Hm. Looking through the game so far:
Fallacy seems a little strange, but like they're being strange with a purpose behind it. I don't understand what they're doing, but they're doing something. Unsure.
You, Imp, seem fairly reliable to me? You've actively questioned most posts without a clear purpose, and don't seem to be pushing for a lynch without information. Town.
Max has only posted one joke and one vague reply to a vaguer statement. Feels scummy to me, but I have zero evidence and even less room to judge for not posting much.
Interrupted mid-post - Magma, I haven't the faintest idea of what your plan is. You state that you have a lot of solid reads with no visible evidence to back any of them up. Unsure.
Also, I leave my computer and it's tabs open while doing other things. I've been doing laundry between posts.
4mask feels like they're trying to hit a post quota to avoid getting questioned for inactivity. They do have solid posts between the one-line quota ones, though. Town?
Oliver has also only posted once, which I'm unsure about.
AP has said nothing of note game-wise.
Tric feels like FoU to me, but also feels more like town to me. Maybe it's the higher activity, or it's the slightly less obtuse posts?
I might be missing people, but I feel like I should post this before I get stabbed.
Cool, thank you. Hope you don't get stabbed today, I for sure won't be doing that stabbing (I don't have a today stab at this time).
I like your reasoning.
Some of us are many-times repeat played-together players and deep which is largely why, for example, you see me barely brush against
MS. I've challenged him as intensely as I can previously in several games; I'm currently content that if he's anti-town I'm most likely going to suspect that over time, and if he is pro-town he's gonna be awesome over time. I do learn stuff from him based on what he volunteers and reacts to, but I don't learn that much about going head to head with him unless I have reason to (sometimes I do). The Max we see here, to my mind could be absolutely any alignment and anything from super intricately powerful to extremely weak, the only thing to be sure of is 'this behavior suits Max's mood and goals at this time'. I used to intensely strive against him, and he'll probably match it if I do, but I still don't figure out if he's evil or not. I'm also convinced of his usefulness being detectable within a day or two if he's pro-town, if there's not enough sign of that as time passes then I'm probably moving for his elim, or dead; perhaps others still alive do whatever they see best.
In my opinion, FoU is probably showing and exploring her character, and could be any alignment but tended before to be often scum and easily caught, rarely town and often ML. In terms of omg, if this is evil, kill them noooooow, that's usually not
Fallacy unless the role's that powerful.
Tricmagic is kinda also roleplay, but roleplays a dragon gonna maybe eat us all regardless of alignment. Also to my mind a likely more dangerous player, if anti-town. Usually been town in the games I've been in.
I haven't played with
4mask in a decade, so no opinion there but I like the feel so far this game.
My second game with
Oliver, the first was chaotic and difficult, a very confusing game and Oliver was very fast to leap at ideas and make 'without much consideration' decisions about who and what meant evil. In general that kind of thinking hurts town in B12 games, and the traps that can trick that kind of thinking can be extensive and deep; looking forward to seeing how this game goes with Oliver!
AP I have no opinion on, but think I can form an opinion over time. 'If he stays quiet end him' is my current advice, he usually has stances as good but this is fine for now, he can be busy/distracted/whatever. Be gentle with him if he thinks I'm evil - even and especially if he's the only one. He's seen me be evil more than anyone else here, he's seen me be good WAY less than anyone else who has played with me before. He's not accurate at identifying me as evil yet, but he's only played beside me when I was town once ever, and we've played like 5 games already.
Juicebox I have little experience with, think is probably a skilled player though, and typical of B12 players, so clever and deep thinking, subtle and surprising in either role.
CrystalizedMire has recently become very convincing as evil but she's still useful as town, and she's likely to play convincingly townlike regardless of her role; her observations are usually useful and present even if she's evil.
Wolfkey is completely new to me and hasn't apparently noticed our game started/decided to speak, Wolf's posting in other threads sometimes today.
My read on you,
Vermilion, is 'good enough for first contact this early in this game'. So, I want to extend to you an invitation, which others may also take as their own, which is fine.
I invite you to target me tonight (presuming I make it to N1) with anything non-lethal you can do. Sure, that's an open invitation to anyone, but it is more likely to be informative and helpful for town than harm town for people who don't have something else they decide to do with an action they could target me tonight. Umm, I'm more useful alive than dead, but killing me won't stop or change the outcome of at least Vermilion targeting me tonight, should that player choose to. Verm, you're also free to just not, you don't have to tell me you won't (like if your abilities all kill your target and you don't want me dead, just don't target me, you don't have to say that you're not gonna).
If I'm alive tomorrow I can participate in discussion (obviously) that this will likely provoke to follow up on, even if I'm dead there'll probably be clearly something to discuss for at least some of those still alive (and targeting me will NOT kill anyone N2). Verm, I would specifically like you to be one of those people/that person if you choose to and are able.
10 reads... oh,
Meter. Meter, I don't get you. A concerned Imp is a Imp that generally wants the concern dead. I want to be careful about that in high power games because I presume this is a high power game and your abilities probably die with you, this is not a personality or popularity contest to me and I already saw a lot of B12 folks are challenging to understand on first contact. But the canine part of me wants to defend territory against you, you're 'other outcast unknown'. Not necessarily evil, and I'm not getting my sometimes-feel-it 'this is the most dangerous evil in the game' sense about you - more you're inexplicable but not necessarily harmful.
Your claims alarm me and I'm still super undecided on if I target you tonight.
Author
Topic: Bring Your Own Monster (8/12) Game Over (Read 15336 times)