All I can do is speculate. Something's wrong here, and I'm probably not going to figure it all out, but I'm just gonna postulate.
I'm gonna make the assumptions that Jim Groovester definitely Recruited NQT Day/Night 1. Why? Not sure. Doesn't matter.
I think that NQT used a superkill because he thought he would be Roleblocked by me Night 2. He seems to think Egan_BW was some type of Cult Leader? Not entirely sure. Also not sure why he didn't kill me. NQT is the weirdest part of this game.
Hypothesis time.
Hypothesis: NJW2000 started as a Cult Leader.
It's entirely possible that NJW was a Cult Leader Day 1 and attempted to Recruit Jim Night 1, but because he was Cult, it failed.
Night 2, NJW2000 attempts to recruit Maximum Spin, but is bussed into himself and EuchreJack. I am not sure that EuchreJack was Recruited on a previous Night.
This means there are 3 Cult Players (I can't get TricMagic to ask about my passive, so this is just a guess. It may not be possible.)
Hypothesis: Toaster started as a Cult Leader.
Toaster started as a Cult Leader, and was unable to Recruit Night 1. Why? Was I targeted by Toaster Night 1?
Night 2, Toaster attempts to recruit Maximum Spin, but is bussed into NJW2000 and EuchreJack.
This means there are 4 Cult Players.
Hypothesis: Maximum Spin started as a Cult Leader.
Maximum Spin is lying about a number of things, so this is not entirely out of the realm of possibility.
Maximum Spin was somehow able to double target his recruiting on Night 2, OR the Recruiting was staggered, and there's just a lot of lying happening. There's not a lot to think about on this one, because it's really just about thinking if everyone else is telling the truth.
This means there are 4 Cult Players.
I don't really see any other possible hypotheses. Suspecting ToonyMan requires me to believe that Toony and Max are on a team, which is not possible if I believe that NJW2000 and EuchreJack are both Cult (Though, this is a workable solution if only one of them is Cult, which is proooobably NJW2000, somehow.) And in that particular case, it doesn't really matter, since my chances to win are too low. So, even if that is the truth, I have to ignore it.