No, A counter-proposal implies disagreement inherently, therefore your proposal has not passed!
Not really. A counter-proposal indicates disagreement, but it does not mean that the person is AGAINST the proposal. Cthulhu may have desired a seperate course of action, but have choosen to support my proposal because his belief that it would be better to accept my proposal and adpat it for the good of the game. He may have preferred his very own proposal, but he saw that my proposal is also good for society and therefore accepted it.
Since my proposal is valid, I'd would hereby begin calcuating what Proposals has been passed/fail after the offical adoption of my Proposal on November 3rd, 2008 11:43:55 PM. I'll also calcuate what proposals would have passed/fail before the adoption of my Proposal...but that these proposals would be declared inactive except if:
I propose that this previous Proposal be declared 'retroactive' for all proposals that was proposed since the begining of this game. This way, we can ensure that duro gets renamed to Mr. Capitan as soon as possible.
****
Cthulhu, from November 02, 2008, 06:08:07 PM to November 03, 2008, 06:08:07 PM
I propose Duro change his name to Captain Goatse, because, seriously, where did that guy go? I haven't seen him in forever, and his name always made me smile. It was a slightly unnerved smile, but a smile nonetheless.
Cheeetar, inaluct, neo1096: FOR
Boksi: ABSTAIN
Dwarfaholic: NO
Aqizzar, Hawkfrost: ILLEGAL VOTE, not counted
4-1, Proposal Would Pass, If "Retroactive" Proposal is Agreed To.
Cthulhu, November 02, 2008, 06:49:03 PM to November 03, 2008, 06:49:03 PM
Proposal: The moderator must vote on all proposals in divisive and self-contradictory ways, attempting to fulfill a goal decided in a separate vote.
Cheeetar, inaluct, Dwarfaholic, neo1096: FOR
Nobody voted Abstain or No.
4-0, Proposal Would Pass, If "Retroactive" Proposal is Agreed To.
(more later, be right back)