Did you ever play with webadict?
You didn't direct this question. I can't remember if I played with wuba or not. I last played nearly a decade ago. I've read so much, and have a decent memory (that doesn't really focus on names much, more info in general)
@Imp: no I'm not going to hound you all day, especially because your latest post did move my scum-o-meter into town direction. If the trend persists I will explain why later.
My issue isn't about if you hound me or not (we're all hounds here, right? Oh 'cept for two who aren't). My concern is only if your efforts focus on one player alone. You don't have to suspect many, or share your suspicions at all times. But you really, really hurt town if you tunnel, especially if you're wrong. Even if you're right, there's still, as you say, two scum. Also, it's just lazy/easy play to tunnel. It can look like scumhunting, and it's potentially fun and easy, even profitable for scum.
If you suspect a player, what do you think is best? Barking about it immediately in the first 24 hours or waiting for them to provide more evidence before presenting your case?
I have no single answer to that, nearly everything to me is specific and context-based.
Who else is in the game?
What do I know of how they've played?
What's the entire game composition like?
Do I think any players are demoralized (imp-tip [like a pro-tip, only I'm an imp, not a pro] I prefer my game-mates to have motivation and positive emotions if possible. I'd like you all active, involved, learning, feeling challenged but not too much, hopeful even if just about how great your next game's gonna go with how much you've learned and your great ideas to try next, and ideally proud of how each has done and involved and all that good stuff)?
What are my real goals that game?
Do I think anyone else has seen what I have seen, and do I think they'd understand it and evaluate my information and myself in a way that helps my team?
How sure am I of the meaning of what I saw?
A perfect example of that was the very end of last game, when I voted sof as soon as I saw the game was ended, and explained why. I considered sof most likely mafia trying to appear Knowing (or just buddying me), or the Know, based on their behavior towards me and what specific words they said. I note that when I revealed this, I got some pushback. Max in particular strongly disagreed with my view that sof might be hinting that sof Knew (maybe because sof said 'not in the Know' - but I can think of at least 1 reason why I could have been the Know and would have chosen, at some point especially early, to claim not-knowing status. There are reasons for town to lie at certain points of play
frowns at Max and they can even be potentially good for town reasons, especially if interpreted correctly by fellow town).
But I didn't reveal my supposition of sof as possible scum or possible Know until after that game had ended. And I can't tell you when I would have revealed it as the game continued, because that would have been determined by the exact details that played out.
Author
Topic: Catfia: Dogs vs Cats Untitled Cat Game (Mafia Victory) (Read 14565 times)