Fine, have it your way.
-You marked Org for death even from the beginning of Day One. You claimed Org was lurking at the beginning, but kept your vote on him anyway when you noticed he still posted. You occasionally got sidetracked with other lurkers, but you still came back to Org.
I explained why I voted for Org to dakarian. I voted him to get him to talk. He proved uncooperative and defiant. I retained my voted. webadict talked about Org's tell. I was convinced. As I said to dakarian, I can't defend my vote beyond my original reasoning.
-You were very jumpy during Day One. You asked that I clarify the context of a post that was addressed to BloodBeard. Why? Obviously you must have thought it was addressed to you. Paranoid about being suspected, are you?
I was legitimately confused about whom you were referring to. I figured it was BloodBeard, since you quoted him, but you posted after dakarian, and referred to 'you' without clarifying. It's important to get people's suspicions straight.
-You defended Vector on multiple occasions. Defending other people does not help the town. If someone is being accused or questioned, the intent is to determine that person's guilt. If someone were interested in your guilt, they'd question you instead.
That's crap. If I can defend somebody when I think they're town, I do it successfully, and they later prove to be town, I saved the town from an unnecessary lynch. Ta da! I helped the town.
If I defend somebody, it's because I think the arguments don't stack up against them. I defended ToonyMan, because I thought his behavior was in line with the way he normally acts, and he seemed genuinely frustrated that people were going to lynch him. I defended Vector, because I thought webadict's accusations were far overblown, and he gave me no reason to suspect him. I was going to defend eduren from Vector's suspicion of a webadict/eduren pair, but then eduren started to act suspiciously again.
-As previously noted, I suspect webadict heavily. His above described suspect behavior regarding you, combined with the obvious lack of relationship between Vector and webadict, leads me to believe you are probably webadict's partner in scum.
-On the off-chance that Vector, my other main suspect, is scum, the strong connection between the two of you leads me to believe that you would also be his partner in scum.
I seem to be two people at once with you, but either way, I'm scum, huh? I can't defend myself if you're willing to believe all possibilities of my guilt at the same time.
If my campaign against webadict was ineffectual, then that means that I must suck at argumentation, rather than some scheme to only give webadict a decent, not token, amount of suspicion. I truly meant everything I said about him, and I can safely say that even as my suspicions about him begin vanishing.
Any attempts by webadict or Vector to defend me, or them just stating their reduced suspicions, were completely unsolicited by me, much in the same way me defending Vector or stating my reduced suspicions about webadict were unsolicited by them.
-dakarian is willing to risk the fate of the entire game on your scumminess. Something has to be up with that. I'd expect a scum ploy like this if it were lynch or lose, but we've still got at least one, probably two more days left.
And he's risking it foolishly. I think you're giving his gamble more credit than it deserves.
I'm not naive enough to believe that if I were to pull some crazy gamble, that you'd be willing to believe me. But that's your suggestion, anyway, that there's truth in whatever somebody's gamble is, if he's willing to gamble something big with it, despite how idiotic the gamble may be.
dakarian can choose to vote for me without deciding to drag the rest of the town with him or force it into a false dichotomy. I think it's stupid for him to try to do so, and very suspicious on its own.
-You're trying to organize a bandwagon on dakarian without actually taking the risk of voting for him. It's been repeated numerous times in this game: caution is a scum tell.
eduren proposed he and I call dakarian's bluff. It turns out he was trying to lure me out, or something. eduren's reasoning isn't very clear on this issue.
But I fell for it. The only way to call dakarian's bluff was to get a guaranteed lynch on him, since he was and currently is within no danger to be lynched. Then maybe he would start changing his tune once the votes started piling on him, or he would keep up his spiel. If the former, a scum tell, if the latter, a town tell.
So yes, I called for other people to help me and eduren call his bluff. If there weren't enough people, then the whole exercise would be a wasted effort, and we might as well not even bother trying.
Did I answer your suspicions?
Now, more grilling.
If I accuse you of lurking it's because you seem uninvolved most of the time. You only pop in to ask questions about other people, and you only express your opinions when asked. You never volunteer them on your own. That's
caution, and as we all know, caution is a scum tell. If you were interested in the discussion as opposed to the final lynch, you'd be somewhat more willing to give your opinions about what's going on, I think. However, giving people your opinions can lead people to suspecting you, after all, so you hold them tightly to your chest.
The only person that you've questioned that doesn't meet this pattern is ToonyMan. Instead you gave him the benefit of the doubt, and you even
cleared him. The selective nature of this is suspect.
Your behavior today constitutes bandwagoning. You voted for Vector after webadict did. Once suspicion on him began winding down, you voted for me. You don't seem to take initiative and accuse people on your own, only after somebody else does. Again,
caution.
But in Day 1, you accused BloodBeard. I looked over your posts, and your accusations seemed pretty trumped up, especially for the kinds of activity that went on during Day 1. Then, during the night, BloodBeard was killed, and you voted for him. I guess you decided to finish the job, then, figuring correctly that BloodBeard's suspicions were far more likely to be discussed than BloodBeard's accusers.
Free Beer, you're the scum. Am I certain of it? I'm hardly certain of anything anymore. But you've skated by completely without suspicion, for mostly suspicious reasons, and it's time somebody start grilling you.