Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Krr1ss]

For the record: I think fishing is probably not a good idea. I think town should conceal and lie about their roles if that furthers their goals. Still, I'm not sure I ever really see scum try and rolefish directly in a game like this.

I second this. Town is encouraged to lie but I believe that there is a need for cooperation as well. Why? Cuz my role is useless otherwise

I think that the best way for town is to not lie but not tell the truth unless nessecary.

What are the chances that scum has something in their arsenal to deal with troublesome roles? I'd say pretty high. So unless there's direct benefit to saying things like I did, then I think it's better not to. I am forced to reveal some things otherwise I'd be vanilla.

Lying is usually going to be anti town though. There are times where lying is going to benefit town. I think it is better for town to reveal how many hats they have in order to prevent Hat Victory.

Where is Imp? I'm not allowed to do any scumhunting until she shows up to tell everyone how awesome I am. It's in my contract.

I think Imp's internet's still down.

I lost against Urist (Magma Mater) because he lied. He was town, I was scum.

What I said was that lying is usually anti town and that there are cases where lying is protown. There is a time and place for lying but you have to know what lie will benefit town.
Everyone: Do you think that everyone should claim how many hats they have in order to prevent Hat Victory?

How many hats are in the game? 12? How much is needed for hat victory? 6?

[Magma Mater]

For the record: I think fishing is probably not a good idea. I think town should conceal and lie about their roles if that furthers their goals. Still, I'm not sure I ever really see scum try and rolefish directly in a game like this.

I second this. Town is encouraged to lie but I believe that there is a need for cooperation as well. Why? Cuz my role is useless otherwise

I think that the best way for town is to not lie but not tell the truth unless nessecary.

What are the chances that scum has something in their arsenal to deal with troublesome roles? I'd say pretty high. So unless there's direct benefit to saying things like I did, then I think it's better not to. I am forced to reveal some things otherwise I'd be vanilla.

Lying is usually going to be anti town though. There are times where lying is going to benefit town. I think it is better for town to reveal how many hats they have in order to prevent Hat Victory.

Where is Imp? I'm not allowed to do any scumhunting until she shows up to tell everyone how awesome I am. It's in my contract.

I think Imp's internet's still down.

I lost against Urist (Magma Mater) because he lied. He was town, I was scum.

What I said was that lying is usually anti town and that there are cases where lying is protown. There is a time and place for lying but you have to know what lie will benefit town.
Everyone: Do you think that everyone should claim how many hats they have in order to prevent Hat Victory?

I don't see how that would be helpful. Town who are trying to achieve a hat victory will likely lie. It'll just be a distraction.

[TricMagic]

Agentt

NQT for looking like they are fishing for roles!

Though fishing for roles doesn't really matter in a game where everyone is PR.

What gave you the impression I was fishing for roles?

For the record: I think fishing is probably not a good idea. I think town should conceal and lie about their roles if that furthers their goals. Still, I'm not sure I ever really see scum try and rolefish directly in a game like this.


TricMagic

On a side note, ♫ NQT NQT will you let down your hair? ♫

♫ Starting the day with a double vote isn't something I want to see. What guarantee that you aren't a mafia sheep? ♫

I can theoretically build up to 6 votes on you, so... Crescendo or die. That vote power has to be a passive one.

This is a really weird attack line. Now, are you fishing for more info about my vote power, voting me for having two votes when you also apparently have two votes, or are you just being wacky?

The second. Mine is hat based, hence getting rid of the attached vote shot immediately. You just started with one and can apparently ramp up votes, which is not a town power, it's a selfish power.

[TricMagic]

For the record I have the one hat. I assume that's true for everyone but mafia? 12 is an odd amount of hats with 14 people.
Granted there is one person who can't get a hat victory so. Do they have a hat?

[Crystalizedmire]

What I said was that lying is usually anti town and that there are cases where lying is protown. There is a time and place for lying but you have to know what lie will benefit town.
Everyone: Do you think that everyone should claim how many hats they have in order to prevent Hat Victory?

