Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[sofanthiel]

Why don't you ever seem to suspect me?

You always seemed to jumped immediately at NJW or EP, but never me, why?

1. This might seem very arbitrary, but being confused about your role gave you a lot of leverage in my eyes.  This is something both I and, presumably, Snowkiller went through in some capacity, but that wouldn't be enough to ignore my accumulative suspicion of you that's been building up.

CK described the exact thought process I went through before I even mentioned the fact that I did.  I doubt any scum, especially a newer player, would, or even could, do something that skilled based on the premise of the strategy itself and, most importantly, the specific wording quoted in my previous reply.

2. I believe I already answered the first part of this question here; I just never suspected you strongly enough to vote, especially early on.

Question #1: Why are you talking like a robot now?
Question #2: How mad were you yesterday when you shot me and I didn't die?
Question #3: This is less a question than a concurrence, but seriously, how did you conclude that TCk was scum without even questioning them today?  Are you seriously 100% confident in that?

Answer #1: Maybe I AM?
Answer #2: Would assuming you implied you were bluffing yesterday when you claimed to get shot even make sense as the one that did the shooting?  Not to mention, I distrusted that claim yesterday.
Answer #3: I operate under the assumption that it is still technically possible for either of you to be mafia, so I'm voting for the person I consider it more likely to be, and your defense today was incredible.  I'm taking mental notes on most posts I read, and the scale has completely toppled over with that.

More questions: Why are you voting me at the end of the timeframe?

Are you like some kind of third party jester?

I am so confused by your actions the way you jump from people to people with arguments and then suddenly saying that I will be voted for no discernable reason?

1. I have to vote one of you.  If I don't, I will lose, as your options will be either a no-lynch or a sofa-lynch.  The former will lead to EP dying; you can figure the latter out yourself.
2. A third party is impossible, as scum would, in that case, equal town, meaning we already lost.
3. See above for reasons.

After putting even more thought into this important decision, I've chosen to commit to CK.  Farewell!

[Elephant Parade]

Guess what: I'm not scum

[Elephant Parade]

yep, maybe the jester one can be taken as jokingly, but it's more for me questioning whether they wanted to be lynched something

Then I have no choice but to vote you. Sofanthiel has dropped more red flags than a department store the week before Canada Day, but your last round of questions was complete nonsense. The Canadian Kitten.

[The Canadian kitten]

EP: I assume that when you see this, are you going to hammer?

I would still find third party if they were town orientated

fuck

[Elephant Parade]

Were you actually town? Nooooooooooo

[EuchreJack]

Game Over. The Rebellion has LOST.  All hail the Emperor!

[EuchreJack]

Night Actions:

Spoiler: Night 1 (click to show/hide)

Sofanthiel: No action
Maximum Spin: Shoot Crystalizedmire
The Canadian Kitten: Shoot NJW2000
Elephant Parade: No action
Crystalizedmire: Throw grenade at Snowkiller and Maxine
NJW2000: Scoped Shoot Maximum Spin
Maxine: Shoot Maximum Spin
Snowkiller: No Action

People Killed:
Crystalizedmire – Armor destroyed, still alive
NJW2000 – Armor destroyed, still alive
Snowkiller – Armor destroyed, still alive
Maxine – Armor destroyed, still alive
Maximum Spin – Very dead

Spoiler: Night 2 (click to show/hide)

Elephant Parade: No action
Crystalizedmire: Shoot Maxine
The Canadian Kitten: Blow up Elephant Parade with Improvised Explosives
NJW2000: Shoot CrystallizedMire
Sofanthiel: Shoot Maxine
Maxine: No actions remaining

Maxine: Was shot twice! Is now dead!

Elephant Parade: Your Stormtrooper Armor is destroyed! Thankfully, you’re still important enough to have an extra life!

CrystallizedMire: You were shot. With no armor, you are now dead.  But hey, at least Maxine is also dead!

The Canadian Kitten: You blew up Elephant Parade, but he’s still alive!

NJW2000: You have shot CrystallizedMire. He is now dead.

Sofanthiel: You have shot Maxine! Maxine is now dead.

Survivors of Night 2:
NJW2000
Elephant Parade
The Canadian Kitten
Sofanthiel

Spoiler: Night 3 (click to show/hide)

A mostly quiet night…

The Canadian Kitten Blows Up Elephant Parade
Elephant Parade does No Action
sofanthiel has No Action left

The Canadian Kitten successfully Blows Up Elephant Parade, but he’s still alive!

