Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[LASD]

I am a Dwarf, Rooster is either a moron, another dwarfy backstabber for no reason, or an elf.

I would go for inexperienced. And saying that people are morons doesn't do any good to anyone.

Also, thinking who was killed and who wasn't, I'm starting to feel that at least one of our most active dwarves is in fact an elf. I base this on the fact that for the elves killing one of the active townies to weaken discussion is a great move, unless they're completely on the wrong tracks... well, that's another option.

Think about it.

[Pandarsenic]

Perhaps.

I'm thinking maybe we should blast Rooster, though. Whether he's an elf or a dwarf, nothing of value will be lost. <_<

[Shades]

That comment makes me suspicious of you pandarsenic. The fact he is clearly a tracker makes him a dwarf, and you would normally strike me as someone who would realise that and realise it's not in our best interests to lynch known town unless they start lieing.

Of course it's always possible both him and LASD are elves and it's a fairly cunning play by them but I doubt it as it seems overly risky.

[Rooster]

Nope, I'm a moronic ambusher. If elves won't attack LASD they will attack me.
Clearly it seems that my inexperienced play was moronic, but when I whink about it now, it quite wasn't. Unless of course our elvish players have IQ 200+
I vote Pandarsenic

It obviously looks like I'm a dwarf, yet you claim that I'm not. Remember the first ambusher and what he did? We shouldn't repeat that.

LASD: Believe me, you won't die this turn. Clearly you will get a bodyguard or something else. It's probable that I die now, whether by lynching or at night.

[qwertyuiopas]

Pandarsenic is a dwarf, but friend or foe is unknown.

[Rooster]

How can you know that he's a dwarf?

If you're sure about it I'll unvote him

[Mephansteras]

Here is my initial analysis of our situation:

First, these are the people who voted for FoboslC. Since the elves KNEW he was a dwarf, it's a safe bet that most or all of them voted for him. That makes people on this list our most likely suspects. They are listed in the order they voted.

• Shades
• Mephansteras
• Rooster
• LASD
• Nuke9.13
• a1s
• Org
• Cheetar
• Zaithmaister
• Karlito

Interestingly, neither of the victims from last night were on that list.

And here are the people who abstained from voting ( in no particular order)
Pandarsenic
qwertyuiopas
Flintus
Alexhans
inaluct
penguinofhonor
A_Fey_Dwarf

There is a decent chance that there is an elf hiding among them, but for now these people are all low on my list of suspects.

LASD and Rooster are also low, based on what they've said. It could all be a tricky elf plot, of course, but for now I'll assume not.
Since querty and Pandar didn't vote for the lynch, I'm currently inclined to believe querty's claim that Pandar is a dwarf.

I'm not an elf, or an elf sympathizer. So I'm off the list (hopefully someone else has checked me so the rest of you can believe that too).

So, that leaves:

• Shades
• Nuke9.13
• a1s
• Org
• Cheetar
• Zaithmaister
• Karlito

I'm most suspicious of Shades. He's been very vocal, but not necessarily helpful. And he started the bandwagon against Foboslc. Granted, that was an odd bandwagon since he seemed to want to be lynched, but it's all I've really got right now.

The rest of the people on that list have been fairly quiet, or posting a bit but not contributing all that much. So I'm pretty suspicious of everyone.

To pick the three most likely elves, I'd say:
Shades - Vocal and started the bandwagon
Zaithmaister - Joined the bandwagon but has said pretty much nothing
Nuke9.13 - I didn't like the wording used to join the bandwagon

So, unless people say something to convince me otherwise, I vote Shades

[Shades]

Your logic is sound, there is not much I can say to argue against it other than to roleclaim. I will if it comes to that but for now I'll see what others think.

[penguinofhonor]

We've lost 3 non-elves in the first day. This isn't going that well, but hopefully the child and sheriff are working on figuring out who's who.

I'll wait a little bit to vote so everyone being voted against can retaliate.

[qwertyuiopas]

I can't help narrow things down until tomorrow(as the topic is locked at night), and I really don't want to help kill dwarves.

[Pandarsenic]

Shades, Rooster is NOT clearly a dwarf. Take note:

You watch as LASD goes over to Mephansteras' house.

I'm quoting a message now. Yes you guessed it I'm a dwarf with a role.

Mephansteras watch out. LASD is either a role dwarf or an elf!

His quote is not directly stated as being from webadict; this leads me to believe it MAY be a fabricated act of elfiness; this is my primary suspicion of him. In addition, getting dwarf guards on an elf (LASD) would be a skillful elven ploy.

More thinking for now, I'll decide my vote later. Just a warning, I AM GONE OVER THE WEEKEND. So, yeah.

[webadict]

Would you like a replacement?

[Pandarsenic]

No need. I'll be back Sunday and there's a CHANCE I'll be able to log in once a night.

[Karlito]

Shades, Rooster is NOT clearly a dwarf. Take note:

You watch as LASD goes over to Mephansteras' house.

I'm quoting a message now. Yes you guessed it I'm a dwarf with a role.

Mephansteras watch out. LASD is either a role dwarf or an elf!

His quote is not directly stated as being from webadict; this leads me to believe it MAY be a fabricated act of elfiness; this is my primary suspicion of him. In addition, getting dwarf guards on an elf (LASD) would be a skillful elven ploy.

Nice job spotting that quote.  While it wouldn't be too hard to add in the tags to make it appear as if the quote were from webadict, the lack of any metadata at all is very suspicious.

[qwertyuiopas]

I won't be available tomorrow night(but I will be in the morning)