On a scale from 0 to 0, how ironic were you when you lumped Mahouka with the likes of AOT or KLK?
On a scale of "Mahouka seems really popular and hyped."
Wha? I've heard nothing but bad things about it O_o
It's got a hardcore group of fans out there, there was mega-hype when it first aired, though it's shifting towards the haters bit by bit as more people check it out who weren't fans of the novels / manga.
Mahouka fans don't take criticism of the series well, worse than SAO fans even. And this even extends to the authors. SAO's author has publicly acknowledged in interviews that the series has a lot of flaws, so he's at least aware about it, acknowledges issues and can therefore grow as a writer, whereas I heard that Mahouka's author is a completely shithead in interviews if anyone dares note any problems with his work: i.e. the author is every bit as insecure and immature as the work suggests.
The author's terrible behavior in interviews should put the nail in the coffin of the "this
must be a parody" line of thought, and his ultra-defensiveness if anyone criticizes Tatsuya (who shares the same initials as the author), who is pretty much synonymous with the series, makes it abundantly clear that Tatsuya is an author's proxy / gary-stu / self-insert / fantasy wank character.