Elephant Parade evades death yet again, yet is reminded that even the best Stormtrooper Cadets sometimes die in Basic Training. And with that, you feel your Plot Armor is gone…

sofanthiel has a quiet night polishing his still-intact Stormtrooper Armor.

[EuchreJack]

Spoiler: Raw Roles List (click to show/hide)

Rule: Can only use ONE Night ability, unless that ability is an AUTO.

Stormtroopers (Town)
3 x Standard Stormtrooper Cadet:
(Night, 1-shot) E-11 medium blaster rifle: Kill 1 target player on 1 night.
(Night, 1-shot, Auto) Stormtrooper Armor: Prevent one death

Prepared Stormtrooper Cadet:
(Night, 1-shot) E-11 medium blaster rifle: Kill 1 target player on 1 night.
(Night, 1-shot, Auto) Stormtrooper Armor: Prevent one death
(Night, 1-shot) Grenade: Kill 2 target players on 1 night.

Named Stormtrooper Cadet:
(Night, 1-shot) E-11 medium blaster rifle: Kill 1 target player on 1 night.
(Night, 1-shot, Auto) Stormtrooper Armor: Prevent one death
(Night, 1-shot, Auto) Plot Armor: Prevent one death

Supplied Stormtrooper Cadet:
(Night, 1-shot) E-11 medium blaster rifle: Kill 1 target player on 1 night.
(Night, 1-shot, Auto) Stormtrooper Armor: Prevent one death
(Night, 1-shot) Supplies: Replenish 1 player's E-11 medium blaster rifle ability (can self target).

Accurate Stormtrooper Cadet:
(Night, 1-shot) E-11 medium blaster rifle: Kill 1 target player on 1 night.
(Night, 1-shot, Auto) Stormtrooper Armor: Prevent one death
(Night, 1-shot) Scoped Shot: Kill 1 target player on 1 night. Stormtrooper Armor has no effect on this ability.

Rebels (Mafia)

Smuggler:
(Night, 1-shot) E-11 medium blaster rifle: Kill 1 target player on 1 night.
(Night, 1-shot, Auto) Stormtrooper Armor: Prevent one death
(Night, 1-shot) Smuggling myself: You can not participate in the Night Stage. No actions can be performed upon you, and you can perform no actions.

Jedi:
(Night, 1-shot) E-11 medium blaster rifle: Kill 1 target player on 1 night.
(Night, 1-shot, Auto) Stormtrooper Armor: Prevent one death
(Night, 1-shot) Lightsaber deflect: Choose 1 target player on 1 night. If you are targetted with an ability that can kill, that ability will target that other player instead.
(Night, 1-shot) Lightsaber slash: Kill 1 target player on 1 night. Stormtrooper Armor has no effect on this ability.
(Reconned Ability) The Jedi died a long time ago: On death, you appear as a Rebel Smuggler [I accidentally said Quarque's role was Rebel Smuggler. I figured correcting that fact that might hurt the Mafia team who were already down one player after Day 1, so I kept it to myself.]

Shared Mafia Nightkill: Improvised Explosives: Kill one player per night, Player using this ability can NOT use it in conjunction with any other Night ability, unless that ability is an AUTO.



NJW2000 - Accurate Stormtrooper Cadet OK
Quarque - Jedi
sofanthiel -  Standard Stormtrooper Cadet OK
Maxine -  Standard Stormtrooper Cadet OK
Snowkiller -  Standard Stormtrooper Cadet OK
Elephant Parade - Named Stormtrooper Cadet OK
The Canadian kitten - Smuggler
Crystalizedmire - Prepared Stormtrooper Cadet OK
Maximum Spin - Supplied Stormtrooper Cadet OK

Subject: Stormtrooper Academy Forum Game

Role PM:

You have joined the few, the proud, the Imperial Stormtroopers. But you’re still a cadet.
For you, the blind loyalty to the Emperor is absolute. It is still possible one or more of your fellow cadets has...rebellious thoughts.

You will kill them.

For the Emperor!

Standard Stormtrooper Cadet (Town):
(Night, 1-shot) E-11 medium blaster rifle: Kill 1 target player on 1 night.
(Night, 1-shot, Auto) Stormtrooper Armor: Prevent one death

Win Condition: Kill all the Rebels (Mafia)

Rule: Can only use ONE Night ability, unless that ability is an AUTO.

Role PM:

You have joined the few, the proud, the Imperial Stormtroopers. But you’re still a cadet.
For you, the blind loyalty to the Emperor is absolute. It is still possible one or more of your fellow cadets has...rebellious thoughts.

You will kill them.

For the Emperor!

