@Chaoswizkid:
Is Rosario + Vampire good? It looks like a harem romcom with "some" supernatural elements that don't really matter.
Toony, that's pretty much exactly what the first season of Rosario + Vampire is. The manga and the second season are both quite a bit darker, and focus much more on the fighting and spoilers.
What Flying Dice said, except the second season of the anime is also bad for the same reason that the first season of the anime is bad. Bad because bad. I've harped on enough about it.
The manga has some definite redeeming qualities. The big thing is that it's definitely got a harem romcom highschool drama deal going on, and yeah, there are a bunch of fights, and it feels all tropey and stuff, but that's all on the surface. If you take a step back, you realize that it's not just another "everything works out great in the end!" story. It's almost a deconstruction, except it doesn't focus enough on it to be a proper deconstruction, but its there.
I enjoyed R+V and I'm still enjoying it. It gets past most of its silliness much faster than in the anime and you get an impression of "Oh, man... if I think about it... that's not good at all..." It's a very atypical shounen action-romance, I guess. I'm not trying to sell it really hard because it really isn't for everyone. *shrug*
As for "supernatural elements", I'm not sure what you mean. There being monsters is a pretty big deal, although it mostly just plays out in the fights (until then it's more of a setting/premise thing and plays a back seat to high school drama). There's magic, but you don't see that for a while. I mean, there's supernatural elements all over (a good portion of it is about being a monster high school), I'm just not sure what you'd classify as "don't really matter".