Thanks
I do, however, have a remark...
Which ones constitute "best" can be decided as easily as "the ones someone took the trouble to wikify".
Wikis aren't really designed as suggestion boards. Features that Toady will implement and already has the design mapped out for can be put into a wiki, but wikis don't match the needs of a suggestion system. A great way to do suggestions is by putting them into a message board (forum) into distinguishable groupings (like this thread is attempting).
To post a new suggestion, a user should go to the appropriate subsection and search for that suggestion to see if it has already been posted. These rules should be available via a sticky.
Google Moderator suggestions should have links to suggestion threads perhaps. This way, popular suggestions will be discussed and detailed making it clear and concise for Toady.
The beauty of Google Moderator is that the most popular suggestions bubble to the top, while the least popular get lost in the dogpile.
This system shows your users that you really are building it for them, and that they have a say in how it's built. This is most important to an indie game community, because it keeps them
active and excited.
(p.s. can anyone link Toady or ThreeToe to this thread?)