shouldnt all this kind of stuff be engravable?
in granite of the year 495 urist mcuristurist the axedwarf battled gobby gob gob the goblin during the 12731678th siege of smellypeaks
urist stabbed gobby in the guts, gobby ripped off urists arm, urist decapitated gobby etc.
it all seems like the kind of thing that dwarves would "write" about, with the major points covered. would sure make for more interesting engravings than yet more masterful depictions of squares
I would think the engraving would be a depiction of a single line from a combat log, since engravings are static in time. I can imagine combat logs being parsed into a very short summary of a battle, and possibly being entered into the available pool of legends. For example, one day of a very famous battle might be distilled by all but the most historically-minded dwarves as:
In 2nd Malachite of 1863, Cog Chamberlain's Squad "The Mains of Iron" killed 30 goblins
In 3rd Malachite of 1863, the Squad "The Fences of Pickett" was annhihilated!
So each dwarf might be remembered for
one action in a battle - one of his thirty kills, for example, but the details of that kill would be part of the story. You take that action, pair it with a little more information about the fight (say, the outcome from the combat log) and it makes a nice little history lesson:
The engraving is a masterful image of a dwarf and a goblin. The dwarf is shooting the goblin in the eye with a crossbow. This relates to Cog Battletoad slaying the goblin swordmaster Nizhniy Tagil in the battle of Boatmurdered in Felsite of 208, with the legendary iron crossbow The Flames of Iron. The goblins fled the field of battle!
This would require creating a second layer of legends. The top layer would be "Battle of Boatmurdered, Felsite 208 - goblins fled the field of battle" but there would be a sub-legend for each of the following events:
- Death of a legendary dwarf
- Death of a legendary foe
- Naming of a weapon
- Death of a dwarf holding a named weapon
- Death of a megabeast
- The death of any dwarf who has made more than N kills already in the battle
- The death of any foe who has killed more than N dwarves already
- Some critical hits ("Oy, did you see that?! I'll be telling my grandkids about that one.")
If the events can get scores for importance, then the legend of a given battle would include only the top 25 or so scores, giving engravers a huge library of events to choose from. If the engraver has some latitude to adjust scores (for personal friends or dwarves of the same faith) then you could end up with engravers distorting history based on their unique biases. Hrmm. Maybe this belongs in the suggestions board instead of here.