This is a level headed post that I lilke.
If notquitethere is scum with either ToonyMan or hector13 he has to be gambling pretty hard with their lives or has ruthlessly decided to bus them. It's possible but seems unlikely.
Why would a mafia medium even…
Bro whatever
There are many examples of games with mafia mediums so it's not unreasonable to raise it as a possibility and to ask whether your behavior is more or less fitting of a scum medium.
Given that you're relaying derogatory information from dead chat to here regarding hector13, I think at bare minimum it's unlikely you're scum partners with hector13, but generally I'd say you're probably not scum.
Fallacy:
(That would eliminate the Lenglon-hector13 scumteam, I think. But since scum are most motivated to kill other scum, I don't think that's a good idea at this time If I were you I'd vote either Jim or Toony.)
Getting sent mixed messages
What do
you want to do, Knightwing64? You're not a dead chat telephone, you're a person, and you don't have to be weak to social pressures, and you can make decisions on your own.
'i accidentally the whole toaster'
:|
Jim needs to be on the wagon though and Jim won’t vote.
You did this.
Egan, my dude, you’re the only person I’m sure I can trust; what are your thoughts on the game?
Jim and Max killed my sibling and therefore they must die. Either as scum or for the same reason they killed Fallacy.
Come on, now, an eye for an eye leaves the whole world blind.
Being spiteful is not productive.
Personally, I would rather eliminate the player that was caught lying.
I would too.
Why do people suspect ToonyMan? Is there anything besides the scum results on him? People have come out swinging against him because of the inspect result against him but I haven't seen much discussion about ToonyMan being suspicious prior to that event.
So as far as I'm aware, it's
guilty inspect result
compared to hector13, who
was tracked to Toaster, who was night killed
initially claimed to steal Toaster's vote
was counterclaimed by Toaster from dead chat
changed his story to accidentally killing Toaster
On one side is a night game result, which I've been harping about being misleading, and on the other side there are claims and counterclaims which hector13 owned up to, which there is no uncertainty about.
I don't think there should be any question that hector13's circumstances are more damning than ToonyMan's. I think hector13 is the much better lynch today and I would vote him if I wasn't going to suffer CONSEQUENCES because of it. I suspect the people holding out for a ToonyMan lynch have ulterior motives. Spite most obviously, but there's also strange notions about the utility of choosing which scum team we can lynch from as if we have perfect information to make that choice as well as perfect expectation that the mafia teams will shoot each other instead of us. Other cases like the waffling from A_Curious_Cat and Knightwing64's vote remaining on ToonyMan are confusing to me as well.
Author
Topic: BYOR 16: Game Over. Mafia 2 Wins. (Read 50261 times)