Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

Yes

14 (60.9%)

No

8 (34.8%)

Other (explain)

1 (4.3%)

Total Members Voted: 23

[ToonyMan]

*sigh

If I post the PMs this game would be over too soon.  Plus anyway, if you kill me you don't get anymore info.  Hee hee.

Anyway, where in the rules does it say I can't ask scum for there roles?

[Mr.Person]

*sigh

If I post the PMs this game would be over too soon.  Plus anyway, if you kill me you don't get anymore info.  Hee hee.

Anyway, where in the rules does it say I can't ask scum for there roles?

It doesn't say that anywhere. It doesn't say the game has to be long either. Look, we're gonna lynch you and somebody else. If you come up scum, good, we've gotten a scum. If you come up town, great, we've gotten out scum. Win-win for town.

[ToonyMan]

Thanks.  You see it my way.

[ToonyMan]

Anyway, this was a really fun mafia for me.  I think I did some real great sleuthing.

[Beacon80]

Anyway, where in the rules does it say I can't ask scum for there roles?

Just because you're not breaking the letter of the law doesn't mean you're not breaking the spirit of the law.

[ToonyMan]

So you want me to tell you who my partner was and get him instant lynched?

Sounds fun.

[Mr.Person]

So you want me to tell you who my partner was and get him instant lynched?

Sounds fun.

Why yes, we would. A winning game=win.

[EchoP]

Anyway, this was a really fun mafia for me.  I think I did some real great sleuthing.

Sigh. At least try and defend yourself.

Also:

Anyway, where in the rules does it say I can't ask scum for there roles?

Just because you're not breaking the letter of the law doesn't mean you're not breaking the spirit of the law.

This. Teaming up with some one from outside the game breaks the game, as shown here.

So you want me to tell you who my partner was and get him instant lynched?

Sounds fun.

That would be nice. Or at least who the other scum are.

[Beacon80]

So you want me to tell you who my partner was and get him instant lynched?

Sounds fun.

Yes, because then we could start another game and not have anyone cheat.

[ToonyMan]

Fine, you win.

CULT:
SniHjen
Kashyyk
Duke 2.0


You will find it funny that I have already told you this.


@EchoP:

I'm sorry I'm not defending myself.  But I said I was townie and I do not lie.

[ToonyMan]

Where am I cheating again?  I just asked and he told.

[Beacon80]

Like I said, it violates the spirit of the game, even if it doesn't break any rules.  You play for your side to win.  You don't intentionally lose just because your friend is on the other side.
Look at it this way.  I could say "Guys, if I'm ever scum, I'll immediately flip on my allies."  Sure, it means if I'm a dopp, I'll always lose, but if I'm townie, it means I'm an immediately trusted town base.
Of course, assuming you're telling us the truth even now, this is still making the assumption that your "friend" isn't lying to you.
If it does turn out that this is exactly how you say it is, I want it to be known I won't play in any game you or your scum-flipping friend are in from now on.

[Rysith]

Unvote. This is... weird.

Unvote, agree with Pandarsenic. Too many suspicious people for the number of scum left.

SniHJen is still suspicious. EchoP will be suspicious only if ToonyMan flips scum, otherwise I'll put him down to being new. Kashyyk is suspicious since an agent claim, as has been said, makes no sense. Duke I have no idea about, since he hasn't been posting, which while ordinarily suspicious seems less suspicious than all of the other stuff that's been going on.

ToonyMan is suspicious for claiming to know everything, but not wanting to reveal his sources. If he does have everything, we've essentially won and what we do at this point doesn't matter. I'll agree with the sentiment that a cultist ratting out his fellow cultists seems weird. I'm not sure why we've decided that he must be lynched, though, apart from the "being confusing and crazy" part. And why vote for SniHjen if you know who the three cultists are?

At the same time, Alexhans is suspicious for pushing so hard for a ToonyMan lynch. That smacks of trying to save a fellow scum by pushing a last-minute bandwagon to a townie. That it's nearly worked is vaguely scary.

I'm still not sure about who to vote for, since it looks like votes for people other than ToonyMan, SniHjen, and EchoP won't matter at this point, and they are all potentially suspicious. I suppose I'll have to wait for the last moment, and see if anything in particular jumps out.

Fake Edit: 8 replies while I was typing that? What the hell? And vote ToonyMan, that a) looks really suspicious and b) if it's true, I object to it on principle.

[SniHjen]

Fine, you win.

CULT:
SniHjen
Kashyyk
Duke 2.0

HE IS STILL LYING!

I RAGEQUIT!

I was Towny.
I'm not going to join a mafia game ever again.

Spoiler (click to show/hide)

You are a regular Townsperson. You came here for a nice relaxing vacation, and instead you've found yourself caught up in some sort of bad horror movie. Or, it would be, if it weren't real. You'll have to use all your wits to get out of this alive!

[ToonyMan]

@Rysith:

It's a bandwagon started by the cult.  It won't work though.

@Beacon80:

I'm sorry.


I don't mean any hating.  I feel like I did something wrong.


fakeedit:

Ummm.....I stick with what I said earlier.