Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[EuchreJack]

Day 2 Starting Votecount:
NJW2000: (0)
sofanthiel: (0)
Maxine: (0)
Snowkiller: (0)
Elephant Parade: (0)
The Canadian kitten: (0)
Crystalizedmire: (0)


Not voting: NJW2000, sofanthiel, Maxine, Snowkiller, Elephant Parade, The Canadian kitten, Crystalizedmire

Day ends on Tuesday, September 5th at 8:30pm EST, approximately 71 hours 57 minutes from now, or a HAMMER by total of FOUR (4) votes on one player.

[Elephant Parade]

Alright then. In that case I think it's most likely NJW. If there's a third party, which the OP hints at, I'd guess TCk or Maxine. If it's a three-man team instead, which the OP also hints at, then I dunno; maybe CM?

Anybody have any fancy ideas for claiming shots given/taken or are we just going to get straight to it?

[Maximum Spin]

I mean, I told you this would happen.

[Crystalizedmire]

I threw a grenade at Snowkiller and Maxine. Not my best decision in hindsight because NJW looks most suspicious now.

[Crystalizedmire]

I threw a grenade at Snowkiller and Maxine. Not my best decision in hindsight because NJW looks most suspicious now.

NJW should've bolded and coloured that

[Elephant Parade]

@CM: Were you shot?

[Elephant Parade]

Actually, a second question, CM: Near as I can tell, you hopped on every single wagon except Quarque's. In fact, I don't believe you interacted with Quarque at all. Why was that?

[The Canadian kitten]

I shot NJW when I said I was going to shoot Maxine. Mostly because I was convinced that MaxSpin is town, if that is a legitimate reason.
I am quite glad I didn't decide to shoot Maxine as I am currently undecided about how I feel about Maxine right now.

I however did not get shot during the night.

NJW


EP: Did you shoot? If so, who?
sofanthiel: Are you now going to replace Maxspin for the funny clever nicknames of other people?

Best for everyone to claim whether you shot or not, and who anyways.

[Elephant Parade]

I neither shot nor was shot.

[NJW2000]

I shot Max. The last interaction looked like Quarque was trying to distance from them, after townreading them earlier. Max only hammered them when there was no chance they’d live, which looked like an attempt to appear town.

I knew it could have been Quarque being coached into doing that, or just a random attempt to live. It would be unsubtle and obvious distancing, but after I missed Quarque’s “wildly misinterpret people and just make stuff up” approach, I wasn’t going to ignore the simplest explanation again.

Alright then. In that case I think it's most likely NJW.

The new players seem to believe you, but… care to explain why?


CanadianKitten: why did you shoot me?

[Crystalizedmire]

@CM: Were you shot?

Yes.

Actually, a second question, CM: Near as I can tell, you hopped on every single wagon except Quarque's. In fact, I don't believe you interacted with Quarque at all. Why was that?

I don't think I was on Snowkiller's bandwagon but I did volunteer to kill them. The reason I didn't interact with Quarque is because they never struck me as suspicious. Sure, they made a suspicious attack on Sofanthiel but I thought that was a genuine mistake.

[NJW2000]

Alright then. The elimination yesterday did provide some insight.

Unless it's a rather cruel and very unusual bussing play, it's hard to see Elephant Parade, sofanthiel, or The Canadian kitten as mafia. Especially not Canadian... a new player that concerned about how they appeared would probably be too nervous to bus their partner, I think. EP probably wouldn't bus a new player that hard and early. Sofa definitely would not have made this vote when they could have just joined the Maxine consensus.

That leaves Snowkiller, CM for staying on the Maxine wagon, and Maxine themselves.

Going to have to reread those... well, two.

Snowkiller: are you still here?

[Elephant Parade]

PFP

No, Max hammered because he was worried about someone blowing up the game with a tie, which was the correct move for both scum!Max and town!Max.

[Elephant Parade]

The new players seem to believe you, but… care to explain why?

1. I just get bad vibes from you, man
2. Zero interaction with Quarque up until RVS 2
3. Shot a townie for a reason I think is silly
4. I'm generally not following your logic

I don't see Maxine being groupscum because I don't see an initially engaged player leaving their scumbudd(y/ies) to hang like that for the last 36 hours of the game. They're probably town or a third party.

I agree that it probably isn't sofanthiel either given how hard Quarque pushed them early and how sofanthiel pushed them back, but after last game I'm wary of giving votes too much weight.

TCk seems innocent though they could be a 3P

I am currently leaning toward lynching Crystallizedmire over you

@CM: Were you shot?

Yes.

Actually, a second question, CM: Near as I can tell, you hopped on every single wagon except Quarque's. In fact, I don't believe you interacted with Quarque at all. Why was that?

I don't think I was on Snowkiller's bandwagon but I did volunteer to kill them. The reason I didn't interact with Quarque is because they never struck me as suspicious. Sure, they made a suspicious attack on Sofanthiel but I thought that was a genuine mistake.

So you didn't say anything even as someone you thought was innocent was lynched?

[Crystalizedmire]

@CM: Were you shot?

Yes.

Actually, a second question, CM: Near as I can tell, you hopped on every single wagon except Quarque's. In fact, I don't believe you interacted with Quarque at all. Why was that?

I don't think I was on Snowkiller's bandwagon but I did volunteer to kill them. The reason I didn't interact with Quarque is because they never struck me as suspicious. Sure, they made a suspicious attack on Sofanthiel but I thought that was a genuine mistake.

So you didn't say anything even as someone you thought was innocent was lynched?

While I didn't read Quarque as scum, I also wouldn't be surprised if they were. At the time Maxine looked more suspicious due to their lack of engagement so I voted them instead of Quarque.