Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Imp]

Do you have a second wincon already? I can either give you a new one, or greatly empower one you already have. I already have an action in mind for tonight, but I can always pencil you in for later!

I believe Egan buffed me. The wording of the ability I gained is... concerning.

Egan, inquiring minds want to know, yes/no maybeso?

[Imp]

Well, I expected it to be LYLO or endgame today, and I'm pleasantly surprised to see that it's not.

Last night I gifted both my playing cards to EuchreJack, just in case it would give him more votes to contest the scum.

It was a bit of a flail action, but I didn't really see anything else productive I could do.

I received two cards. Fallacy and I could probably each name one, if that would help.

Anyone able to do anything with the cards? I believe that I now have four.

Jim claims can eat items and maybe benefits from doing so.

Otherwise I didn't spot anyone who said could use.

[Egan_BW]

Do you have a second wincon already? I can either give you a new one, or greatly empower one you already have. I already have an action in mind for tonight, but I can always pencil you in for later!

I believe Egan buffed me. The wording of the ability I gained is... concerning.

Egan, inquiring minds want to know, yes/no maybeso?

What do you want to know again

[Imp]

What did you do last night, Egan?

[TricMagic]

I'd like to see fullclaims from Toony and Max

1: Saying Imp is posting too much. You have seen Imp when they're posting walls of text right? This split is actually pretty good flow.
2: Claiming you can mess with spheres, then asking for full claims in thread. Max isn't the ghostmaker, Egan is. Or rather Max got hit with something by Egan producing this effect, and subsequently died.
3: Still waiting for third strike.

[Elephant Parade]

I'd like to see fullclaims from Toony and Max

1: Saying Imp is posting too much. You have seen Imp when they're posting walls of text right? This split is actually pretty good flow.
2: Claiming you can mess with spheres, then asking for full claims in thread. Max isn't the ghostmaker, Egan is. Or rather Max got hit with something by Egan producing this effect, and subsequently died.
3: Still waiting for third strike.

I don't want to dwell on this but it's still enough posts that it makes it harder for me to read the flow of the conversation.

I'm asking for full claims so I can figure out who the ghostmaker is. I don't think it's Egan.

Re: EJ: I'm thinking about it. But regardless, I don't think he can be the ghostmaker and that means he isn't a priority today.

[TricMagic]

All this talk about the ghostmaker is a smokescreen. I've already given my opinion on what happened. The only way you remove the ghosts is to kill Max. Saying other people could be when Egan is the one who died N0 is just ridiculous at this point..

Actually. Looking back with the search function, Fal was the one to coin that phase, and you said you don't think Fal was the ghostmaker. What's up with that combo? Other person besides me who talked about it was Toony. So this whole ghost business if it isn't Max is within the four of us

Looking at the end of day result,. Acutally, when did Jack dump an item? His vote counted for 1 yesterday. They haven't shown up today.

[ToonyMan]

PFW

@Tric:
We need to know player's flips because analysis is much more difficult otherwise. Not having this information is us wandering in smokescreen, not the other way around. I agree with this sentiment and it's what we should be voting today. It's pretty likely that they destroyed Hector too, so we sort of have an actual mafiakill victim to avenge for once!

[Maximum Spin]

Yeah, so every single living player can tell me why they don't think it's Jack or why Jack doesn't comfortably fit into a lot of potential scum teams.

Just so we're clear, I didn't answer because I don't not think it's Jack. It could be Jack. It could even be Jack twice.

[Imp]

Yeah, so every single living player can tell me why they don't think it's Jack or why Jack doesn't comfortably fit into a lot of potential scum teams.

Just so we're clear, I didn't answer because I don't not think it's Jack. It could be Jack. It could even be Jack twice.

Twice how, means what?

[Imp]

NQT, is the vote count end of day 2 correct, showing Eucherjack having one vote, not 1.5?

[TricMagic]

If it is Jack lied day 1. They only had one vote yesterday too.

[Elephant Parade]

I'd like to see fullclaims from Toony and Max

Sure I don't mind doing most at this point.

Who Framed Roger Rabbit But Everyone Is Played By Eddie Murphy

Variety -> Niche -> Improve -> Selfless -> Peek

I started the game with Eight of Hearts which I traded with FoU on D2.

I have a bunch of ACME Props that do different things peek focused, I would like to keep most to myself.
I can also give someone acting lessons that do different things improve focused, same thing.
My Toon False Confidence means I can't be protected and fruits don't work on me, I already admitted this in the private chat so it doesn't matter.

On N1 -
1. I used my ACME Branded Dolittle Stethoscope and learned that Vermilion's corpse was missing.
2. I was invited to a group chat by Jim that had Tric/Jim/Max for the cycle.
3. Someone tried to steal or mutate me, but my Hand Buzzer stopped them, unfortunately it was used up by doing this.

On N2 -
1. I got 0.1 votes from presumably Jack.
2. I tried giving one of my acting lessons to Imp but instead I learned "nothing".
3. I received a catear headband hat, which I assume was from FoU.

I think that's everything. I need to sleep soon but my tuned instinct is to trust Elephant over Max here, although I do not know if that is correct!

I think I forgot to comment on this so: seems legit. My only concern is that you're keeping so much to your chest at what feels to me like endgame, but there are reasonable explanations for that. Also, I notice you left my action and part of its immediate consequences out of your N2 summary here, though you alluded to it earlier; mind saying why?

[Imp]

My thoughts about jack.

Early eager to discuss card and page, participate in trade, didn't seem protective of either item.  Announces and proves 1.5 vote on Max, never says if always has 1.5 votes.  Comments d2 about the 0.1 vote adjustments, soft claim.

Post 111 points out indirectly play style may be doing all the right things, formulaic - might not be intended.

Chases ghost stuff a bit, fairly interested in Hector.  Chases reads on day 1, doesn't chase later.

Busy d2, plans then drunk, still sick, work fatigue.  Big play style change by post 347.  Calls game broken, asks how town can lose, just kill everyone.  If anyone doesn't die to infection they have to dodge town vig and elim.  Seems to strongly think Hector is town, never mentions missing night kills.  Seems to think a ghost that can infect is unfair for antitown. 

Then day kills (suggesting is a town vig as mentioned earlier).  Kills Jim for weird not towny reason.  Goes back to voting max.  "Hector deserves to win".

Never seems to think Hector might not be town.  Too informed?

I want to hear more from Jack when he can.  I could vote here, def want to hear more first.

So hard to do reads pfp.  Wrote out notes by hand, hah.

[Elephant Parade]

I have a longshot theory that I don't really believe (~5% chance in my mind) but would like to raise: if there is no Mafia, or if the Mafia have no access to a traditional mafiakill (eyebrow-raising given that the OP says they do but theoretically possible via e.g. a mafiakill-disabling auto on the ghostmaker), it would be reasonably balanced for the ghostmaker to be a ghost—i.e., Egan. Both of those things are extremely unlikely, though. The only reason I'm bringing it up is that we still don't seem to have seen a traditional mafiakill, unless they targeted Imp N2 despite them claiming infection.

NQT: Is there guaranteed to be a Mafia faction in this game?