Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Mr.Person]

Pandarsenic cleared him, and Pandarsenic was clear by being dead.

[ToonyMan]

I'll need to iron out a fe--ALOT of bugs next game.  (if there is one)

[Pandarsenic]

So basically Archangel fucked us over by ignoring this game?

[Mr.Person]

I think you should at least make sure everybody who isn't mafia has a different role.

[ToonyMan]

Probably.

[Rysith]

So basically Archangel fucked us over by ignoring this game?

Basically. That, plus the two old farts (including one who didn't die like the confirmed one) threw off the roleclaim-deduction. Archangel contest Cheeetar's claim, even privately when I asked for the mass-claim, would have gone a long way towards figuring out who was who.

[Pandarsenic]

Can... can we just not accept him into Mafia games any more?

[Rysith]

I'll need to iron out a fe--ALOT of bugs next game.  (if there is one)

I'd be up for playing in a next game. My suggestion, however, would be to make sure that there is a good balance of roles, both between kill/protect/investigate and mafia vs. town, rather than having some large number of roles and randomizing between them. I will say I kind of liked the kill roles with restrictions, that added a bit of flavor.

One possibility would be to generate a role set and "play" a few games of it to see how the roles interact. If you find one side winning consistently, regenerate the roles and try again. That's what I did for Delta Green, and that seemed to be reasonably balanced in the actual playing.

Oh, and fix that bit where Serious Sams can self-confirm. That was fun, but sort of broken. For those of you wondering what it was, Pandar was able to quote "conscience" from the role PM to me, which basically meant that he couldn't be faking his claim. Another possibility would be a scum "doppleganger" role that N0 chose a player to "steal" the role of, and they'd get that role PM and appear to scans as that role, which would stop that sort of thing.

[SHAD0Wdump]

Definitely in on the next one.

[ToonyMan]

Next game will have all completely different roles.  I'll run a few (with like a default of 11 player, 3 mafia) and see if some roles are too powerful or if some are too weak.  Less killing roles for one.

[JoshuaFH]

I've been doing a little bit better lately, and I think I could start one of my mafia's again.

[Pandarsenic]

Is it wrong for me to be bitter that ToonMafia, which operates on basically the same principle as Ridiculous Mafia, succeeds while RM fails?

[Mr.Person]

Is it wrong for me to be bitter that ToonMafia, which operates on basically the same principle as Ridiculous Mafia, succeeds while RM fails?

That depends on why RM failed, actually.

[ToonyMan]

Is it wrong for me to be bitter that ToonMafia, which operates on basically the same principle as Ridiculous Mafia, succeeds while RM fails?

I don't know.  DON'T HATE ME.  IT'S NOT LIKE I CHEATED YOU IN THIS GAM--OH WAIT.  Sorry.

[Mr.Person]

Before I forget, I would like to be in the next game, since others are doing that here.