Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Maximum Spin]

Uhm.

You’re still part of this?

You can still solve this?

Why you makin’ like you’re gonna bounce?

I mean, I would.
Dead's dead, I'd consider my obligation to the game fulfilled. Weird that you're still posting tbh.

Anyway FallacyofUrist.

[Jim Groovester]

Like I mentioned I don't think an explicit daykill was what killed me, but thanks FoU for handwaving (and possibly intentionally misdirecting) on why it couldn't be you.

I was likely double Exhausted, which is fatal based on information Tric claimed on Day 1. I doubt it's a coincidence that an hour and a half after I claim being Exhausted I end up dead.

So whoever killed me is either TricMagic or somebody with TricMagic's abilities, which includes Imp. Based on speculation about the evil tome that allows ability copy as well, which puts page owners and tome owners under suspicion as well. I'm kind of wary about confidently saying either of those two players actually did shoot me though.

Imp, why did you double exhaust me?



I did a lazy read of the entire game. Between the alive players, I think shooting within Elephant Parade, EuchreJack, and FallacyofUrist has pretty good odds of catching scum.

[FallacyofUrist]

Ha, ha, ha, ha.

Why do I post arguments if nobody cares about them?

I'm not the ghostmaker. I've demonstrated on multiple levels that I'm not and can't be the ghostmaker.

Until the ghostmaker is executed, every single execution is a shot in the dark.

Am I so ridiculously suspicious, just oozing some aura of unbridled suspicion, that a bandwagon is forming on me based on vibes?

Hell nah.

ToonyMan.

[Jim Groovester]

I should mention that I'll be on company travel starting Sunday and ending Thursday. I won't be completely absent but it will be more difficult than even now to pay attention to the game.

Which means a lot less now that I am dead and don't have to meaningfully participate anymore. :'|

[Maximum Spin]

I'm not the ghostmaker. I've demonstrated on multiple levels that I'm not and can't be the ghostmaker.

Until the ghostmaker is executed, every single execution is a shot in the dark.

"Hey, don't look at me, look at some OTHER guy who may not even be scum but sounds shady!", the traditional scum Fallacy argument

[FallacyofUrist]

I'm getting bandwagoned based on a meta read and vibes.

Lovely.

Sighs.

[Maximum Spin]

I'm getting bandwagoned based on a meta read and vibes.

Lovely.

Sighs.

Mafia is like a man hanging in a tree by his teeth over a precipice. His hands grasp no branch, his feet rest on no limb, and under the tree another person asks him: 'Why did Bodhidharma come to China from India?'

If the man in the tree does not answer, he fails; and if he does answer, he falls and loses his life. Now what shall he do?

[hector13]

Spoiler (click to show/hide)

[Imp]

Like I mentioned I don't think an explicit daykill was what killed me, but thanks FoU for handwaving (and possibly intentionally misdirecting) on why it couldn't be you.

I was likely double Exhausted, which is fatal based on information Tric claimed on Day 1. I doubt it's a coincidence that an hour and a half after I claim being Exhausted I end up dead.

So whoever killed me is either TricMagic or somebody with TricMagic's abilities, which includes Imp. Based on speculation about the evil tome that allows ability copy as well, which puts page owners and tome owners under suspicion as well. I'm kind of wary about confidently saying either of those two players actually did shoot me though.

Imp, why did you double exhaust me?



I did a lazy read of the entire game. Between the alive players, I think shooting within Elephant Parade, EuchreJack, and FallacyofUrist has pretty good odds of catching scum.

Wasn't me.

I do not have a way to directly and personally exhaust anyone.  I only know exhaust exists because Tric discussed it and you said you were exhausted, it's not even mentioned in the ability copy I was forced to have by Tric.  And I haven't used that one-shot, which is a day-only ability.

Tric's day ability maybe.  Maybe someone can copy/use what others reveal in some way.  I don't know.

[Imp]

And I haven't used that one-shot, which is a day night-only ability.

Sleepy.  Good luck all.

[Imp]

Like I mentioned I don't think an explicit daykill was what killed me, but thanks FoU for handwaving (and possibly intentionally misdirecting) on why it couldn't be you.

Wait.  And the mod message about your dying, you specifically were 'killed'.  we had an elim and 3 'died'.  The mod message about your death is different.  Exhaust is a way to die from what we've been told.  But you were expressly 'killed'.  If it matters.

[TricMagic]

I get the feeling it wasn't Fal. Even with hypnosis to make Jim act that doesn't mean it can self-target.

Well.. There is a world where Jim has Chat, Day, and Mimic. And hence gained a copy of my ability from the chat he put us in.

... It would have to be Toony as the partner there. Just a feeling from day 1.

[Elephant Parade]

Mechanics spec: Unless he's pulled off some kind of trick or this setup is even stranger than we think, Hector ought to be town. His infect clearly isn't a mafiakill since he's a ghost, meaning it could be a mafiakill, meaning that both it and a mafiakill could be used the same night. That would be insane.

I would be most inclined to lynch CM today because of (1) everything I said here (2) her failure to sufficiently acquit herself after (3) her quietude today (4) a small other thing. But she's supposedly dying tonight, so she goes on the backburner unless that doesn't happen.

I get some really bad vibes from Toony and I'm trying to figure out why. It's not because he suspects me—I've been playing pretty weirdly this game because of personal circumstances. But I don't like how he conducted himself at the end of D1, and I could read his interactions with FoU as spending the whole game trying to force a mislynch on the most vulnerable player.

Nevertheless, I think it's more likely that FallacyofUrist is actually just scum and Toony correctly senses that. Based on their ability to trade random items, their D1 itemfishing for cards, and the "Sasuga" keyword (anime = most likely FoU, Tric, or Toony, and FoU's claim already has an anime theme), I think they were behind the casino, which makes them acting as if they weren't awfully strange.

The only issue is that I don't think FoU is behind the ghosts, which are the most pressing problem ATM. If everyone's assumptions are wrong and the ghosts are actually caused by, say, a town player who can revive exactly one player during the game and keeps everyone around as a ghost until they use the power or die, please just get rid of the ghosts already, the lack of roleflips is incredibly punishing.

I think it's most likely CM who's responsible for the ghosts because she's scummy and she hasn't said anything about her role. (I know I also haven't said anything about mine besides not being responsible for the ghosts/plague/chat.)

I still need to think about everyone else.

I would vote Fallacy here but I don't want to accidentally hammer and I'm too lazy to scan the entire day for votes. @NQT: Votecount please.

[TricMagic]

Nevermind my last post. Really Elephant? For the record it's a meat thing, not an Anime thing. I just don't want to add the 'e' so used 'a'. Just in case there was something that happened if it was said in thread.

[Elephant Parade]

Nevermind my last post. Really Elephant? For the record it's a meat thing, not an Anime thing. I just don't want to add the 'e' so used 'a'. Just in case there was something that happened if it was said in thread.

Oh. OK. That makes me less certain.