computer, or at least the way I do it is, and I can't really blame either side on this. The musician simply wanted to be sure he was "doing it right." if it's what I assume, while AH was too busy to give the in-depth feedback that really makes a Musician sure he is spending his time correctly. or something.
Also, with less feedback the chance of spending time making something that doesn't fit increases, and it's annoying to have to start over or take out parts because you made something that, while not sounding bad, just doesn't work.
It's sort of like digging a hole while your boss is in his office, and if you dig in the wrong spot on accident and he doesn't check up on you, you still have to dig the second hole when he does realize it's not going to work.
I should repeat this, in AH's defense he's said he plans some storyboards according to the music. I don't know if that's what he usually does for the flash parts or just that one, but it's pretty freaking sweet from my digital musicians point of view. It would mean I wouldn't have to worry so much about the structure of a song and could just let it ride from mild to intense and back and be able to assume it will work within reason as long as it is a good song.
Also, it could all be tied into the record sales. A disagreement in that is extremely easy way for something like this to happen.
That said, maybe I could try sending him my slow backwards song once I get around to finishing it. I actually only have to finish work on fine tuning one song and I'll be able to make 4 different versions (fast, slow, backwards fast, backwards slow)
I wouldn't even ask for any kind of deal on the CD, it would be a great reference and that would be enough for me. Maybe I'd ask for a contract that states after a million copies sold I get $x amount. That way if it gets super famous I get compensated while AH won't have to worry about accounting his percentages and can spend his time making sweet comics.
Poll
Author
Topic: MSPA Homestuck (Read 5188118 times)