How many hats are in the game? 12? How much is needed for hat victory? 6?

It's five.

I don't see how that would be helpful. Town who are trying to achieve a hat victory will likely lie. It'll just be a distraction.

Got it.
I would like to see others input as well.

For the record I have the one hat. I assume that's true for everyone but mafia? 12 is an odd amount of hats with 14 people.
Granted there is one person who can't get a hat victory so. Do they have a hat?

Everyone starts with 1 hat except for two players who get 0 hats is what it says in the op.
I think Tricmagic is town. Based on what everybody else says about Tricmagic, he's more aggressive and wacky as town and also I'm pretty sure he is wacky and aggressive this game.

[Magma Mater]

For the record I have the one hat. I assume that's true for everyone but mafia? 12 is an odd amount of hats with 14 people.
Granted there is one person who can't get a hat victory so. Do they have a hat?

Hats were distributed randomly. Two people just got unlucky.

[Krr1ss]

You guys are free to decide for yourselves but I'll say I have one hat. It's also useful for scum more than town.

[TricMagic]

... Thinking on it the hat I got would let you beat Hatlo. NQT do you desire hats?

[Crystalizedmire]

When I said this:

What I said was that lying is usually anti town and that there are cases where lying is protown. There is a time and place for lying but you have to know what lie will benefit town.
Everyone: Do you think that everyone should claim how many hats they have in order to prevent Hat Victory?

I meant days after this one since everyone either has 1 hat or no hat.
Sorry for the confusion.

[notquitethere]

Crystal

Everyone: Do you think that everyone should claim how many hats they have in order to prevent Hat Victory?

From D2 on, I think if only some players claim hat numbers, it might make hat theft easier. Also, I would assume a player after a hat victory would just lie about the number of hats they had.


Tricmagic

can apparently ramp up votes, which is not a town power, it's a selfish power.

Extra votes is more often a town power than a scum power, but naturally it can be either. I said ramping up votes was a possibility. I also said something else entirely was a possibility. In sum, I said nothing. As such, you're voting for me based on you own poor reading comprehension. That's okay, I misread things too sometimes. You can stand down.

... Thinking on it the hat I got would let you beat Hatlo. NQT do you desire hats?

I'm planning to win the game through pursuing the town wincondition, if that's what you're asking. If you're offering me a hat though, of course the more power the better.

[Crystalizedmire]

Salvatore Monday, answer my question: Do you have any reads right now?

[Imp]

Hi all!  I exist and have internet and a place for my computer set up.

I also have vital appointments to schedule for updating DL and stuff because new state.  And I drove over 1300 miles in 44 hours, counting rest breaks.  12 hours of sleep maybe fixed me, we'll see!  I'll catch up in a few hours when I can actually be here.  Hope everyone's having fun!

Anything vital better not need me for a couple hours yet, I may have people to help and people who can help me and stuff but I have no time to read nuthin' yet.  See you soon!  Everyone better be having fun!  FBYOR7 Wooo!

[TricMagic]

Tricmagic

can apparently ramp up votes, which is not a town power, it's a selfish power.

Extra votes is more often a town power than a scum power, but naturally it can be either. I said ramping up votes was a possibility. I also said something else entirely was a possibility. In sum, I said nothing. As such, you're voting for me based on you own poor reading comprehension. That's okay, I misread things too sometimes. You can stand down.

... NQT you just shot straight up to the top of my suspect list. That is not normal from you.

Unvote Doubt we will end up with an early hammer.. But man if that statement doesn't ping my instinct something fierce.

[EuchreJack]

Salvatore Monday, answer my question: Do you have any reads right now?

Salvatore Monday hasn't been posting normally, so they might have a post restriction. They seem to be indicating whom they suspect by "gazing upon them".

[EuchreJack]

Claim: I have an ability that can destroy a hat. Knowing Fallacy, one of you probably has a "cursed" hat of "screw the wearer".

So, if anyone wants their hat destroyed, let me know.