Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

Yes

14 (60.9%)

No

8 (34.8%)

Other (explain)

1 (4.3%)

Total Members Voted: 23

[Mr.Person]

Why him? Why not Kashyyk? As far as I can tell, we have just as much information about him.

Because while Kashyyk could potentially be Cult, EchoP cannot. Simply, there is no role he could be, apart from Exterminator, that could be hurtful to us. And I doubt he's an Exterminator.

Wait, EchoP is not clear and neither is kashyyk. If kashyyk were claiming to be an FBI agent while actually an alien with no actual investigative role, he could be making up these alignments of players just to clear himself. It is easy to fake an FBI agent, as you don't need to know anything about the players you say you are investigating. You can just say they are town, and even if they weren't, they wouldn't disagree with you anyway. This may be the case with EchoP, I suggest we hold off sending him role info just in case this is what has happened.
I agree that a lynch of lurkers would definitely be best in this situation, so I am voting for a inaluct lynch seeing as he hasn't posted much at all and voted to lynch twiggie for lurking which is exactly what he did.

The only alien that would pull that kind of thing would be an exterminator, and the lack of night kills would seem to suggest against that. Even still, I suppose you're correct. Until he pulls out an inspection that correctly tells an alien, we can't say anything for sure.

[Pandarsenic]

A survivor could reasonably desire to pull that off, if we haven't already lynched one.

[Mr.Person]

No, but Servant Corps puts a monkey wrench in that idea. There's no scientist, there's no dopp seeker (Of if there is one, he's already lost, so whatever), and if there is an agent seeker, it's Kashyyk. Survivor, maybe, but a survivor would have to be aware how easily the facade can be broken by a myriad of roles.

[webadict]

Why him? Why not Kashyyk? As far as I can tell, we have just as much information about him.

Because while Kashyyk could potentially be Cult, EchoP cannot. Simply, there is no role he could be, apart from Exterminator, that could be hurtful to us. And I doubt he's an Exterminator.

Wait, EchoP is not clear and neither is kashyyk. If kashyyk were claiming to be an FBI agent while actually an alien with no actual investigative role, he could be making up these alignments of players just to clear himself. It is easy to fake an FBI agent, as you don't need to know anything about the players you say you are investigating. You can just say they are town, and even if they weren't, they wouldn't disagree with you anyway. This may be the case with EchoP, I suggest we hold off sending him role info just in case this is what has happened.
I agree that a lynch of lurkers would definitely be best in this situation, so I am voting for a inaluct lynch seeing as he hasn't posted much at all and voted to lynch twiggie for lurking which is exactly what he did.

Like I said, the only role that WOULD disagree is the Exterminator. No more Dopps, so no point for Dopp seeker. If Agent Seeker, choose Kashyyk. No point in lying. Duuuuuuh.

[Twiggie]

Well, then, would anyone be against lynching lurkers? I want Twiggie gone.

what exactly have you got against me in particular?
i've posted more than some other people here. (and no, i didnt count, so if im wrong... i really dont care.)

im going to vote inaluct for bandwaggoning against me and trying to lynch anyone he can to get the numbers down.

[Mr.Person]

It was Webadict that voted you, I think.

[Twiggie]

i know... thats why i quoted him. i simply find inalucts voting more suspicious than webadicts here.

[Pandarsenic]

Fact: Webadict is alive on Day 3, I am suspicious of him.

[Cheeetar]

I don't quite get what you mean, Pandarsenic.

[webadict]

I don't quite get what you mean, Pandarsenic.

He means that it's suspicious that I'm still alive with it being Day 3, which usually means I'm scum. Although, to be fair, I've never died in a game yet. I've only ever been lynched.

Also, Cheeetar, would you mind telling me who's the last scum?

[Cheeetar]

I don't know. Are you inferring that I am the last scum, or are you asking for my suspicions?

[inaluct]

i know... thats why i quoted him. i simply find inalucts voting more suspicious than webadicts here.

More like you want to make an OMGUS vote, and Fey is already voting for me, right?

[Pandarsenic]

Inaluct, that's the impression I got from it, too.

[Mr.Person]

I got the impression he was trying very hard to avoid OMGUS'ing. This is a purposeful null-tell. At the same time, he seems town-like to me for correctly pointing out that Inaluct was acting scummy. He didn't COMPLETELY ignore the vote, like some scum do, nor did he get all dramatic and defend himself, making a big deal out of a mislynch, like scum would. He simply pointed out what, to me, is a better lynch target anyways.

On the other hand, lynching REAL lurkers would probably be a better idea at this point. I'm talking Archangel levels of lurking here.

[Archangel]

I don't have an opinion one way or the other, so, I've got nothing to say.

I'm talking Archangel levels of lurking here.

OK. I think I should just stay away from this subsection once this game is over. I'm just not talkative enough. I don't have anything to say so I don't post, which tends to mean that I don't have anything to say.