Prepared Stormtrooper Cadet (Town):
(Night, 1-shot) E-11 medium blaster rifle: Kill 1 target player on 1 night.
(Night, 1-shot, Auto) Stormtrooper Armor: Prevent one death
(Night, 1-shot) Grenade: Kill 2 target players on 1 night.

Win Condition: Kill all the Rebels (Mafia)

Rule: Can only use ONE Night ability, unless that ability is an AUTO.

Role PM:

You have joined the few, the proud, the Imperial Stormtroopers. But you’re still a cadet.
For you, the blind loyalty to the Emperor is absolute. It is still possible one or more of your fellow cadets has...rebellious thoughts.

You will kill them.

For the Emperor!

Named Stormtrooper Cadet (Town):
(Night, 1-shot) E-11 medium blaster rifle: Kill 1 target player on 1 night.
(Night, 1-shot, Auto) Stormtrooper Armor: Prevent one death
(Night, 1-shot, Auto) Plot Armor: Prevent one death

Win Condition: Kill all the Rebels (Mafia)

Rule: Can only use ONE Night ability, unless that ability is an AUTO.

Role PM:

You have joined the few, the proud, the Imperial Stormtroopers. But you’re still a cadet.
For you, the blind loyalty to the Emperor is absolute. It is still possible one or more of your fellow cadets has...rebellious thoughts.

You will kill them.

For the Emperor!

Supplied Stormtrooper Cadet (Town):
(Night, 1-shot) E-11 medium blaster rifle: Kill 1 target player on 1 night.
(Night, 1-shot, Auto) Stormtrooper Armor: Prevent one death
(Night, 1-shot) Supplies: Replenish 1 player's E-11 medium blaster rifle ability (can self target).

Win Condition: Kill all the Rebels (Mafia)

Rule: Can only use ONE Night ability, unless that ability is an AUTO.

Role PM:

You have joined the few, the proud, the Imperial Stormtroopers. But you’re still a cadet.
For you, the blind loyalty to the Emperor is absolute. It is still possible one or more of your fellow cadets has...rebellious thoughts.

You will kill them.

For the Emperor!

Accurate Stormtrooper Cadet (Town):
(Night, 1-shot) E-11 medium blaster rifle: Kill 1 target player on 1 night.
(Night, 1-shot, Auto) Stormtrooper Armor: Prevent one death
(Night, 1-shot) Scoped Shot: Kill 1 target player on 1 night. Stormtrooper Armor has no effect on this ability.

Win Condition: Kill all the Rebels (Mafia)

Rule: Can only use ONE Night ability, unless that ability is an AUTO.

[NJW2000]

Wow. Well played all, sorry about killing town all those times, really not my finest hour.

Well, sorry for the ones that weren’t Snowkiller.

Annoying as it is when someone with a different idea of the game plays well, EP was far and away the MVP that game. Very strong play from sofanthiel too, nice to see a (newer?) player that focused on aggressively find scum.

The scum team had a very hard job and CK made some creative plays - shooting EP on night 2 to leave a larger pool of suspect players was especially smart… game really came down to the wire, as sofa couldn’t have survived two shots. Perhaps EP would have shot me to reduce it to 3 players D3 if he hadn’t had the armour, but still, incredibly close.

Fake scumhunting is much harder than real scumhunting, so was very good to see Quarque really going for it, even though that made his life harder. D1 could have gone very differently.

Congrats to the rest of the town - very strong showing from the new players, which made this whole thing that much more embarrassing for me.

Thanks for running it, EJ. Was good fun, and nice to have a simple, scumhunting focused setup that still feels very different mechanically… I’d like to see AF become a bay12 tradition of some sort.

[The Canadian kitten]

Was extremely stressful playing as scum and trying to pretend that I was an absolutely clueless town.

Hope I didn't drive you too nuts NJW?

[NJW2000]

Was extremely stressful playing as scum and trying to pretend that I was an absolutely clueless town.

Hope I didn't drive you too nuts NJW?

Not at all! And definitely not something you should apologise for as mafia.

[EuchreJack]

Thanks for the kind words NJW2000.
The Armed Forces setup is interesting, and it's getting better each time. It's still an open question whether Mafia was balanced with this setup, since they lost the greater half of their killing power before the First Night. I'll have to remember that in the future.

[Snowkiller]

Wait, we took an L? Aw man, come on bruh. LOCK IN!

[EuchreJack]

Wait, we took an L? Aw man, come on bruh. LOCK IN!

You won

[sofanthiel]

Good game, everyone!

Back from my short trip, and I'm so glad I made the right decision; losing the game for everyone else due to having to depart early would've sucked, haha.