Well, I've seen worse D1s, but this one hasn't been great.
Couple of ways to move forward here. One way is talking about contraband, but ech... I don't like power talk D1, and most games aren't solvable. Honestly, the most suspicious thing Hector's said is that we might try to solve the game that way, tbh. Does he have a reason to want to know who has or is using contraband?
Imp claimed survivor, then swung onto someone for not taking that at face value/suggesting we might kill them anyway. Thus far, this is in character for surv-Imp, so I'm inclined to believe their claim.
Hector made reasonable points, became irate when presented with a dubious challenge, and voted in retaliation to a weak case. So far, this is in character with town!Hector... from what I remember, scum!Hector stays calm just gives town rope to hang themselves, but I haven't seen him in this kind of position as scum. So maybe NAI there - Hector has been defensive, but if he's scum, you don't catch him out by giving him something to be genuinely defensive about.
EuchreJack being extremely sensible is sometimes a bad sign, but in this case it seems a bit more like frustrated surprise at other people's posts than the
calmness that really indicates something's off with them. Sofa makes some interesting points about the possibility of a role outside of the capitalist wreckers... 3P fishing can be a bad sign D1, but for some reason I liked their thinking there. Town for now, I think they might be on our side.
Tric asking to die is in character for town!Tric. Need to see more here to be sure.
CM hasn't shown up yet, and that's in character for CM.
AnimePigeon is going to be a struggle to read, as I haven't played with them before, and they're clearly nothing like a new player. May need to read past games. There was one thing that pinged me the wrong way though... their
vote on Hector13 came across as a little opportunistic, coming straight after Imp's vote and with slightly minimal explanation. Their reasoning seemed to be that they read Hector as scum faking the exasperation and desire to remove a survivor, which is something, but again a little odd. Scum would make an instant enemy by getting into a spat with a survivor, while losing a potential friend, so it would be a very costly way to fake a town-tell, and one that would invite much more pressure from the survivor. And to be honest... I didn't read Hector as trying to do that. They seemed more concerned with defending themselves in the argument than appearing townie, to be honest
Hm... that's not much to go on, but it's something.
AnimePigeon: why did you unvote hector and switch onto CrystallizedMire
here?
Author
Topic: Maximum Spin's Soviet Mafia ENDED. (Read 5015 times)