Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[bob_smith]

I'll try to make this as clear as possible, as my last post was messy...
Facts - Either way, All of these are true:

• LCH or Criminal Mastermind must have killed Inaluct.
• Alexhans is either insane through looking at Cheetar, the LCH, or I am the LCH.
• Webadict is the Criminal Mastermind, found on the first day.

Death Results
If Alexhans is insane through looking at Cheetar either:

• Cheetar killed the White Mage, Inaluct.
• Webadict killed the White Mage, Inaluct.

If I am the LCH, then I killed the Necromancer, Inaluct.


Question: Does the Master Detective say a random name if the Criminal Mastermind killed the victim?
If the answer to this question is no, then only Cheetar or I could have killed Inaluct.

Edit: If killing still continues after Webadict and I are dead, kill Cheetar. I know he's the LCH.

[JoshuaFH]

Question: Does the Master Detective say a random name if the Criminal Mastermind killed the victim?

Any person killed by the CM is done in such a way as to leave NO evidence whatsoever. The AMD, if wanting to investigate this person, instead of telling everyone, would admit defeat and his action is made defunct.

In other words, no.

[bob_smith]

'Nother Question, my calculations must be off. If Alexhans was insane, then he would see both the killer, and the victim's profession opposite, correct?

Edit: Also, what are the opposites of Cop Enabler, Amnesiamancer, and Alarmomancer?

[JoshuaFH]

'Nother Question, my calculations must be off. If Alexhans was insane, then he would see both the killer, and the victim's profession opposite, correct?

Well, it's hard to determine "opposite" because not everyone has a clear opposite, I should change the wording to "inaccurate" or "false", because it better describes what you're saying.

[bob_smith]

Question: If Alexhans was insane, would he see both the killer's name and victim's profession inaccurately?
If not, which one would be false?

[JoshuaFH]

Question: If Alexhans was insane, would he see both the killer's name and victim's profession inaccurately?
If not, which one would be false?

In the case of insanity, as you've described, yes, the AMD is given entirely incorrect information, on whole.

The only time this isn't the case would be if he were looking at the LCH, where he is always given the "townie" result, regardless of sanity.

[Jackrabbit]

Are you running another round after this? I'm in if so.

[bob_smith]

Could the Cop Enabler, Amnesiamancer, or Alarmomancer be seen by an insane AMD as a Necromancer?

[JoshuaFH]

Could the Cop Enabler, Amnesiamancer, or Alarmomancer be seen by an insane AMD as a Necromancer?

Generally, an insane AMD could see anyone as any other member of any faction, except the correct one.

There is a very weird loophole in the rules though pertaining to this, and you get a cookie if you can spot it.

[Pandarsenic]

Could the Cop Enabler, Amnesiamancer, or Alarmomancer be seen by an insane AMD as a Necromancer?

Generally, an insane AMD could see anyone as any other member of any faction, except the correct one.

There is a very weird loophole in the rules though pertaining to this, and you get a cookie if you can spot it.

Is it that there's a chance the person he scans could either give a result he's gotten before or show up as the Lovecraftian Horror?

[JoshuaFH]

Could the Cop Enabler, Amnesiamancer, or Alarmomancer be seen by an insane AMD as a Necromancer?

Generally, an insane AMD could see anyone as any other member of any faction, except the correct one.

There is a very weird loophole in the rules though pertaining to this, and you get a cookie if you can spot it.

Is it that there's a chance the person he scans could either give a result he's gotten before or show up as the Lovecraftian Horror?

He could never deduce that someone's the LCH, because it contradicts the rules given, but yes, he could get a result he's gotten before.

[Pandarsenic]

Well, you were saying there's a weird loophole, and you said that he could see the target as ANY member of ANY faction, meaning that the inherently impossible result of seeing someone as a Lovecraftian Horror SHOULD be possible.

[JoshuaFH]

Don't take my absent-mindedness at face value.

[Pandarsenic]

Could the Cop Enabler, Amnesiamancer, or Alarmomancer be seen by an insane AMD as a Necromancer?

Generally, an insane AMD could see anyone as any other member of any faction, except the correct one.

There is a very weird loophole in the rules though pertaining to this, and you get a cookie if you can spot it.

Is it that there's a chance the person he scans could either give a result he's gotten before or show up as the Lovecraftian Horror?

He could never deduce that someone's the LCH, because it contradicts the rules given, but yes, he could get a result he's gotten before.

Well, you were saying there's a weird loophole, and you said that he could see the target as ANY member of ANY faction, meaning that the inherently impossible result of seeing someone as a Lovecraftian Horror SHOULD be possible.

Don't take my absent-mindedness at face value.

THIS IS CONFUSINGS ME. ARGHBLBLBL.

Wait, so guys, fill me in... how do we know the White Mage is dead and webadict is the Criminal Mastermind again?

[bob_smith]

Alexhans is the AMD, it was revealed earlier. He said he found Webadict was the Criminal Mastermind, implying it was on the first day. Alexhans then searched Cheetar, coming up with townie.

If Cheetar made Alexhans go insane by being the Lovecraftian Horror, the victim could be anyone except a person with a mafia role.
Otherwise, I killed Inaluct, who would be the Necromancer, making me the LCH.