Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

Keep it as is

3 (12%)

Change it to a full Jester, with game-end on win

1 (4%)

Change it to a full Jester, but without game-end on win

5 (20%)

Change it to a full Jester, with game-end on win AFTER day 3

3 (12%)

Change it to a Jester with the loss of the Next Day phase

4 (16%)

Remove it entirely

9 (36%)

Other (explain)

0 (0%)

Total Members Voted: 25

[JoshuaFH]

I somewhat disapprove of the new roles.

Does the bodyguard get to choose which of the three actions he does? or is he assigned them?

[Mephansteras]

I somewhat disapprove of the new roles.

Does the bodyguard get to choose which of the three actions he does? or is he assigned them?

Why do you disapprove?

It's assigned. The whole point being that I can assign different weights to the roles this way. For example, a bodyguard who guards against multiple attacks is less powerful then one who kills the attacker, so they'd have different weights.

[JoshuaFH]

I mean, we have a ton of roles already, and I don't want this to get more complicated than it already is.

[Alexhans]

I agree with Josh...

less PRs and more scumhunting.

[Rysith]

I think I agree with Webadict that Silent Specter is bad, unless they had access to Dead Chat as well. Otherwise, they are essentially relegated to lurking, which they can do without a role anyway.

[webadict]

I think I agree with Webadict that Silent Specter is bad, unless they had access to Dead Chat as well. Otherwise, they are essentially relegated to lurking, which they can do without a role anyway.

It's basically a lame (Or rather, a dumb [har har]) person. Just do an unknown role for a ghost. Also, do we ever find the body of the ghost? And it turns out the killer combo doesn't work. I thought Operative got an item.

[Pandarsenic]

What if the town ghost can't send or receive PMs?

[Alexhans]

I think the dead chat should just be a discussion chat...

Forget the medium... it only helps town too much.

[Mephansteras]

I think the dead chat should just be a discussion chat...

Forget the medium... it only helps town too much.

I don't know. It helps, certainly, but I'm not sure it's as powerful as, say, an Agent.

[Alexhans]

dude... What's the point of kills if you do NOT shut up a player?

and it's one more unique claim for town...

I still think that if you MC on day 1 you can easyly find scum.

[webadict]

Let's try it next time, when I'm NOT scum.

[Mephansteras]

Perhaps its time for another Role vote. See what things people want in and what they'd like to see go.

[Mephansteras]

Ok, here is the voting sheet. I've included all current and proposed roles. Feel free to vote Yes or No for each role.

Vote Sheet under spoiler:

Spoiler (click to show/hide)

Name	Include
Mind Shield	Y
Townsperson	Y
Agent	Y
Detective	Y
Telepath	Y
Protector	Y
Paranoid War Vet	Y
Bodyguard	Y
Mad Scientist	Y
Medium	Y
Enchanter	Y
Warlock	Y
Psychic Warden	Y
Aggressive Vet	Y
Reporter	Y
Kook	Y
Disciple Of Truth	Y
Bodyguard Varients	Y
Ghost	Y
Twisted Soul	Y
Silent Specter	Y
Cultist	Y
Cult Leader	Y
Mind Knfe	Y
Child	Y
Watcher	Y
Psi-Hunter	Y
Doppelganger	Y
Doppelganger Leader	Y
Advanced Doppelganger	Y
Controlled Doppelganger	Y
Alien Exterminator	Y
Alien Agent Seeker	Y
Alien Doppelganger Hunter	Y
Alien Survivor	Y
Alien Operative	Y
Alien Scientist	Y

If you have any questions about a role, check out its description on the First Page. If that doesn't answer your questions, just ask.

[webadict]

Answer Sheet

Spoiler (click to show/hide)

Name	Include
Mind Shield	Y, if Telepath result is random (If Survive, then only Kill, Protect, and Find appear) instead of not given
Townsperson	Y
Agent	Y
Detective	Y
Telepath	Y
Guardian	Y
Paranoid War Vet	Y
Bodyguard	Y
Mad Scientist	N
Medium	Y
Enchanter	N
Warlock	Y
Psychic Warden	Y
Aggressive Vet	Y
Reporter	Y
Kook	Y
Disciple Of Truth	N
Bodyguard Varients	Y, if random
Ghost	N
Twisted Soul	N
Silent Specter	N
Cultist	N
Cult Leader	N
Mind Knfe	N
Child	N
Watcher	N
Psi-Hunter	N
Doppelganger	Y
Doppelganger Leader	Y
Advanced Doppelganger	Y
Controlled Doppelganger	N
Alien Exterminator	Y
Alien Agent Seeker	Y
Alien Doppelganger Hunter	Y
Alien Survivor	Y
Alien Operative	Y
Alien Scientist	N

[Twiggie]

Spoiler (click to show/hide)

Name	Include
Mind Shield	Y
Townsperson	Y
Agent	Y
Detective	Y
Telepath	Y
Protector	Y
Paranoid War Vet	Y
Bodyguard	Y
Mad Scientist	Y
Medium	N
Enchanter	N
Warlock	N
Psychic Warden	Y
Aggressive Vet	Y
Reporter	Y
Kook	Y
Disciple Of Truth	Y
Bodyguard Varients	Y
Ghost	N
Twisted Soul	N
Silent Specter	N
Cultist	N
Cult Leader	N
Mind Knfe	Y
Child	N
Watcher	Y
Psi-Hunter	Y
Doppelganger	Y
Doppelganger Leader	Y
Advanced Doppelganger	Y
Controlled Doppelganger	Y
Alien Exterminator	Y
Alien Agent Seeker	N
Alien Doppelganger Hunter	N
Alien Survivor	Y
Alien Operative	Y
Alien Scientist	Y