Post-game analysis:
-BloodBeard: You did a good job trying to think things through, but you were too obvious about the fact that you were thinking things through. It's why the mafia targeted you on Night One. If you're town, think things through but don't let on that you're doing it.
-dakarian: You also did a good job at thinking things through. I think the problem is that you put too much stock in what other people were saying. You listened to me and webadict, even though IIRC both of us manipulated the facts.
-ToonyMan: Your
clever ruse at the beginning caught me. I don't understand why you focused on eduren and webadict. If you tried to talk more rather than focusing on the actual mechanics of the game, then I think your survival rate would go up.
-Org: You've improved your play style, since you didn't exhibit your tell in this game. Why didn't you vote, man? That alone probably would have kept you alive until day two, at least.
-eduren: You did well defending yourself, when you did defend yourself. I think if you were more active, you would not have been voted so much. Try to start bandwagons more instead of joining them, and think about why you suspect people before you say that you suspect them. In short, play a more cerebral game and a less visceral game.
-Jim Groovester: Don't claim Doctor. It's suicide. Your instincts were good, but you did not do a good job following up on them. You would have enjoyed more success if you relied more on logic and evidence, rather than emotional appeals.
-webadict: Why did you lie about being Doctor? You completely burned the bridge for a Cop claim when you did that. If you had stuck with the "I might be Cop" story then I'd have been too scared to move off Vector on Day Two. Good job posturing, either way.
-Vector: Your plans were way better than mine and your defense was superb, but you gave yourself away a couple of times. I think you have the potential to become a very dangerous scum player.
-Kashyyk: You were absent at first, and then you jumped on the eduren bandwagon, which contradicted our earlier plan. I think we were lucky that everyone was tired on Day Three.
-Free Beer: My ambusher skill has increased. It is now High Master. The only person who seriously suspected me was Jim Groovester, and he only did so for the sake of suspecting me. As Meph could testify, I was probably the most paranoid player present. I had all the bases covered. My defense was ironclad. My problem was that I sucked at planning and tended to get in the way of Vector's better ideas. I also relied completely on the mafia wiki, even after it was demonstrated to be wrong (for example, I was led to believe that Jim was Cop, not Doctor).
Author
Topic: Beginners Mafia - Game over! (Read 73448 times)